AFL Top 10 players

[Here It Is]

Been missing all year, but here's my list back for you to pull apart....


AFL TOP 10 PLAYERS
Leaderboard After Round 14
1. Chris Judd (Carlton) 87
2. Dane Swan (Collingwood) 86
3. Gary Ablett (Geelong) 74
4. Dean Cox (West Coast) 70
4. Nick Riewoldt (St Kilda) 70
6. Brad Sewell (Hawthorn) 68
7. Kane Cornes (Port Adelaide) 64
8. Steve Johnson (Geelong) 63
8. Sam Mitchell (Hawthorn) 63
8. Marc Murphy (Carlton) 63
8. Scott Pendlebury (Collingwood) 63

If the match is a draw - both teams’ best five players score 10,8,6,4,2
If the margin is 1-9 points - winners get 10,8,6,4,2; losers get 9,7,5,3,1
If the margin is 10-29 points - winners get 10,9,6,5,2; losers get 8,7,4,3,1
If the margin is 30-59 points - winners get 10,9,8,4,3; losers get 7,6,5,2,1
If the margin is 60-99 points - winners get 10,9,8,7,6; losers get 5,4,3,2,1
If the margin is 100+ points - winners get 10,9,8,7,6,5; losers get 4,3,2,1

 

[AG]

I understand you have a method for ranking the players but I think it is too hard to rate individual performances based on the teams winning margins. Still it requires effort on your behalf to rank them so I give you credit.

I would go:

1. Gary Ablett
2. Nick Riewoldt
3. Lenny Hayes
4. Leigh Montagna
5. Chris Judd
6. Steve Johnson
7. Joel Selwood
8. Nick Dal Santo
9. Brendan Goddard
10. Matthew Boyd / Dane Swan

Probably leaning towards the top 2 sides too much.

 

[skzm]

I thought was a pretty decent list then I saw

8. Marc Murphy (Carlton) 63

 

[The_JUDDERNAUT]

I thought was a pretty decent list then I saw

another ignorant opposition supporter. Murphy has been almost as good as Juddy this year...

 

[Undecide]

another ignorant opposition supporter. Murphy has been almost as good as Juddy this year...

Another ignorant opposition supporter, there is no way in hell Murphy is in the top 10 players in the comp

 

[AG]

Another ifnorant opposition supporter, there is no way in hell Murphy is in the top 10 players in the comp

He'd probably be top 20 though, so it's not that outrageous.

 

[johncitizen]

Leon Davis is probably rated just a tad better then Swan down at Magpieland. Just my opinion

 

[rose jam]

another ignorant opposition supporter. Murphy has been almost as good as Juddy this year...

just confirms how overhyped and overrated Judd is then

 

[Foley is a Gun #]

1. Chris Judd(Carlton)
2. Gary Ablett(Geelong)
3. Dean Cox(West Coast)
4. Lance Franklin(Hawthorn)
5. Jimmy Bartel(Geelong)
6. Nick Riewoldt(St Kilda)
7. Matthew Richardson(Richmond)
8. Simon Black(Brisbane)
9. Matthew Pavlich
10. Matthew Scarlett(Geelong)

 

[AG]

1. Chris Judd(Carlton)
2. Gary Ablett(Geelong)
3. Dean Cox(West Coast)
4. Lance Franklin(Hawthorn)
5. Jimmy Bartel(Geelong)
6. Nick Riewoldt(St Kilda)
7. Matthew Richardson(Richmond)
8. Simon Black(Brisbane)
9. Matthew Pavlich
10. Matthew Scarlett(Geelong)

What?? This is for this year, not overall.

 

[Foley is a Gun #]

Chris Judd Honours
Brownlow Medal 2004
Leigh Matthew Trophy 2006(AFL MVP)
AA 2004,2006,2008
Norm Smith 2005
John Nicholls Medal 2008(Carlton B&F)
West Coast B&F 2004,2006
AFLPA Best First Year Player 2002
I think that record speaks for itsef

Gary Ablett Honours
Leigh Matthews Trophy 2007,2008(AFL MVP)
AA 2007,2008
Geelong B&F 2007
Geelong Leading Goalkicker 2006
AFL Coaches Player of Year 2007,2008

I think Juddy takes the cake for best player in the league
followed closely by Gaz

 

[Foley is a Gun #]

What?? This is for this year, not overall.

oh i thought this was at their best
closely followed by Shane Tuck

 

[AG]

oh i thought this was at their best
closely followed by Shane Tuck

Funny.

 

[Foley is a Gun #]

Funny.

what this yr? is it funny

 

[AG]

what this yr? is it funny

Of course it is. He wouldn't be top 50.

 

[Rosstickle]

Chris Judd Honours
Brownlow Medal 2004
Leigh Matthew Trophy 2006(AFL MVP)
AA 2004,2006,2008
Norm Smith 2005
John Nicholls Medal 2008(Carlton B&F)
West Coast B&F 2004,2006
AFLPA Best First Year Player 2002
I think that record speaks for itsef

Gary Ablett Honours
Leigh Matthews Trophy 2007,2008(AFL MVP)
AA 2007,2008
Geelong B&F 2007
Geelong Leading Goalkicker 2006
AFL Coaches Player of Year 2007,2008

I think Juddy takes the cake for best player in the league
followed closely by Gaz

Ablett's grand final last year was better than Judd's in 05.Those accomplishments can be misleading. Ablett is a better player at present.

 

[Foley is a Gun #]

Of course it is. He wouldn't be top 50.

hahaha ur funny
ok... explain this
4th in the league for touches
1st for Contested Possesions
7 conseuctive 30+touch games

 

[AG]

hahaha ur funny
ok... explain this
4th in the league for touches
1st for Contested Possesions
7 conseuctive 30+touch games

I don't know his stats. If that's the case then I take back my original comment. I rate players on what I see, so maybe I am underrating him this season. You know what my Top 50 for this year is so maybe I should put him in but I don't think he has been better than any of the players I have in.

 

[Foley is a Gun #]

I don't know his stats. If that's the case then I take back my original comment. I rate players on what I see, so maybe I am underrating him this season. You know what my Top 50 for this year is so maybe I should put him in but I don't think he has been better than any of the players I have in.

hahaha andrew lovett r u shitting me?

 

[AG]

hahaha andrew lovett r u shitting me?

He is a match winner and has had a massive influence in a lot of games this season. Doesn't accumulate the amount of possessions as Tuck but he is twice as damaging with the ball in his hands. Nothing much better than seeing Lovett tear through the middle of the MCG.

 

[Foley is a Gun #]

Ablett's grand final last year was better than Judd's in 05.Those accomplishments can be misleading. Ablett is a better player at present.

i think thats bullshit, ablett wouldnt be as good at carlton and judd would be at Geelong. Judd has been better for longer, he has more impact and he earns his own footy, so shut up

 

[Rosstickle]

i think thats bullshit, ablett wouldnt be as good at carlton and judd would be at Geelong. Judd has been better for longer, he has more impact and he earns his own footy, so shut up

You have to keep in mind that Judd had Cousins, Kerr, Embley and Cox at West Coast. The argument that Ablett looks better because of his teammates is crap. Judd wasn't as good at West Coast as Gablett is at Geelong (some people will dispute that) with a very similar qualities of teamates.

 

[Foley is a Gun #]

You have to keep in mind that Judd had Cousins, Kerr, Embley and Cox at West Coast. The argument that Ablett looks better because of his teammates is crap. Judd wasn't as good at West Coast as Gablett is at Geelong (some people will dispute that) with a very similar qualities of teamates.

hahahah wateva mate thats crap
how can u say Ablett is better then Judd? haha

 

[Rosstickle]

hahahah wateva mate thats crap
how can u say Ablett is better then Judd? haha

Because I've watched them play, and think Ablett gets more of the ball and uses it far better. He's also more dangerous around goals.

And because he's won the last two MVP's and is widely considered to be the best in the league by the media, players and coaches.

 

[deledio7]

Foley is a gun = troll