Brownlow Medal 2009 (Part 1)

[banta]

Re: Brownlow Medal

for those giving Gaz 3 votes v Brisbane...i have a sneaking suspicion come brownlow night we might see 3 votes to A Mackie...

yeah i agree, not sure if he'll definitely get 3 this round.
3. Mackie
2. Ablett
1. Mooney
maybe something like that?

 

[senrulzisback]

Re: Brownlow Medal

Gave Goodwin 3 votes, he ripped it apart. S.Thomspson for 2, and B. Miller for the 1.
Goodwin stood out easily though.

 

[tarky]

Re: Brownlow Medal

gaz is $1.80 after 5 rounds.....seems ridiculous

 

[asanque]

Re: Brownlow Medal

Gave Goodwin 3 votes, he ripped it apart. S.Thomspson for 2, and B. Miller for the 1.
Goodwin stood out easily though.

What game did you watch?

I agree with Goodwin 3 votes.

But B.Miller with 1?

The only excuse I can see with that vote, is that you watched last Thursday's footy show and want to get into Pia's good books.

Lets recap Brad Miller
5 kicks, 1 handpass, 4 marks, 2 behinds.

Only Goodes could get a brownlow vote with stats like that.

3. Goodwin
2. Tippett
1. Mclean

 

[asanque]

Re: Brownlow Medal

for those giving Gaz 3 votes v Brisbane...i have a sneaking suspicion come brownlow night we might see 3 votes to A Mackie...

He might not get 3 in round 1 either.

S.Johnson, B.Ottens and G.Ablett will split the 6 votes.

 

[senrulzisback]

Re: Brownlow Medal

What game did you watch?

I agree with Goodwin 3 votes.

But B.Miller with 1?

The only excuse I can see with that vote, is that you watched last Thursday's footy show and want to get into Pia's good books.

Lets recap Brad Miller
5 kicks, 1 handpass, 4 marks, 2 behinds.

Only Goodes could get a brownlow vote with stats like that.

3. Goodwin
2. Tippett
1. Mclean

Sorry mate wasn't Miller it was Moloney....

 

[Shut up Flanders]

Re: Brownlow Medal

I'm a bit late with mine this week ...

COMPLETION OF ROUND 5 VOTES

11: Ablett

10: Dal Santo

8: Mitchell, Murphy

7: Stanton

6: Pearce, Judd

5: Goddard, Gilbee, Kerr, Swan, Gibbs, Vince

4: Richo, Tredrea, N.Riewoldt, Goodwin

3: J.Riewoldt, N.Brown, Edwards, Johnstone, Harding, Pavlich, J.Bolton, Hasleby, Drummond, Chapman, Goodes, Winderlich, Griffen, C.Cornes, S.Tuck, Pendlebury, Lockyer, Montagna , Harvey, Bowden, Wirrpanda, Hayes, Ryder, Mackie

2: McLeod, Power, Moloney, P Burgoyne, Boyd, Didak, Schammer, Bateman, Bruce, Jolly, Fletcher, Simpson, A Selwood, Waite, Bartel, Aa.Davey, Moss, Mundy, Deledio

1: Bradshaw, Wiggins, S Johnson, Fletcher, Ball, McDonald, Higgins, Green, Symes, Guerra, Fevola, Adcock, McVeigh, Watson, Cross, Salopek, Akermanis, Dalziell, Boak, Kirk, Corey, Hale, Embley, S.Fisher, Cox, Swallow, Mooney, Br.Johnson, Mclean

 

[Athomas]

Re: Brownlow Medal

Round 6 Brownlow votes Running Total:


13: Ablett

10: Dal Santo

8: Mitchell, Goddard

7: Chapman

6: Judd, Tredrea, Montagna, Gibbs

5: Higgins, Pendlebury, Lockyer, Bartel, NRiewoldt

4: Edwards, SJohnson, Jolly, Cross, PBurgoyne, Gilbee, Kerr, Pearce, Bowden, Vince, Haselby, CCornes, RShaw

3: Murphy, Johnstone, Harding, Fraser, Winderlich, BJohnson, ASelwood, Adcock, Lloyd, Mitchell, Waite, Harvey, Davey, Wirripanda, Hayes, Ryder, Pavlich, Goodwin, Davis, Swan, Roughhead, JBrown, Brogan, Mattner,

2: Ottens, Mcleod, Power, Mcintosh, Goodes, Fletcher, Lake, Drummond, Walker, Dew, JMcVeigh, JSelwood, Hale, Miller, Moss, Jackson, Mundy, KSimpson, Thompson, Cox, Sewell, Duffield, Power, Watson

1: Wiggins, Le Cras, Gilbert, McDonald, Motlop, Giansiracusa, Koschitzke, Didak, Bradshaw, Mcphee, Bateman, Richardson, Medhurst, LHansen, Krakouer, Fisher, JRiewoldt, Sandilands, Kruezer, Hill, KCornes, Richards, Corey, Ray



Interesting early, Mitchell + Goddard catching up to Mr Ablett.

 

[Shut up Flanders]

Re: Brownlow Medal

COMPLETION OF ROUND 6 VOTES

11: Ablett

10: Dal Santo

9: Mitchell

8: Murphy, Goddard

7: Stanton, Vince

6: Pearce, Judd, Swan, Hasleby, C.Cornes, Chapman

5: Gilbee, Kerr, Gibbs, Lockyer, N.Riewoldt

4: Richo, Tredrea, Goodwin, Bartel

3: J.Riewoldt, N.Brown, Edwards, Johnstone, Harding, Pavlich, J.Bolton, Drummond, Goodes, Winderlich, Griffen, S.Tuck, Pendlebury, Montagna , Harvey, Bowden, Wirrpanda, Hayes, Ryder, Mackie, Davis, Roughead, Fevola, J.Brown, Watson, Mattner

2: McLeod, Power, Moloney, P.Burgoyne, Boyd, Didak, Schammer, Bateman, Bruce, Jolly, Fletcher, Simpson, A Selwood, Waite, Aa.Davey, Moss, Mundy, Deledio, Duffield, Roberts-Thomson, Corey, Ray

1: Bradshaw, Wiggins, S Johnson, Fletcher, Ball, McDonald, Higgins, Green, Symes, Guerra, Adcock, McVeigh, Cross, Salopek, Akermanis, Dalziell, Boak, Kirk, Hale, Embley, S.Fisher, Cox, Swallow, Mooney, Br.Johnson, Mclean, Hill, T.Selwood, K.Cornes, Collins

 

[scooterselwood]

Re: Brownlow Medal

COMPLETION OF ROUND 6 VOTES

11: Ablett

10: Dal Santo

9: Mitchell

8: Murphy, Goddard

7: Stanton, Vince

6: Pearce, Judd, Swan, Hasleby, C.Cornes, Chapman

5: Gilbee, Kerr, Gibbs, Lockyer, N.Riewoldt

4: Richo, Tredrea, Goodwin, Bartel

3: J.Riewoldt, N.Brown, Edwards, Johnstone, Harding, Pavlich, J.Bolton, Drummond, Goodes, Winderlich, Griffen, S.Tuck, Pendlebury, Montagna , Harvey, Bowden, Wirrpanda, Hayes, Ryder, Mackie, Davis, Roughead, Fevola, J.Brown, Watson, Mattner

2: McLeod, Power, Moloney, P.Burgoyne, Boyd, Didak, Schammer, Bateman, Bruce, Jolly, Fletcher, Simpson, A Selwood, Waite, Aa.Davey, Moss, Mundy, Deledio, Duffield, Roberts-Thomson, Corey, Ray

1: Bradshaw, Wiggins, S Johnson, Fletcher, Ball, McDonald, Higgins, Green, Symes, Guerra, Adcock, McVeigh, Cross, Salopek, Akermanis, Dalziell, Boak, Kirk, Hale, Embley, S.Fisher, Cox, Swallow, Mooney, Br.Johnson, Mclean, Hill, T.Selwood, K.Cornes, Collins

why bthe highlightings?

 

[tarky]

Re: Brownlow Medal

no votes for sewell this week???

 

[Athomas]

Re: Brownlow Medal

no votes for sewell this week???

I gave him 2.

 

[senrulzisback]

Re: Brownlow Medal

16 Votes
Gary Ablett

11 Votes
Chris Judd
Leigh Montagna
Nick Riewoldt

10 Votes
Brendon Goddard

9 Votes
Lenny Hayes
Bryce Gibbs
Steve Johnson
Leon Davis

8 Votes
Nick Dal Santo
Paul Haselby
Brad Sewell
Scott Pendlebury

7 Votes
Sam Mitchell
Jason Akermanis
Warren Tredrea
Aaron Sandilands


6 Votes
Matthew Richardson
Adam Goodes
Jimmy Bartel
Jarrad McVeigh
Jonothan Brown
Joel Selwood
Danyle Pearce
Mark LeCras
Jason Winderlich
Patty Ryder
Chad Cornes
Paul Chapman

5 Votes
Matthew Boyd
Nathan Foley
Scott Thompson
David Hale
Andrew Swallow
Daniel Giansiracusa
Travis Boak
Tarkyn Lockyer
Brett Kirk
Bernie Vince

4 Votes
Josh Fraser
Justin Koschitzke
Dane Swan
Rhyce Shaw
Adam Selwood
Darren Jolly
Jed Adcock
Shaun Higgins
Brent Moloney

3 Votes
Jack Riewoldt
Simon Goodwin
Kade Simpson
Mitch Clark
Simon Wiggins
Adam Cooney
Daniel Motlop
Justin Sherman
Luke Power
Chris Knights
Leigh Harding
Lindsay Gilbee
Brian Lake
Brent Harvey
David Wirrpunda
Daniel Kerr
Gary Moss
Taylor Walker
David Mundy
Marc Murphy
Travis Johnstone
Daniel Jackson
Paul Duffield
Martin Mattner
Jarryd Roughead
Brent Stanton

2 Votes
Jude Bolton
Angus Graham
Colin Sylvia
Andrew Mcleod
Angus Monfries
Michael Doughty
Sam Gilbert
Leigh Brown
David Mackay
Brad Ottens
Troy Selwood
Joel Corey
James McDonald
Brad Johnson
Dustin Fletcher
Shaun Burgoyne
Dean Cox
Josh Drummond
James Kelly
Ryan Crowley
Matthew Lloyd
Drew Petrie
Brady Rawlings
Hamish McIntosh
Joel Bowden
Cyril Rioli
Shannon Byrnes
Ryan O'Keefe
Matthew Pavlich
Steven Salopek
Brendon Fevola
Matt Priddis

1 Vote
Matt White
Shane O'Bree
Cameron Mooney
Peter Burgoyne
Alan Didak
Daniel Bradshaw
Alwyn Davey
Nathan G Brown
Courtenay Dempsey
Brendon Whitecross
Ted Richards
Paul Medhurst
Michael Firrito
Cameron Ling
Simon Black
Jarrad Waite
Matthew Stokes
Jordan Lewis
Sam Fisher
Nick Stevens
Jobe Watson
Clinton Jones
Shane Tuck
Adam Schneider
Farren Ray

Updated for Round 9.

 

[asanque]

Re: Brownlow Medal

no votes for sewell this week???

Votes will be between: Roughhead, Fevola, Sewell, Judd

I suspect it will be: 3 Roughhead, 2 Fevola, 1 Judd/Sewell.

 

[asanque]

Re: Brownlow Medal

COMPLETION OF ROUND 6 VOTES

11: Ablett

10: Dal Santo

9: Mitchell

8: Murphy, Goddard

7: Stanton, Vince

6: Pearce, Judd, Swan, Hasleby, C.Cornes, Chapman

5: Gilbee, Kerr, Gibbs, Lockyer, N.Riewoldt

4: Richo, Tredrea, Goodwin, Bartel

3: J.Riewoldt, N.Brown, Edwards, Johnstone, Harding, Pavlich, J.Bolton, Drummond, Goodes, Winderlich, Griffen, S.Tuck, Pendlebury, Montagna , Harvey, Bowden, Wirrpanda, Hayes, Ryder, Mackie, Davis, Roughead, Fevola, J.Brown, Watson, Mattner

2: McLeod, Power, Moloney, P.Burgoyne, Boyd, Didak, Schammer, Bateman, Bruce, Jolly, Fletcher, Simpson, A Selwood, Waite, Aa.Davey, Moss, Mundy, Deledio, Duffield, Roberts-Thomson, Corey, Ray

1: Bradshaw, Wiggins, S Johnson, Fletcher, Ball, McDonald, Higgins, Green, Symes, Guerra, Adcock, McVeigh, Cross, Salopek, Akermanis, Dalziell, Boak, Kirk, Hale, Embley, S.Fisher, Cox, Swallow, Mooney, Br.Johnson, Mclean, Hill, T.Selwood, K.Cornes, Collins

As much as I rate Mitchell as a player. He is definitely not on 9.

I'm not sure how you slotted him in for 1 on the weekend, with Roughhead (8 goals), Fevola (8 goals), Sewell/Judd - clearly in front on the weekend.

Round 5 - he got 40 possessions - mostly of half back. He will be fighting with Moss and Sewell for the 3 votes. However, lets say he gets 3 there.

Will not get votes for rounds 1,2,4.
At best, he will get 1 for round 1, but that is unlikely as Ablett, Ottens, S.Johnson dominated.

I thought he was very good round 3 and will probably get the 3, but will be fighting for it.

I put Mitchell on 7 maximum, with perhaps no more then 5.

 

[asanque]

Re: Brownlow Medal

Ablett is also too short in the brownlow for mine.

Round 1 - 3 votes best case, most likely 2, possible 1 (for reasons in above posts)
Round 2 - I didn't watch this match. Lets say 2? With S.Johnson with 4 goals and 24 possessions, Bartel, Richo both playing well.
Round 3- 3 votes to Chapman for mine. Possibly 3 for Ablett, but most likely 2.
Round 4 - Definite 3
Round 5 - Didn't watch. Stats say 3.
Round 6 - 0

So I put Ablett on 12.

 

[asanque]

Re: Brownlow Medal

14 Votes

6 Votes
Leigh Montagna
Matthew Richardson
Sam Mitchell
Leon Davis
Brendon Goddard
Chad Cornes
Paul Haselby
Paul Chapman

How do you figure 6 votes for Hasleby?
Potentially 3 this weekend.
But where else do the votes come from?
Surely not 3 votes for the loss v Adelaide in round 3?
Although admittedly, I didn't see this game.

 

[senrulzisback]

Re: Brownlow Medal

How do you figure 6 votes for Hasleby?
Potentially 3 this weekend.
But where else do the votes come from?
Surely not 3 votes for the loss v Adelaide in round 3?
Although admittedly, I didn't see this game.

I don't keep track of my BOG's for each game, so I can't remember which games I gave him votes for.

 

[Athomas]

Re: Brownlow Medal

I've updated mine for the week!

Round 7 Brownlow votes Running Total:


13: Ablett

12: Dal Santo

8: Goddard, Gibbs, NRiewoldt

7: Chapman, Mitchell, SJohnson, Montagna

6: Judd, Tredrea, JBrown, Gilbee

5: Higgins, Pendlebury, Lockyer, Bartel, Haselby

4: Edwards, Jolly, Cross, PBurgoyne, Kerr, Pearce, Bowden, Vince, CCornes, RShaw, Winderlich, JSelwood, Power, Sandilands, LeCras

3: Murphy, Johnstone, Harding, Fraser, BJohnson, ASelwood, Adcock, Lloyd, Mitchell, Waite, Harvey, Davey, Wirripanda, Hayes, Ryder, Pavlich, Goodwin, Davis, Swan, Roughhead, Brogan, Mattner, Stanton, ASimpson, Cooney, Walker

2: Ottens, Mcleod, Power, Mcintosh, Goodes, Fletcher, Lake, Drummond, Dew, JMcVeigh, Hale, Miller, Moss, Jackson, Mundy, KSimpson, Thompson, Cox, Duffield, Watson, Fevola, Monfries, Corey, Kornes, Boak

1: Wiggins, Gilbert, McDonald, Motlop, Giansiracusa, Koschitzke, Didak, Bradshaw, Mcphee, Bateman, Richardson, Medhurst, LHansen, Krakouer, Fisher, JRiewoldt, Kruezer, Hill, Richards, Ray, Sewell, Graham

 

[scooterselwood]

Re: Brownlow Medal

how is lecras only on 1??

what votes did you give for wce v melb??

 

[Athomas]

Re: Brownlow Medal

how is lecras only on 1??

what votes did you give for wce v melb??

Strange I gave him 3. Must have not added him to the tally correctly.

 

[banta]

Re: Brownlow Medal

what did people get for the Carlton vs Fremantle and Kangaroos vs Port Adelaide games? anyone fans of those teams see the matches? since brent harvey's injury i've found it pretty tough to find a player who stands out for north and can attract umpires votes. Maybe Wells.
cheers

 

[Juddbemetron]

Re: Brownlow Medal

what did people get for the Carlton vs Fremantle and Kangaroos vs Port Adelaide games? anyone fans of those teams see the matches? since brent harvey's injury i've found it pretty tough to find a player who stands out for north and can attract umpires votes. Maybe Wells.
cheers

for carl freo
i got
3. Sandilands
2.Haselby
1.Judd
but the way the umps love judd wouldnt be surprosed if he got 2

 

[Jimmy Two Hands]

Re: Brownlow Medal

Like many others here, I'm recording my own Brownlow votes this year and keeping a running tally. I watched the Saints v Pies game on Monday night with great interest as a heap of Saints are around the mark and I had a dabble on Dal Santo before the start of the season. How did people score that game? So many Saints played well.

You could raffle the 3-2-1 between

Schneider
Riewoldt
Gilbert
Montagna
Hayes
Dal Santo
Goddard

Considering its a typically midfield award and the higher profile players are going to get noticed I went

3. Montagna
2. Riewoldt
1. Dal Santo

Thoughts?

 

[Athomas]

Re: Brownlow Medal

Like many others here, I'm recording my own Brownlow votes this year and keeping a running tally. I watched the Saints v Pies game on Monday night with great interest as a heap of Saints are around the mark and I had a dabble on Dal Santo before the start of the season. How did people score that game? So many Saints played well.

You could raffle the 3-2-1 between

Schneider
Riewoldt
Gilbert
Montagna
Hayes
Dal Santo
Goddard

Considering its a typically midfield award and the higher profile players are going to get noticed I went

3. Montagna
2. Riewoldt
1. Dal Santo

Thoughts?

Was an incredibly tough choice for me too. Those were the 3 players I went with, with NDS swapped with Volt.