- Banned
- #876
Didak has had a great year, but he hasn't been so dominant as to cancel out missing the last four games.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
All Australian Team 08
- Thread starter dorko1
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Didak has had a great year, but he hasn't been so dominant as to cancel out missing the last four games.
- Mar 15, 2006
- 8,419
- 6,557
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Missing the last 4 games of the season doesn't help his cause.
He's nothing more than a good/average player massively overrated due to Collingwood hyperbole.
He's Behind; Harvey, Stokes, N.Brown among others.
He's nowhere near good enough to make it as a midfeilder and doesn't kick enough goals to make it as a small forward.
Didak is ahead of Stokes. I could use that same sentence in regards to Stokes at Geelong. Nathan Brown has been underated this season, he has been back to his best.
Perjury is an offense punishable by living in Geelong.
LOL I know it is a bad choice. I just had a brain freeze about who else to put in at the time. Any ideas?
- Banned
- #882
C. Bolton – M. Scarlett – D. Morris
L. Hodge - N. Bock – C. Enright
M. Richardson – J. Bartel – B. Harvey
L. Franklin – M. Pavlich - R. Okeefe
P. Medhurst – B. Fevola – A. Didak
Foll: D. Cox – G. Ablett – A. Cooney
Int: J. Corey – D. Petrie – S. Mitchell - B. Kirk
L. Hodge - N. Bock – C. Enright
M. Richardson – J. Bartel – B. Harvey
L. Franklin – M. Pavlich - R. Okeefe
P. Medhurst – B. Fevola – A. Didak
Foll: D. Cox – G. Ablett – A. Cooney
Int: J. Corey – D. Petrie – S. Mitchell - B. Kirk
- Mar 15, 2006
- 8,419
- 6,557
- AFL Club
- Hawthorn
Apparently Didak is a lock!
richmond fanatic
Cancelled
- Banned
- #884
Deledios standing there waving his arms screaming 'What about me ?! '
Petrie not good enough first half of year, Enright doubtful. Judd has been doing a much better in an under role than Mitchell. Apart from that pretty good.
IN: Millburn, Sandilands, Judd
OUT: Petrie, Enright, Mitchel
Dunno if Hodge would get a gig either.
- Banned
- #887
Hodge is definately a must. He's been absolutely fantastic this season, and excelled in each position he's played - in the guts, moved up forward, or down back. If I was going to move him anywhere it'd be to the bench for the above reasons.
I prefer Sandilands to Petrie, but the fact that he's been very versatile has put him slightly ahead for mine.
Judd's had 6 'down'/poor games this season. In comparison Mitchell's only had 2, with another 2 being merely average. Don't know too much Kirk's season (as in if Judd's been better), aside from the fact most people on here have been putting him in their list. I do however know Mitchell's been magnificent as per usual.
Deledio has been a bit stiff I think.
I think petrie was good all year he just gets recognised because of friday night footy against the pies. We've been on foxtel most of the year which suits me live footy no adds but the general public underestimate us.
Anyhow at the moment the our AA chances are:
B Harvey (definately)
Petrie, Pratt and Wells (petrie and wells in career best form while pratt who was in contention last year continues to hit in hard and get plenty of the footy but all 3 another good season away from selection.
If and only IF we can continue on and win 2 of the next 3 and win a final or two and compete admirable I think 3 of the four could make the side. Just to finish off you are wrong, hodge has been great and I think will get a gig.
Wells not good enough for the whole year unfortunately. Pratt and Petrie a certainty for the top 40 and a toss up for the 22.
Medhurst AA.... PFFFFFT
Didn't see Medhursts game last week... But against the Hawks and again tonight he has been WOEFUL.
No chance of AA...
Didn't see Medhursts game last week... But against the Hawks and again tonight he has been WOEFUL.
No chance of AA...
- Aug 11, 2008
- 3,601
- 1,439
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Liverpool
Re: Medhurst AA.... PFFFFFT
Swan, Thomas, Fraser, Burns, Davis, Pendlebury and O'Brien at the VERY least were better than him. Was very average last week.
No he wasn't. In fact he wouldn't have even gotten B+F votes.
Swan, Thomas, Fraser, Burns, Davis, Pendlebury and O'Brien at the VERY least were better than him. Was very average last week.
- Sep 14, 2005
- 18,419
- 18,679
Re: Medhurst AA.... PFFFFFT
5 direct goal assists is a bit more than solid, mate.
5 direct goal assists is a bit more than solid, mate.
- May 16, 2008
- 21,298
- 33,993
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Re: Medhurst AA.... PFFFFFT
keep track of which week people are talking about peanut
keep track of which week people are talking about peanut
Re: Medhurst AA.... PFFFFFT
Medhurst only had 2 direct goal assists against the Saints, he had 5 score assists, in other words he set up 3 behinds.
- Status
