Autopsy AFL 2023 Round 5 Gather Round - Pies v Saints Sun April 16th 4:50pm AEST (AO)

[adammania9]

New found respect for CEY.

View attachment 1662837

Who is Cam Ellis-Yolmen?

 

[ChristianBoy]

Membrey was available.

Granted King is a big out and so is Steele, but I think Membrey is comfortably covered by Collingwoods defence.

Pies were missing Cameron and Cox in ruck against Marshall, in which Frampton held up admirably, and De Goey who on he’s day can torch any side. So apples for apples, the better side definitely won I think there’s no arguments from anyone here, Saints have shown significant gains and I’m sure all there supporters are enjoying the ride at the moment, if maybe only short and sweet, still enjoyable.

Membrey 3 goals last game v Collingwood.

 

[beerbandit]

Membrey 3 goals last game v Collingwood.

Rd 1 last year???

 

[adammania9]

Membrey 3 goals last game v Collingwood.

Missing the point champ. Membrey was available and not selected. Clearly they rate Caminiti higher. Now they can see who is better while Caminiti has a 4 week holiday

 

[beerbandit]

Missing the point champ. Membrey was available and not selected. Clearly they rate Caminiti higher. Now they can see who is better while Caminiti has a 4 week holiday

Nah 5 or 6 for the dog act

 

[PieLebo87]

Membrey 3 goals last game v Collingwood.

Round 1 2022 Brownlow votes vs StK:
3 votes - Pat Lipinski
2 votes - Jordan De Goey

Am I doing it right?

 

[beerbandit]

Round 1 2022 Brownlow votes vs StK:
3 votes - Pat Lipinski
2 votes - Jordan De Goey

Am I doing it right?

Very good Leb, this bloke is always obsessed with Pies match day threads.

 

[puppy_dog7]

Missing the point champ. Membrey was available and not selected. Clearly they rate Caminiti higher. Now they can see who is better while Caminiti has a 4 week holiday

 

[ChristianBoy]

Round 1 2022 Brownlow votes vs StK:
3 votes - Pat Lipinski
2 votes - Jordan De Goey

Am I doing it right?

No one is saying they weren’t missed. One poster is claiming Membrey isn’t of value which is not true.

 

[Apex36]

The only one throwing cheap shots was Murphy while Caminiti had his back turned. Go watch the vision on First Crack. They were all in agreeance that it was Murphy who started it and If he doesn’t drop at the knees he doesn’t get concussed and it’s a non discussion. No way it’s more than 2 weeks.

Once again, it doesn’t matter who started it, that’s not something that the MRO or the tribunal will care about. The only thing they care about is:
Was it high contact?
Was it intentional?
Was the contact severe?

Given the answer to those questions are yes, yes, and severe, he doesn’t get less than 4.

 

[puppy_dog7]

Once again, it doesn’t matter who started it, that’s not something that the MRO or the tribunal will care about. The only thing they care about is:
Was it high contact?
Was it intentional?
Was the contact severe?

Given the answer to those questions are yes, yes, and severe, he doesn’t get less than 4.

Well it’s not severe. Medium at best

 

[ChristianBoy]

Missing the point champ. Membrey was available and not selected. Clearly they rate Caminiti higher. Now they can see who is better while Caminiti has a 4 week holiday

Yes of course only one of the best lead up forwards in the game.

 

[Kipz]

Who is Cam Ellis-Yolmen?

An anti vaxxer that couldn't manage 50 games in 10 years at AFL level who now plays for a side that won 1 game last year and lost 17 in a farmers league. An opinion you should respect

 

[iBeng]

good for you. Enjoy!!

Your the one on here banging on about Nick Daicos champ, enjoy Neales game, he played well, as did Nick tonight.

Now jog on back to the Lions board.

Pretty sure this is the public AFL board, not your private Collingwood one?

 

[Apex36]

Well it’s not severe. Medium at best

Lol, when a player gets concussed from a hit they always grade it as severe, you numpty.

 

[MagpieJo]

Congrats on your April premiership Collingwood.

It's a marathon and not a sprint.

We will keep our powder dry for September.

See you there and we will be at full strength then.

Salty as!

we will be full strength too!

gottasay loved the librarian onthe goal line touch again, what a glorious October day that was last time!

 

[BringFevBack2021]

“Neutral” observer from a team we are playing next week

Point taken, but I am genuinely pretty impartial on here. The guys concussed right now due to a hit off the ball, this is exactly the time where I’d expect to see a hefty suspension.

Genuinely don’t think it’ll make a difference, I’m not confident at all that we’ll beat you.

 

[beerbandit]

Pretty sure this is the public AFL board, not your private Collingwood one?

So what’s your purpose on this thread apart from obvious trolling?

 

[puppy_dog7]

Lol, when a player gets concussed from a hit they always grade it as severe, you numpty.

He ran off the ground mouthing off. If he had a fractured jaw then yes fair enough, grade it as severe. But what happened does not constitute severe you flipping bellend.

 

[Rooeys shorts]

I wish it worked that way, because Cripps would flip 90% of AFL midfielders on their heads - but it doesn’t

We play AFL, not Ice Hockey

So the "dog shot with nothing to do with play" you mentioned was Murphy who threw the first strike for no reason yeah? And unfortunately for him his glass jaw couldn't handle the retaliation...

 

[MagpieJo]

42 touches looks great from a distance, 6 contested and 1 tackle looks odd up close.

Just means he leaves em standing!

 

[MagpieJo]

Ross Lyon was laughing in the last quarter, we weren't even trying that hard and we still nearly beat Collingwood with that last quarter comeback.

Tonight was a fact finding mission for us, we didn't care that much if we won or lost, but we found out that we can beat Collingwood when it counts.

3 goals after knocking out one of our main defenders, hmm,

 

[beerbandit]

He ran off the ground mouthing off. If he had a fractured jaw then yes fair enough, grade it as severe. But what happened does not constitute severe you bellend.

It does mate when it concerns concussion.

Nathan Broad got 3 for a tackle when the ball was in play, purely through the bloke being concussed.

This is a concussion with an elbow to the head 50m from the play.

He will get minimum 4, more likely 5 or 6. I understand your frustration but this is fact and this is AFL in 2023, head is out of bounds especially when it comes to concussion

 

[Apex36]

He ran off the ground mouthing off. If he had a fractured jaw then yes fair enough, grade it as severe. But what happened does not constitute severe you bellend.

I’m not sure why it’s so difficult for you to understand AFL guidelines, but I’ll repeat it. Any hit from a player that causes concussion is graded as severe impact. It’s not something that’s up for debate, despite you thinking it is.

 

[puppy_dog7]

3 goals after knocking out one of our main defenders, hmm,

Main defenders?! Haha what a stretch. If Murphy didn’t have a glass jaw know one would know who the weak prick was.