All time greatest/worst trades?

[goodie23]

Saints have some doozies in our history, Lovett was a debacle but I rate the Brooks trade (a ruckman drafted the previous year for pick 7 and 32, which became 6 and 31 after Carlton's indiscretions) and the Ian Stewart-Billy Barrott trade as worse. Other notable horror stories include Heath Black (traded in for pick 17 a couple of years earlier) for Aaron Fiora and Fergus Watts for pick 17.

St Kilda wins are much rarer. Jason Gram for pick 23 (Matthew Moody) was a good deal, Michael Gardiner for a 16 pick downgrade proved inspired and Dempster/Schneider for pick 26 as well as King + Charlie Gardiner for pick 90 made 2007 our best trade period yet.

 

[willoblue]

hello I'm willoblue and I'm a Freo supporter.
It has been a few years since our last trading blunder.

now you all say,

well I'm sure u get the gist of it

 

[THE THIN MAN]

John Pitura trade was bad -

The trade saw Graham Teasdale, Brian Roberts and Francis Jackson come to South Melbourne

 

[SweetLeftFoot]

Shannon Grant for Wayne Schwass.

 

[Genesis67]

Shannon Grant for Wayne Schwass.

Classic win-win, that one.

 

[Koutafidamedis]

Not really fair to count the player that wa picked up by a club receiving a draft pick in a trade. No way to know whethe the first club wouldn't taken the same player.