Event AMA with Admin Candidates

[The Filth Wizard]

I don't get the debate.

If anything it's more convenient having a mod as admin. The rules are essentially the same. The only issue is if a mod/admin is carding posters for Sweet FA rules as opposed to site rules but that would be madness.

 

[Jabba73]

The SFA Admin would not be the avenue of appeal against a mod decision.

You're looking for a super-moderator or the site admin ala Chief to appeal a mod decision.

Who would talk to the Mod making the original decision, in this case also the Admin.

What?

The league admin has nothing to do with/has no say in mod decisions unless they are a mod...

Which you are.

 

[Noidenous]

The SFA Admin would not be the avenue of appeal against a mod decision.

You're looking for a super-moderator or the site admin ala Chief to appeal a mod decision.

Which you cannot do if the suspension involves cutting off all communication through the site.

If right of reply is removed, then one has to question the reason for it.

 

[NaturalDisaster]

Which you cannot do if the suspension involves cutting off all communication through the site.

If right of reply is removed, then one has to question the reason for it.

No it isn’t, you can still pm the mod who suspends you. You can also contact the admins directly.

Contact us

www.bigfooty.com

If anyone has any issues regarding site modding, take it to PM. This is not the thread for it.

 

[Noidenous]

No it isn’t, you can still pm the mod who suspends you. You can also contact the admins directly.

Contact us

www.bigfooty.com

If anyone has any issues regarding site modding, take it to PM. This is not the thread for it.

When was the last time you were suspended?

I'd say it was pretty recent for me. Think I didn't try and reply?

I know I'd prefer an admin that doesn't get drunk on power and declare clear jibes as mod abuse.

 

[NaturalDisaster]

When was the last time you were suspended?

I'd say it was pretty recent for me. Think I didn't try and reply?

I know I'd prefer an admin that doesn't get drunk on power and declare clear jibes as mod abuse.

You’re talking modding here so I would be careful where you take this.

If you can’t reply to PMs when suspended, take it up with Chief. I keep them open for reply, so theres no reason why you shouldn’t be able to read.

 

[Jabba73]

No it isn’t, you can still pm the mod who suspends you. You can also contact the admins directly.

Contact us

www.bigfooty.com

If anyone has any issues regarding site modding, take it to PM. This is not the thread for it.

This is a discussion about the admin of the SFA, while being a Mod.

Once again you are blurring lines by stifling discussion about one role by using your powers in another.

 

[NaturalDisaster]

This is a discussion about the admin of the SFA, while being a Mod.

Once again you are blurring lines by stifling discussion about one role by using your powers in another.

No, I am stopping mod discussion, not admin discussion.

 

[Noidenous]

No, I am stopping mod discussion, not admin discussion.

No, the two roles are demarcated.

If one of your buddy-buddies calls you a dickhead because you're admin and it's the league way, yet someone else makes a veiled reference and you discipline the latter, that is very much an admin issue.

The difference between them is not the role, but the parties involved.

 

[NaturalDisaster]

No, the two roles are demarcated.

If one of your buddy-buddies calls you a dickhead because you're admin, yet someone else makes a veiled reference and you discipline the latter, that is very much an admin issue.

The difference between them is not the role, but the parties involved.

As I said, if you’re upset about a mod decision take it to PM.

 

[Noidenous]

As I said, if you’re upset about a mod decision take it to PM.

Yeah, yeah, let's pretend that will amount to anything, shall we?

 

[NaturalDisaster]

Yeah, yeah, let's pretend that will amount to anything, shall we?

Then don’t post about it here

 

[Noidenous]

Then don’t post about it here

Or I could express concern in an AMA thread.

 

[NaturalDisaster]

Or I could express concern in an AMA thread.

Like I said, its not the place to discuss site moderation.

 

[Noidenous]

Like I said, its not the place to discuss site moderation.

It's not about moderation, it's about the admin's ability to keep the two roles demarcated, no matter how anyone would like to try and obfuscate the context.

 

[Jabba73]

Thanks NaturalDisaster, you have made a compelling case why someone should not hold both roles simultaneously.

 

[TheInjuryFactory]

A serious question please for all the candidates.

Barrybran Kennedy Parker kdavva PMBangers Jabba73

With the future phasing out of the current simulator flagged in favour of KP's QootyPy...

Just how quickly will you retool the current sim to bring in an AFL-X style, rock and roll pre-season competition??

Kind of like the Tittybong Cup... But entertaining and well run?

KOLOKOTRONIS

I mean, RAMPAGE

 

[NaturalDisaster]

It's not about moderation, it's about the admin's ability to keep the two roles demarcated, no matter how anyone would like to try and obfuscate the context.

You are whinging about the time you got wacked for clear mod abuse, now give it a rest.

 

[NaturalDisaster]

No, I am contrasting that with other references to yourself that occur on a regular basis.

One is ok, apparently my version was not despite clear difference in severity.

There is a distinct difference in application.

Right

No idea what you’re on about, but like i said, happy to take it to pm. Last warning

 

[Kennedy Parker]

A serious question please for all the candidates.

Barrybran Kennedy Parker kdavva PMBangers Jabba73

With the future phasing out of the current simulator flagged in favour of KP's QootyPy...

Just how quickly will you retool the current sim to bring in an AFL-X style, rock and roll pre-season competition??

Kind of like the Tittybong Cup... But entertaining and well run?

KOLOKOTRONIS

I mean, RAMPAGE

I love it.

We can do a draft the captains will be: the All-SFA captain, premiership captain, Mobbs Medalist and Beez winner of the previous season.

Rig the sim so that it only gives us the most favourable weather condition: Fine, for the highest stats for all.

And grand final-esque special commentary for every game.

 

[TheInjuryFactory]

I love it.

We can do a draft the captains will be: the All-SFA captain, premiership captain, Mobbs Medalist and Beez winner of the previous season.

Rig the sim so that it only gives us the most favourable weather condition: Fine, for the highest stats for all.

And grand final-esque special commentary for every game.

Congratulations Mr Admin Man.

 

[Jabba73]

Right

No idea what you’re on about, but like i said, happy to take it to pm. Last warning

Thought it was pretty clear. Let me put it very simply for you.

In the SFA, it appears to be encouraged to pick on the Admin, it is open slather as long as it is restricted to Admin duties and doesn’t cross an lines in regards to site rules.

Sometimes, you forget which role you are in and this results in a blurring of the line between your dual roles as the Admin and as a Mod. It happens, no big deal as mistakes happen … until you pretend it hasn’t happened in your role as the Admin, while dispensing your duties as a Mod.

Have seen it happen, only to certain teams/players though. It is as though your dealings in one role affects your dealings in the other role, which is the whole point of the discussion about separation of powers.

 

[TheInjuryFactory]

Thought it was pretty clear. Let me put it very simply for you.

In the SFA, it appears to be encouraged to pick on the Admin, it is open slather as long as it is restricted to Admin duties and doesn’t cross an lines in regards to site rules.

Sometimes, you forget which role you are in and this results in a blurring of the line between your dual roles as the Admin and as a Mod. It happens, no big deal as mistakes happen … until you pretend it hasn’t happened in your role as the Admin, while dispensing your duties as a Mod.

Have seen it happen, only to certain teams/players though. It is as though your dealings in one role affects your dealings in the other role, which is the whole point of the discussion about separation of powers.

Mate, he'll catch up with you after ok?

 

[Jabba73]

Noidenous can o longer respond to this thread.

The silence is deafening.

 

[ImissFrosty]

Noidenous can o longer respond to this thread.

The silence is deafening.

jesus you can sook.

Noid had chance after chance to shut up yet chose not to.