Opinion Best 22 - 2015

[thylacine60]

Brando as Judd on hearing MM was to be the new coach. Award winning stuff.

 

[Bluey24]

Apologies if this is pointless!

I'm bored waiting for a delayed train... Have tried to put The List in order of "first-picked" (when fit). Hopefully it sparks some good chat

1. Murphy
2. Gibbs
3. Henderson
4. Judd
5. Simpson
6. Yarran
7. Jamison
8. Kreuzer
9. Thomas
10. Everitt
11. Walker
12. Rowe
13. Menzel
14. Curnow
15. Docherty
16. Jones
17. Carrazzo
18. Casboult
19. White
20. Tuohy
21. Buckley
22. Bell
23. Jaksch
24. Boekhorst
25. Tutt
26. Wood
27. Armfield
28. Cripps
29. Sheehan
30. Graham
31. Whiley
32. Ellard
33. Watson
34. Johnson
35. Warnock (so tempted to put last)
36. Giles
37. Rainbow
38. Dick
39. Holman
40. Smith
41. Walsh
42. Foster
43. Byrne
44. Russell
45. Gowers
46. Fields

 

[LanceRomance]

Brando as Judd on hearing MM was to be the new coach. Award winning stuff.

I could have seen eddie betts as ed harris given how fast he talked

 

[thylacine60]

Apologies if this is pointless!

I'm bored waiting for a delayed train... Have tried to put The List in order of "first-picked" (when fit). Hopefully it sparks some good chat

1. Murphy
2. Gibbs
3. Henderson
4. Judd
5. Simpson
6. Yarran
7. Jamison
8. Kreuzer
9. Thomas
10. Everitt
11. Walker
12. Rowe
13. Menzel
14. Curnow
15. Docherty
16. Jones
17. Carrazzo
18. Casboult
19. White
20. Tuohy
21. Buckley
22. Bell
23. Jaksch
24. Boekhorst
25. Tutt
26. Wood
27. Armfield
28. Cripps
29. Sheehan
30. Graham
31. Whiley
32. Ellard
33. Watson
34. Johnson
35. Warnock (so tempted to put last)
36. Giles
37. Rainbow
38. Dick
39. Holman
40. Smith
41. Walsh
42. Foster
43. Byrne
44. Russell
45. Gowers
46. Fields

5.06am........that's delayed..........

 

[Azul]

Apologies if this is pointless!

I'm bored waiting for a delayed train... Have tried to put The List in order of "first-picked" (when fit). Hopefully it sparks some good chat

Nice effort. My feeling is Everitt and Jones are a bit high.

Players 28-31 and 39 will be the keys. When those 5 cement a spot in our 22 we'll be sneaking into the finals this year.

 

[Moe B]

Apologies if this is pointless!

I'm bored waiting for a delayed train... Have tried to put The List in order of "first-picked" (when fit). Hopefully it sparks some good chat

1. Murphy
2. Gibbs
3. Henderson
4. Judd
5. Simpson
6. Yarran
7. Jamison
8. Kreuzer
9. Thomas
10. Everitt
11. Walker
12. Rowe
13. Menzel
14. Curnow
15. Docherty
16. Jones
17. Carrazzo
18. Casboult
19. White
20. Tuohy
21. Buckley
22. Bell
23. Jaksch
24. Boekhorst
25. Tutt
26. Wood
27. Armfield
28. Cripps
29. Sheehan
30. Graham
31. Whiley
32. Ellard
33. Watson
34. Johnson
35. Warnock (so tempted to put last)
36. Giles
37. Rainbow
38. Dick
39. Holman
40. Smith
41. Walsh
42. Foster
43. Byrne
44. Russell
45. Gowers
46. Fields

Rainbow at 25, seriously!! And i think Watto could be way higher after round 5...

 

[Aphrodite]

Rainbow at 25, seriously!! And i think Watto could be way higher after round 5...

Where do you see Rainbow at 25?

I see Tutt at 25 and Rainbow at 37!

 

[Moe B]

As in should be 25... I know he hasn't played yet but could be better then almost half the list already!!

 

[Moe B]

Casboult would be in the top 10 picked for sure... Almost as important as anyone else!

 

[Moe B]

Casboult would be in the top 10 picked for sure... Almost as important as anyone else!

 

[SickQwon]

Nice effort. My feeling is Everitt and Jones are a bit high.

Players 28-31 and 39 will be the keys. When those 5 cement a spot in our 22 we'll be sneaking into the finals this year.

I reckon Everitt was one of our most important players last season

 

[Azul]

I reckon Everitt was one of our most important players last season

It depends on how one ranks versatility. To me he's a bit of a jack of all trades; I wouldn't select him at 10.

Players 12-15 I'd pick ahead of him in a heartbeat. Buckley will leapfrog ahead of quite a number this year.

 

[Zlatan]

-Carrazzo way too high
-Cripps to move into the top 15 by seasons end

 

[DaVillaBlues]

Casboult would be in the top 10 picked for sure... Almost as important as anyone else!

Wouldn't have thought so, he has yet to deliver the goods on a consistent enough basis yet, although hopefully he can make it into our top 5 most important players by season's end

 

[Moe B]

Wouldn't have thought so, he has yet to deliver the goods on a consistent enough basis yet, although hopefully he can make it into our top 5 most important players by season's end

I know hes inconsistent but hes an imposing figure up fwd which makes him of higher importance...

 

[Crippa16]

Jaksch Jamison Touhy
Buckley Rowe Simpson
Yarran Cripps Docherty
Thomas Casboult Menzel
Jones Henderson Graham

Kreuzer Murphy Gibbs

Everrit Judd Whiley Sub: Boekhorst

 

[Bluey24]

5.06am........that's delayed..........

Ha ha, I'm studying over in the UK mate, ha...

 

[Crippa16]

Jaksch Jamison Touhy

Buckley Rowe Simpson
Yarran Cripps Docherty
Thomas Casboult Menzel
Jones Henderson Graham

Kreuzer Murphy Gibbs

Everrit Judd Whiley Sub: Boekhorst

Its hard to fit everyone in, even Walker and Carrazzo

 

[BM123]

Wouldn't have thought so, he has yet to deliver the goods on a consistent enough basis yet, although hopefully he can make it into our top 5 most important players by season's end

Casboult needs to work on maintaining his form for longer. Two seasons in a row where he has looked the good before tapering off badly. His marking game is awesome but it's worth nothing if he isn't presenting himself whenever possible.

 

[Moe B]

Casboult needs to work on maintaining his form for longer. Two seasons in a row where he has looked the good before tapering off badly. His marking game is awesome but it's worth nothing if he isn't presenting himself whenever possible.

The kick isnt great either... Get the Fev back!!!

 

[BM123]

The kick isnt great either... Get the Fev back!!!

Fevola is like 36 now.

I think it's time to move on....

Irregardless Casboult's kicking is hit and miss but most key forwards are. If Casboult pushes himself hard to get 5 scoring opportunities and he kicks 3 out of 5 then that's good enough for us.

 

[Moe B]

Fevola is like 36 now.

I think it's time to move on....

Irregardless Casboult's kicking is hit and miss but most key forwards are. If Casboult pushes himself hard to get 5 scoring opportunities and he kicks 3 out of 5 then that's good enough for us.

I didnt mean to come back and play, that woukd be ignorant... Come back and show these blokes how to kick!!

 

[thylacine60]

some merit in that

 

[MrsEddieBetts]

Except he's a fat, drunk idiot.

 

[thylacine60]

bit weightist.....