Recruiting AFL Trade & Free Agency X - Club has elected not to fill list spot - Davey returning from injury?

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
Hmm Fair enough, It's not a bad deal, I just don't see Hopper as the guy we need, I rather a big body who is defense 1st like Dunks, Hopper wants to attack like Parish and Shiel.
I agree, but there doesn't seem to be any available now.
Personally I don't want Stocker or Dow types. Bytel would be OK, maybe we can get Kemp or Stephens out of Geelong.
 
I agree, the Cats reward for taking on the horrible contract is pick 7, they are no longer taking on a horrible contract.
we could make a play for 7.
Trade 22 into an F2 (dead pick for us anyway)
Trade both F2's & F3 into 7 & GCS 2nd.

Test the cats dedication to Bowes. they waiver, sounds like we were 2nd in line to Bowes anyway and the option is still there.
Only been reported they're willing to include 7.
I also don't see how a Cats F2 (30odd) for 7 gets approved by the AFL, let alone with a player like Bowes going back. If they tick that off, the system is broken.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

we could make a play for 7.
Trade 22 into an F2 (dead pick for us anyway)
Trade both F2's & F3 into 7 & GCS 2nd.

Test the cats dedication to Bowes. they waiver, sounds like we were 2nd in line to Bowes anyway and the option is still there.
Only been reported they're willing to include 7.
I also don't see how a Cats F2 (30odd) for 7 gets approved by the AFL, let alone with a player like Bowes going back. If they tick that off, the system is broken.

I like it, just to make em think haha...
22 to Port for F2
Our F2+Port F2 to Suns for 7+45+46
 
I still wouldn't do it, Hopper is a kick chaser like Parish, Merrett and Shiel, he's just bigger.


That's the important difference though.

If your kick chaser can absorb physical heat he can dictate how the game is played and free up the outside players so that you're not getting sucked into secondary clearance purgatory.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

I would think if the AFL want to tighten up on a club like Geelong taking advantage of it, then this. Must take on the original terms of the outgoing deal ie. 2 x $850k.

Smoothing out the deal makes it possible for a club that shouldn't be able to take advantage of a salary dump trade, to take advantage of it, whilst the whole point was supposed to be that poor performing clubs struggling to meet the cap floor would be able to do so.
Then they would just do:
850 850 200 200

Nothing stopping them. There should be, but there isn't.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top