Autopsy AFL 2023 Round 5 Gather Round - Pies v Saints Sun April 16th 4:50pm AEST (AO)

[Mat Mann]

Yep and Sharman too.

Saying that... Yep it's a 23 game season.

I just think Freos narrow loss to the saints and kangaroos will bite Freo in the Kim Kardashian or in the bum when the 2023 season is over .

I think Freo will finish 10th to 12th sadly

so you fully expected to be embarrassed by Adelaide?

 

[Mat Mann]

Murphy is as tough as they come.

Dog act, off the ball, elbow to the head.

With the big focus on concussions, I’d say he’s looking at 5-6 weeks

dog act would be hitting someone from behind.

hint, that isnt Caminiti's arm in his own face

 

[PieLebo87]

BOG goes to Nick Daicos. 42 possessions and almost 900 metres gained. Instrumental in constantly driving Collingwood forward all night.

2 votes to Wilkie. 24 possessions, 11 marks and 10 intercepts. The guy would be in the AA on current form.

1 vote to Crouch. 33 possessions, 9 clearances and 2 goals. Such an underrated footballer.

 

[Kipz]

St Kilda's last few minutes reminded me of Jack Riewoldt in his prime. Turning it on in junk time when the game was over and taking himself out of the media spotlight.

 

[ChristianBoy]

Omg.
I’m absolutely sorry.

You are 100% correct in that saints will be confident next time because of Membrey & king.

Is that right?

Saints are def hard done by because pies are at full strength.

You were talking about Ross Lyons game plan. StKildas 3 tall forwards had a combined total of 19 games going into tonight.

I’m sure Max King and Membrey will be more than helpful.

 

[Apex36]

He hit Caminiti in the neck while he wasn’t looking. What a *ing hero. Real tough. And then dropped at the knees when Caminiti retaliated.
1-2 weeks is all it deserves take ya black and white glasses off mate

Caminti snotted a bloke in the chin and gave him a concussion. Regardless of what happened beforehand, he’s not going to get away with only 1-2 weeks.

Maybe take off your own teams glasses before you accuse others of bias.

 

[MickG88]

I would have to disagree and give Wilkie best on for stopping most of Collingwoods forward entries and then Diacos also thought Pendles was pretty good tonight, couldn't tell he's over 30.

BOG goes to Nick Daicos. 42 possessions and almost 900 metres gained. Instrumental in constantly driving Collingwood forward all night.

2 votes to Wilkie. 24 possessions, 11 marks and 10 intercepts. The guy would be in the AA on current form.

1 vote to Crouch. 33 possessions, 9 clearances and 2 goals. Such an underrated footballer.

 

[beerbandit]

View attachment 1662803
dog act would be hitting someone from behind.

hint, that isnt Caminiti's arm in his own face

Oh my….

You should offer to act as KC for the club

 

[puppy_dog7]

Caminti snotted a bloke in the chin and gave him a concussion. Regardless of what happened beforehand, he’s not going to get away with only 1-2 weeks.

Maybe take off your own teams glasses before you accuse others of bias.

The only one throwing cheap shots was Murphy while Caminiti had his back turned. Go watch the vision on First Crack. They were all in agreeance that it was Murphy who started it and If he doesn’t drop at the knees he doesn’t get concussed and it’s a non discussion. No way it’s more than 2 weeks.

 

[Mat Mann]

Oh my….

You should offer to act as KC for the club

KC?

no doubt we'll use a QC, ours is crap tho and hasn't won a hearing since we won in '66

 

[TheVillageIdiot7]

You were talking about Ross Lyons game plan. StKildas 3 tall forwards had a combined total of 19 games going into tonight.

I’m sure Max King and Membrey will be more than helpful.

No. I was responding to you saying saints would be better with Membrey and king.

You challenged me when I said it was 6 points disguised as 30.

Saints will win their fair share, but ain’t winning it with that gamestyle.

 

[beerbandit]

KC?

no doubt we'll use a QC, ours is crap tho and hasn't won a hearing since we won in '66

no wonder your photo was grainy and hard to see, you’re still living in 2022.

If you don’t know that QC’s are now KCs then you have been living under a rock unfortunately

 

[Freomaniac]

so you fully expected to be embarrassed by Adelaide?

Last week.... Yep.. crows have finally found a decent game plan to mask their weakness in the midfield

 

[ChristianBoy]

No. I was responding to you saying saints would be better with Membrey and king.

You challenged me when I said it was 6 points disguised as 30.

Saints will win their fair share, but ain’t winning it with that gamestyle.

Ok and I’m saying with their best two forwards they’ll be better.

 

[Mat Mann]

no wonder your photo was grainy and hard to see, you’re still living in 2022.

If you don’t know that QC’s are now KCs then you have been living under a rock unfortunately

in mt defense I reckon Charles like wearing women's clothes

 

[iBeng]

His kicks are hardly chips

By my math each disposal he got was a touch over 20m on average?

 

[iBeng]

Jealous is a curse my man

I'll console myself with Neales minor 37 touches I guess. Probably didn't even get many contested.

 

[Fadge]

By my math each disposal he got was a touch over 20m on average?

Your maths might be OK, but you've just shown you have zero understanding of the statistic and therefore the game...

 

[ChristianBoy]

By my math each disposal he got was a touch over 20m on average?

Kicked out from fullback 8 times and played on all 8. There’s 300 meters there.

 

[TheVillageIdiot7]

Ok and I’m saying with their best two forwards they’ll be better.

So you’re walking back your original statement?

All good mate.
When you don’t follow either team, you can make some calls that are massively wrong. All good.

 

[beerbandit]

Ok and I’m saying with their best two forwards they’ll be better.

Membrey was available.

Granted King is a big out and so is Steele, but I think Membrey is comfortably covered by Collingwoods defence.

Pies were missing Cameron and Cox in ruck against Marshall, in which Frampton held up admirably, and De Goey who on he’s day can torch any side. So apples for apples, the better side definitely won I think there’s no arguments from anyone here, Saints have shown significant gains and I’m sure all there supporters are enjoying the ride at the moment, if maybe only short and sweet, still enjoyable.

 

[BringFevBack2021]

Start s**t get hit

I wish it worked that way, because Cripps would flip 90% of AFL midfielders on their heads - but it doesn’t

We play AFL, not Ice Hockey

 

[puppy_dog7]

New found respect for CEY.

 

[Diehard Saint]

He concussed him off the ball, doesn’t matter who initiated it. He hit Murphy high and dropped him. I don’t disagree that Murphy dogged him first but Murphys hit vs Caminitis are worlds apart.

One is a free kick, one is for the tribunal to decide if it’s 4 or 5 weeks.

No Black and White glasses here, just common sense from a neutral observer

“Neutral” observer from a team we are playing next week

 

[beerbandit]

I'll console myself with Neales minor 37 touches I guess. Probably didn't even get many contested.

good for you. Enjoy!!

Your the one on here banging on about Nick Daicos champ, enjoy Neales game, he played well, as did Nick tonight.

Now jog on back to the Lions board.