AFL Dream Team 2008

[Swan4Brownlow]

Does anyone else think Brock McLean is a steal at his price? 2007 he had a poor year with injury...nothing semed to go right and he still averaged a respectable 74.

In 2008 I think he'll get back to his 06 form and average 90+

He's a bit fo a risk but if he shows some good rpeseason form then he could be very good value. Also wat do people think of Mundy and Gilmore from Freo?

 

[54Dogs]

He's a bit fo a risk but if he shows some good rpeseason form then he could be very good value. Also wat do people think of Mundy and Gilmore from Freo?

Love Gilmore, with the 2 monsters in the ruck his role is uncertain but if they do play him in that roving midfield role he may score huge.

 

[Hawks 08]

Why hasn't Zac Dawson been mentoned much around this thread. He is a must.

 

[Affidavit]

Does anyone else think Brock McLean is a steal at his price? 2007 he had a poor year with injury...nothing semed to go right and he still averaged a respectable 74.

In 2008 I think he'll get back to his 06 form and average 90+

I think it will be the opposite way as TJ is gone now, Brock should get the number 1 tag, which means he should score lower this year.

Just my 2cents

 

[SAINTS 4 07 FLAG]

Why hasn't Zac Dawson been mentoned much around this thread. He is a must.

not in a million years for me

 

[Beau_Waters for PM]

A few player v player here, all roughly the same price
S.Johnson v Chapman
Mattner v Symes
McNamara v Palmer
N.Jones v Gibbs + 50k
Mundy v M.Johnson
Deledio v D.Thomas
Vince v Jetta

He's a bit fo a risk but if he shows some good rpeseason form then he could be very good value. Also wat do people think of Mundy and Gilmore from Freo?

Get them both.

Why hasn't Zac Dawson been mentoned much around this thread. He is a must.

Who?

 

[Swan4Brownlow]

Which backline is a better option

A
Shaw
Newman
P Burgoyne
Mattner
Mundy
Symes
Pfeiffer

or

B
Shaw
Newman
P Burgoyne
Staker
Johncock
B Jones
Lonergan

 

[ohanlon14]

Which backline is a better option

A
Shaw
Newman
P Burgoyne
Mattner
Mundy
Symes
Pfeiffer

or

B
Shaw
Newman
P Burgoyne
Staker
Johncock
B Jones
Lonergan

first one only slightly

 

[SAINTS 4 07 FLAG]

Which backline is a better option

A
Shaw
Newman
P Burgoyne
Mattner
Mundy
Symes
Pfeiffer

or

B
Shaw
Newman
P Burgoyne
Staker
Johncock
B Jones
Lonergan

A for me, had staker last year and wasn't any good, only because A has better players that you can switch if worst comes to worst

 

[SAINTS 4 07 FLAG]

How much st kilda playersd should i have in my team, i have 4 Riewoldt,Kosi,X Clarke and C.gardiner, should i get rid of any, they are all starters but im not sure who to get for gardiner? help appreciated

 

[54Dogs]

Why hasn't Zac Dawson been mentoned much around this thread. He is a must.

Not for me. Made that mistake with Cameron Wight last year thinking he couldn't stay at 130K. I was right, he dropped to 110K.

 

[boribori]

How much st kilda playersd should i have in my team, i have 4 Riewoldt,Kosi,X Clarke and C.gardiner, should i get rid of any, they are all starters but im not sure who to get for gardiner? help appreciated

xavier clarke LOL wow man your hard up for a player

 

[SAINTS 4 07 FLAG]

xavier clarke LOL wow man your hard up for a player

still early days, but he shone against richmond last weekend and your opinion is fine,i dont have all the confidence in him but this could be the year who proves all the doubters wrong. who knows

 

[SAINTS 4 07 FLAG]

jarrad mcveigh or chance bateman for Clarke

 

[banana_bus]

jarrad mcveigh or chance bateman for Clarke

2 of the more obscure choices i have seen posted on these forums.

Bateman could be a nice unique choice though, just too injury prone and inconsistent for mine.

 

[NT.Thunder]

How much st kilda playersd should i have in my team, i have 4 Riewoldt,Kosi,X Clarke and C.gardiner, should i get rid of any, they are all starters but im not sure who to get for gardiner? help appreciated

Clarke

Would prefer (if fit)

Griffen, Gibbs, Higgins, T. Clarke, wojinski, Schammer, Boak, etc, etc, etc, etc...

X did thye same to me last year, dont get suckered!!!

 

[54Dogs]

jarrad mcveigh or chance bateman for Clarke

Can't see the upside

Bateman - 77 / 76 / 68 last 3 years
McVeigh - 41 / 54 / 61

Unless they have a role change they don't seem to fit into any of the 3 categories (stars, improvers or rookies).

 

[SAINTS 4 07 FLAG]

Can't see the upside

Bateman - 77 / 76 / 68 last 3 years
McVeigh - 41 / 54 / 61

Unless they have a role change they don't seem to fit into any of the 3 categories (stars, improvers or rookies).

how come they only scored 3 times each ???

 

[andrew4443]

2 of the more obscure choices i have seen posted on these forums.

Bateman could be a nice unique choice though, just too injury prone and inconsistent for mine.

Thats because they are both sh1te, I would keep Clarke (assuming ur talking about Tim Clarke)

 

[banana_bus]

Thats because they are both sh1te, I would keep Clarke (assuming ur talking about Tim Clarke)

Im pretty sure he was talking X Clarke, and yes they are all shite.

 

[Walshy_The_Goat]

how come they only scored 3 times each ???

I think he was referring to both players averages over the past 3 seasons.

 

[SAINTS 4 07 FLAG]

lol my bad

 

[Swan4Brownlow]

Can some people please give me some feedback on this side. I think it is too unbalanced but am also unsure of whether it is worth balancing a side with players around the 300K mark or going for guns and youngsters. Any thoughts or criticism would be appreciated

Backs
Shaw
Newman
Symes
Burgoyne
Mattner
Staker
Pfeiffer

Selwood
Thompson

Centres
Hayes
Goodes
Cross
Stevens
Johnstone
Dyson

Palmer
Mackay

Rucks
Fraser
Simmonds

Bailey
Meesen

Fowards
Riewoldt
S Johnson
J Brown
Deledio
R Murphy
Porplyzia
Henderson

Rioli
Sellar

 

[54Dogs]

Can some people please give me some feedback on this side. I think it is too unbalanced but am also unsure of whether it is worth balancing a side with players around the 300K mark or going for guns and youngsters. Any thoughts or criticism would be appreciated

Backs
Shaw
Newman
Symes
Burgoyne
Mattner
Staker
Pfeiffer

Selwood
Thompson

Centres
Hayes
Goodes
Cross
Stevens
Johnstone
Dyson

Palmer
Mackay

Rucks
Fraser
Simmonds

Bailey
Meesen

Fowards
Riewoldt
S Johnson
J Brown
Deledio
R Murphy
Porplyzia
Henderson

Rioli
Sellar

Looks solid accross the board. The obvious risk is the 2 starting rookies in the 22. Dependant on Rd1 selections maybe Bird for MacKay and if you could fit Leuenberger or Hampson on the bench it may be safer. Also possibly Couglan in the midfield.

 

[SAINTS 4 07 FLAG]

Can some people please give me some feedback on this side. I think it is too unbalanced but am also unsure of whether it is worth balancing a side with players around the 300K mark or going for guns and youngsters. Any thoughts or criticism would be appreciated

Backs
Shaw
Newman
Symes
Burgoyne
Mattner
Staker not to keen, good reserve though
Pfeiffer

Selwood
Thompson

Centres
Hayes
Goodes
Cross
Stevens
Johnstone
Dyson i reckon downgrade a forward for dyson

Palmer
Mackay

Rucks
Fraser
Simmonds

Bailey Not the best reserves
Meesen

Fowards
Riewoldt All guns, Get rid of henderson i.m.o
S Johnson
J Brown
Deledio
R Murphy
Porplyzia
Henderson

Rioli
Sellar

good team except those few things i think