List Mgmt. Best 23 for 2025

[Better Loosen Up]

Slow day on trade-radio…

B:Archer Logue McDonald
HB:Houston Corr Draper

C:McKercher Davies-Uniacke Scott

HF:Ford Comben Simpkin
F:Curtis Larkey Darling

R:Xerri Parker Sheezel

I:Teakle Zurhaar Powell Wardlaw

Don't think we can have all 4 of Darling Larkey, Comben and Teakle in the forward line.

Backline looks a bit undersized to me and McDonald, yuk!

 

[The Nostradamus]

Don't think we can have all 4 of Darling Larkey, Comben and Teakle in the forward line.

Backline looks a bit undersized to me and McDonald, yuk!

Yeah comben will be backline imo

Only way that would change is if we somehow got SDK

 

[Better Loosen Up]

Curtis, Zurhaar, Durrsma, Ford, Simpkin

All seem to be very similar players to me.

Fitting all of these in our team is probably making us a bit too unbalanced.

Really need a proper small forward or two to step up so we are more dynamic and one or two of those I have mentioned will need to be moved on/ reinvented in the next year or two.

 

[Better Loosen Up]

Yeah comben will be backline imo

Only way that would change is if we somehow got SDK

SDK can take Corr's spot

 

[The Nostradamus]

I think Simpkin can be the small forward we need but not sure how keen he would be to play that role

If he can’t play mid he probs would at least rather high half forward working hard up the ground and through stoppages

 

[FootySmartSimpson]

Don't think we can have all 4 of Darling Larkey, Comben and Teakle in the forward line.

Backline looks a bit undersized to me and McDonald, yuk!

McDonald will be there, it’s not my preference.

Teakle will be the second ruck and work up the ground. Darling and Larks the keys.

If we need Comben back then swing him around.

We have been so starved of actual KP depth, that many of us lose our minds a little when we see 6 key-position players in a team but forget that most run with six in a team and some have 7-8.

 

[ferball]

I think Simpkin can be the small forward we need but not sure how keen he would be to play that role

If he can’t play mid he probs would at least rather high half forward working hard up the ground and through stoppages

Other sides push their small forwards all the way to D50 to provide link-up and pressure on the opposition. Even in our VFL side we'd do that with Harvey, RJH and Drury.

 

[RossHenshaw]

Our best possible 2025 side in my opinion:

B: Archer-Logue-Corr
HB: Houston-Chom-Daniels
C: Scott-LDU-McKercher
R: Xerri-Sheezel-Wardlaw
HF: Parker-Darling- Zurhaar
F: Jy-Larkey-Curtis
Interchange: Powell , Fisher ,Teakel , Duursma
Sub: Goater
Emergency: Hansen Jnr

 

[KingNorth23]

Our best possible 2025 side in my opinion:

B: Archer-Logue-Corr
HB: Houston-Chom-Daniels
C: Scott-LDU-McKercher
R: Xerri-Sheezel-Wardlaw
HF: Parker-Darling- Zurhaar
F: Jy-Larkey-Curtis
Interchange: Powell , Fisher ,Teakel , Duursma
Sub: Goater
Emergency: Hansen Jnr

Just looking at that team looks so beautiful. Tho would be 50/50 on that Houston pick. The draft this season is amazing and probably our last only draft season to pick up the final pieces to start pushing that ladder.

 

[Shermanator]

Our best possible 2025 side in my opinion:

B: Archer-Logue-Corr
HB: Houston-Chom-Daniels
C: Scott-LDU-McKercher
R: Xerri-Sheezel-Wardlaw
HF: Parker-Darling- Zurhaar
F: Jy-Larkey-Curtis
Interchange: Powell , Fisher ,Teakel , Duursma
Sub: Goater
Emergency: Hansen Jnr

B: Archer-Logue-Hardemann
HB: Houston-Chom-Daniels
C: Scott-LDU-McKercher
R: Xerri-Sheezel-Wardlaw
HF: Parker-Darling- Zurhaar
F: Jy-Larkey-Curtis
Interchange: Powell, RHJ, Armstrong, Duursma
Sub: Goater
Emergency: Fisher

 

[Mr north man]

B: Archer-Logue-Hardemann
HB: Houston-Chom-Daniels
C: Scott-LDU-McKercher
R: Xerri-Sheezel-Wardlaw
HF: Parker-Darling- Zurhaar
F: Jy-Larkey-Curtis
Interchange: Powell, RHJ, Armstrong, Duursma
Sub: Goater
Emergency: Fisher

I think yes in theory a good side but unless McDonald is in the side and as captain then it’s ok side.
Everybody should know once the players name him as captain then he just plays.
Iv realised no point calling McDonald to go the players love him so do the coaches no point fighting it just used to it.
Thats my motto.