Brownlow Medal 2010 (Part 1)

[Walshy_The_Goat]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2010

Round 5

Western Bulldogs V Adelaide:
3. R. Griffen
2. D. Giansiracusa
1. N. Eagleton

Sydney V West Coast:
3. J. McVeigh
2. R. O'Keefe
1. K. Jack

Melbourne V Brisbane:
3. B. Moloney
2. J. Trengove
1. M. Bate

Port Adelaide V St. Kilda
3. D. Rodan
2. L. Montagna
1. D. Cassissi

Collingwood V Essendon:
3. S. Pendlebury
2. D. Beams
1. S. Wellingham

Hawthorn V North Melbourne:
3. L. Anthony
2. L. Hodge
1. B. Rawlings

Fremantle V Richmond:
3. A. Sandilands
2. M. Barlow
1. D. Mundy

Carlton V Geelong:
3. C. Judd
2. G. Ablett
1. B. Gibbs

Leaderboard
11 - G. Ablett (+)
8 - A. Sandilands (+)
7 - J. Brennan*
7 - M. Barlow (+)
6 - C. Judd (+)
6 - N. Riewoldt
6 - J. Brown
5 - H. Shaw
5 - T. Boak
5 - R. O'Keefe (+)
5 - R. Griffen (+)
5 - B. Moloney (+)
4 - S. Pendlebury (+)
4 - J. Bartel
4 - L. Hayes
4 - B. Goddard
4 - M. Murphy
4 - A. Goodes (+)

Leaderboard and discussion at www.brownlowtalk.blogspot.com

 

[Effes]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2010

Tricky game last night given the Dogs dominance for most of the game - would think Hayes would have to be in there...NDS last quarter would give him a big chance and Gilbee had leather poisoning...Montagna also lifted late. Harbrow's dash off half back also eyecatching. Gia also had a lot of it.

 

[Effes]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2010

BTW...did the market change at all yesterday after it was announced Ablett was out?

 

[Damon_3388]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2010

Obviously it's not everything, but according to the Champion Data Player Rankings, the Brownlow leaderboard currently sits like this:

Champion Data Brownlow Medal 2010 (after 6 Rounds)

1. Gary Ablett (Geelong) - 11 (3 BOGs)
   Michael Barlow (Fremantle) - 11 (3 BOGs)
2. Jonathan Brown (Brisbane) - 10 (3 BOGs)
3. Luke Hodge (Hawthorn) - 9 (3 BOGs)
4. Jobe Watson (Essendon) - 7 (2 BOG)
   Paul Chapman (Geelong) - 7 (1 BOG)
5. Nick Riewoldt (St Kilda) - 6 (2 BOGs)
   Nick Malceski (Sydney) - 6 (1 BOG)
   Leigh Montagna (St Kilda) - 6 (1 BOG)
   Nick Dal Santo (St Kilda) - 6 (1 BOG)
6. Aaron Sandilands (Fremantle) - 5 (1 BOG)
   Chris Judd (Carlton) - 5 (1 BOG)
   Lindsay Gilbee (Western Bulldogs) - 5 (1 BOG)
   Brent Stanton (Essendon) - 5 (1 BOG)
   Matthew Pavlich (Fremantle) - 5 (1 BOG)
7. Michael Rischitelli (Brisbane) - 4 (1 BOG)
   Kade Simpson (Carlton) - 4 (1 BOG)
   Daniel Giansiracusa (Western Bulldogs) - 4 (1 BOG)
8. Eddie Betts (Carlton) - 3 (1 BOG)
   Kane Cornes (Port Adelaide) - 3 (1 BOG)
   Dane Swan (Collingwood) - 3 (1 BOG)
   Brad Green (Melbourne) - 3 (1 BOG)
   Travis Boak (Port Adelaide) - 3 (1 BOG)
   Ryan O’Keefe (Sydney) - 3 (1 BOG)
   Adam Cooney (Western Bulldogs) - 3 (1 BOG)
   Jimmy Bartel (Geelong) - 3 (1 BOG)
   Simon Goodwin (Adelaide) - 3 (1 BOG)
   Daniel Hannebery (Sydney) - 3 (1 BOG)
   Jared Brennan (Brisbane) - 3 (1 BOG)
   Heath Shaw (Collingwood) - 3
   Jack Riewoldt (Richmond) - 3 (1 BOG)
   Ryan Griffen (Western Bulldogs) - 3
   Simon Black (Brisbane) - 3 (1 BOG)
   Travis Cloke (Collingwood) - 3 (1 BOG)
   Stephen Gilham (Hawthorn) - 3 (1 BOG)
   Andrew Swallow (North Melbourne) - 3 (1 BOG)
   James McDonald (Melbourne) - 3
   Graham Johncock (Adelaide) - 3 (1 BOG)
   Daniel Bradshaw (Sydney) - 3
   Luke Ball (Collingwood) - 3 (1 BOG)
9. Andrew Carrazzo (Carlton) - 2
   Shannon Byrnes (Geelong) - 2
   Campbell Brown (Hawthorn) - 2
   Luke Power (Brisbane) - 2
   Domenic Cassisi (Port Adelaide) - 2
   Luke McPharlin (Fremantle) - 2
   Marc Murphy (Carlton) - 2
   Jack Grimes (Melbourne) - 2
   Jason Davenport (Port Adelaide) - 2
   Mark Seaby (Sydney) - 2
   Steven Baker (St Kilda) - 2
   Steven Salopek (Port Adelaide) - 2
   Ben McGlynn (Sydney) - 2
   Jude Bolton (Sydney) - 2
   Rick Dyson (Essendon) - 2
   Jamie Bennell (Melbourne) - 2
   Matthew Boyd (Western Bulldogs) - 2
   Paul Duffield (Fremantle) - 2
   Ryan Houlihan (Carlton) - 2
   Jarrod Harbrow (Western Bulldogs) - 2
   Steele Sidebottom (Collingwood) - 2
   Brent Moloney (Melbourne) - 2
   Stephen Milne (St Kilda) - 2
   Brendon Goddard (St Kilda) - 2
   Heath Grundy (Sydney) - 2
   Jack Trengove (Melbourne) - 2
   Scott Pendlebury (Collingwood) - 2
   Brent Guerra (Hawthorn) - 2
   Heath Scotland (Carlton) - 2
   Robbie Gray (Port Adelaide) - 2
   Kieran Jack (Sydney) - 2
   Steve Johnson (Geelong) - 2
   Sharrod Wellingham (Collingwood) - 2
10. Paul Bower (Carlton) - 1
    Joel Selwood (Geelong) - 1
    Jordan Lewis (Hawthorn) - 1
    Liam Anthony (North Melbourne) - 1
    Daniel Cross (Western Bulldogs) - 1
    Leon Davis (Collingwood) - 1
    Adam Selwood (West Coast) - 1
    Paul Haselby (Fremantle) - 1
    Cameron Mooney (Geelong) - 1
    Ivan Maric (Adelaide) - 1
    Cyril Rioli (Hawthorn) - 1
    Leigh Adams (North Melbourne) - 1
    Travis Johnstone (Brisbane) - 1
    Harry Taylor (Geelong) - 1
    Barry Hall (Western Bulldogs) - 1
    Jarrad McVeigh (Sydney) - 1
    Colin Sylvia (Melbourne) - 1
    Troy Chaplin (Port Adelaide) - 1
    Alan Didak (Collingwood) - 1
    Brad Sewell (Hawthorn) - 1
    Tyson Edwards (Adelaide) - 1
    Nathan Lovett-Murray (Essendon) - 1
    Shane Tuck (Richmond) - 1
    Jordan Russell (Collingwood) - 1
    David Mundy (Fremantle) - 1

 

[AG]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2010

Goodes has no votes.

 

[Notorious_29]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2010

11 - Barlow
9 - Ablett
8 - Sandilands
7 - Watson
7 - Bradshaw
7 - Judd
7 - Pendlebury

6 - Riewoldt, Hodge, Brennan, Pavlich, Wells, Gilbert

 

[FootyStar#1]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2010

Obviously it's not everything, but according to the Champion Data Player Rankings, the Brownlow leaderboard currently sits like this:

Champion Data Brownlow Medal 2010 (after 6 Rounds)

1. 
   
   Jordan Russell (Collingwood) - 1
   

Mmm haha don't know if i trust them ^

but anyway could you send a link to where this is?

 

[Athomas]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2010

10 - M Barlow
9 - G Ablett
8 - M Pavlich
8 - A Sandilands
7 - J Brown
7 - C Judd
7 - D Wells
6 - Brennan, Harvey, Mglynn, Bradhsaw


That fremantle trio going well for mine.

 

[Damon_3388]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2010

Mmm haha don't know if i trust them ^

but anyway could you send a link to where this is?

I just keep a running tally in a Word document on my computer. I can post the game-by-game votes if people want them.

I watch most games each weekend, but for this, I simply look at the stats from each game on Footy Wire, and take the 3-2-1 for each match from the three players with the highest Champion Data Player Rating. No personal judgements, no bias, just a simple tally of what this particular statistical measure has shown, done purely out of curiosity.

I did the same thing last year too, and it predicted that Gary Ablett would win the Brownlow Medal, right down to the exact vote tally!

Anyway, the votes for the Carlton vs. Collingwood game today went like this:

3. Luke Ball (Collingwood)
2. Sharrod Wellingham (Collingwood)
1. Jordan Russell (Carlton)

According to the CDPR, leading possession winner Chris Judd was the 10th best player on the ground.

 

[FootyStar#1]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2010

heres the top of my tally so far:

M Barlow 11
G Ablett 9
Pavlich 9
Pendlebury 9
C Judd 8
R O'Keefe 7
D Wells 7
Riewoldt 6
J Brown 6
Bartel 6
Hayes 6
B Mcglynn 5
J Mcdonald 5
J Brennan 5
Goodes 5
Sandilands 5
Hodge 5
Watson 5
Jack 5

 

[AG]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2010

 

[TubbsFarquhar]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2010

Round 6
Western Bulldogs V St. Kilda:
3. Jarrod Harbrow
2. Lenny Hayes
1. Lindsay Gilbee

North Melbourne V Melbourne:
3. Daniel Wells
2. Andrew Swallow
1. Scott Thompson

Adelaide V Port Adelaide:
3. Robbie Gray
2. Domenic Cassisi
1. Graham Johncock

Essendon V Hawthorn:
3. NLM
2. Jobe Watson
1. Dustin Fletcher

Sydney V Brisbane:
3. Daniel Bradshaw
2. Kieran Jack
1. Ryan O'Keefe

Geelong V Richmond:
3. Paul Chapman
2. Joel Selwood
1. James Kelly

Carlton V Collingwood:
3. Scott Pendlebury
2. Dane Swan
1. Chris Judd

West Coast V Fremantle:
3. Michael Barlow
2. Matthew Pavlich
1. Paul Duffield


Leaderboard:
1. Michael Barlow (10)
2. Gary Ablett (8)
3. Daniel Wells (8)
4. Scott Pendlebury (8)
5. Aaron Sandilands (7)
6. Jonathon Brown (6)
7. Matthew Pavlich (6)
8. Chris Judd (6)
9. Nick Riewoldt (6)
10. Jared Brennan (6)

 

[AG]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2010

Wells is slipping under the radar a bit this year.

 

[AhSteveSteve27]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2010

Leaderboard after Round 6:

10 - Barlow
8 - Ablett, Brown
7 - Pendlebury, Sandilands
6 - Moloney, ROK, Montagna, Riewoldt, Bartel, Murphy, Watson
5 - McGlynn, Boyd, Brennan, Wellingham, Hodge, James McDonald, Judd, J.Bolton, Swan, Wells.

You'd think now that Barlow would be at least top 5 in this year's count. Amazing for a first-year player, regardless of what age he is.

 

[danielnajdek]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2010

How much is Pendlebury paying for the brownlow? Might be worth putting a 100 on him.

 

[Notorious_29]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2010

AG, you have had Keiran Jack for the 3 votes for the last 2 rounds, yet he is not on your leaderboard for 6 votes or more. Just letting you know in case its a mistake.

 

[jonesy86]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2010

How much is Pendlebury paying for the brownlow? Might be worth putting a 100 on him.

Votes in Pies games are like a raffle this year, in all our wins the votes could go to any of 6 or 7 players. Having said that, Pendlebury out-polled Swan last year when Swan was one of the favs.

 

[AG]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2010

AG, you have had Keiran Jack for the 3 votes for the last 2 rounds, yet he is not on your leaderboard for 6 votes or more. Just letting you know in case its a mistake.

Switched McVeigh to BOG last week after I posted. Jack got the 2 instead. So he's on 5 atm. Thanks though.

 

[maxlad]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2010

can someone tell me if the umpires pick showdown/darby medal or is it another source

 

[Halli]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2010

Got my brownlow count up for Round 6 at my Phantom Brownlow Medal website. Was a tough round with some hard games to pick, but Barlow and Judd are running out in front at the moment, with Sandilands not far behind. My previews are at the links below:

Dogs v Saints
Roos v Dees
Swans v Lions
Hawks v Bombers
Crows v Power
Cats v Tigers
Blues v Pies
Eagles v Dockers

Leaderboard

1. Michael BArlow
2 Chris Judd
3. Aaron Sandilands
4. Gary Ablett
5. Jon Brown
6. Jobe Watson
(view full tally)

 

[banta]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2010

can someone tell me if the umpires pick showdown/darby medal or is it another source

pretty sure there's a panel of people, not umpires. i think gerard healy might have been one of them.

 

[Notorious_29]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2010

can someone tell me if the umpires pick showdown/darby medal or is it another source

No the umpires don't vote for the showdown/glendinning medal.

 

[FootyStar#1]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2010

Got my brownlow count up for Round 6 at my Phantom Brownlow Medal website. Was a tough round with some hard games to pick, but Barlow and Judd are running out in front at the moment, with Sandilands not far behind. My previews are at the links below:

Dogs v Saints
Roos v Dees
Swans v Lions
Hawks v Bombers
Crows v Power
Cats v Tigers
Blues v Pies
Eagles v Dockers

Leaderboard

1. Michael BArlow
2 Chris Judd
3. Aaron Sandilands
4. Gary Ablett
5. Jon Brown
6. Jobe Watson
(view full tally)

That was probably sandilands least stand out game for the season, would be extremely surprised to see him get two votes, and would be equally stunned to not see pavlich at least get 1 votes for his 5 goal performance.

 

[banta]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2010

That was probably sandilands least stand out game for the season, would be extremely surprised to see him get two votes, and would be equally stunned to not see pavlich at least get 1 votes for his 5 goal performance.

true, but there were no real standouts during the derby. it was pretty even across the board and freo player's didn't play as well as they have in previous matches. sandilands was one of a few that was playing well early when the eagles were on top, it was more of a case of guys like fyfe, ballantyne, mayne, johnson, pav and mundy stepping up in patches to get them ahead, but its tough to find the clear votes in that game.
but sandilands was involved quite a lot so will probably poll.

 

[Brent24]

Re: Brownlow Medal 2010

I would be pretty surprised if Pendlebury is on 6+ votes.