Hot Topic Carlton 2024 Trade Discussion

[berisha]

I've not been following the trade period too hard outside of the headlines but are we no longer gunning for Houston?

Also how do we get the Campo twins if we use our first pick?

 

[CJMB]

I've not been following the trade period too hard outside of the headlines but are we no longer gunning for Houston?

Also how do we get the Campo twins if we use our first pick?

We are interested in Houston, but not at any price. Seems Pies willing to pay more than we are.

We won't need a first round pick for either of the Camporeale boys. Seems like Ben could get done with some late picks, Lucas might be a 'free hit'.

 

[Jimmae]

Feel like we could have done that Essendon trade if we'd been able to make any headway with trading Owies and Kennedy.

Would have cost us our future 2nd as well, but we'd still have our future first.

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Feel like we could have done that Essendon trade if we'd been able to make any headway with trading Owies and Kennedy.

Would have cost us our future 2nd as well, but we'd still have our future first.

Sides have recognised our lack of list spots and probably think that trumps our desire for draft picks, so they're waiting out these players to see if we will let them go for almost nothing.

 

[Stamos]

Feel like we could have done that Essendon trade if we'd been able to make any headway with trading Owies and Kennedy.

Would have cost us our future 2nd as well, but we'd still have our future first.

How?
Dees gave up their F1, and 2 x 2nds, and 2 x 3rds, and a 4th.

 

[BRADLESTICKS]

We were never getting a 2nd round pick for either Owies or Kennedy they both have little to no value and unfortunately if they find a club that will take them we are likely to get a token 4th round pick or a minor late upgrade.
The club can’t be criticised for a one paced midfielder and a slow forward have little to no value they are doing the right thing trying to move them on.

 

[SurreyBlue]

We were never getting a 2nd round pick for either Owies or Kennedy they both have little to no value and unfortunately if they find a club that will take them we are likely to get a token 4th round pick or a minor late upgrade.
The club can’t be criticised for a one paced midfielder and a slow forward have little to no value they are doing the right thing trying to move them on.

The same club that recruited Hewett and I'll add one positional Hewett?

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Ok so if the trade looks like this:

Port:

Out: Houston

In: Lukosious, Atkins, Richards, Pick 13

GC

Out: Pick 13, Atkins, Lukosious

In: Noble, Collingwood F1

Collingwood

Out: Future 1st, Noble, Richards

In: Houston

It's still a bit unbalanced.

Maybe Collingwood give up a future 3rd to GC?

On Pixel 7a using BigFooty.com mobile app

Atkins, as in Rory Atkins? Hasn't he retired? Either way, he's shot.

This values Lukosius the same as Noble. Pies make out like bandits.

 

[Wickzki]

FMD Gold Coast folded like a deck of cards.

 

[Wickzki]

Atkins, as in Rory Atkins? Hasn't he retired? Either way, he's shot.

This values Lukosius the same as Noble. Pies make out like bandits.

Not retired was looking for opportunities elsewhere

Gold Coast veteran "looking for opportunities elsewhere": AFL trade news

The 30-year-old finished runner-up for the J.J. Liston Trophy for 2024.

www.google.com

 

[SurreyBlue]

This is what happens when the AFL keep throwing picks to teams such as GC - they don't value them!!!!

 

[Coona Blues]

FMD Gold Coast folded like a deck of cards.

Gold Coast have multiple academy selections next year. The new system is very harsh. Zeke Uwland is in pick 1 conversations. They need bulk high selections for 2025 to have any chance of matching for those players. Future firsts are GOLD for the Suns as they will likely be for us in ‘26. Addinsall another first rounder most likely.

This new system goes way too far the other way from the existing/old system.

This is why it has been/is being done. Very few opportunities to get those picks. Our F1 and F2 wasn’t enough for that reason.

 

[BRADLESTICKS]

The same club that recruited Hewett and I'll add one positional Hewett?

And if hewett was put up for trade he would have similar trade value to Kennedy and Owies little to none.

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Not retired was looking for opportunities elsewhere

Gold Coast veteran "looking for opportunities elsewhere": AFL trade news

The 30-year-old finished runner-up for the J.J. Liston Trophy for 2024.

www.google.com

But why would Port?

 

[Wickzki]

But why would Port?

Depth who can be trusted to play a handful of games.

 

[Jimmae]

How?
Dees gave up their F1, and 2 x 2nds, and 2 x 3rds, and a 4th.

Ah, I missed the future first in the initial tweets... that's an awful trade.

 

[Juddrockz]

FMD Gold Coast folded like a deck of cards.

Typical though,this is why the club will never be successful.

 

[Wickzki]

Gold Coast have multiple academy selections next year. The new system is very harsh. Zeke Uwland is in pick 1 conversations. They need bulk high selections for 2025 to have any chance of matching for those players. Future firsts are GOLD for the Suns as they will likely be for us in ‘26. Addinsall another first rounder most likely.

This new system goes way too far the other way from the existing/old system.

This is why it has been/is being done. Very few opportunities to get those picks. Our F1 and F2 wasn’t enough for that reason.

Regardless they could have done the Melbourne trade and come out further ahead than this trade puts them.

Then there's other teams who were offering future picks to them.

This is just bad list management

 

[Drexl 31]

So we have given up on Mr Houston I take it?

 

[Jimmae]

Surely pick 29 disappears from that alleged deal? Lukosius is by far the 2nd most valuable player in the trade.

Port and Collingwood are making out like bandits because Luoksius will immediately sign something along the lines of a 5 year deal.

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Depth who can be trusted to play a handful of games.

You'd think there'd be better DFAs.

List spots are usually at a premium.

 

[Jimmae]

You'd think there'd be better DFAs.

List spots are usually at a premium.

Thought he'd been injured this season, but he's been destroying it in the VFL, maybe the tiniest bit off in fitness?

Port are getting incredible value.

 

[kreuze_missile]

So do we have SDK Petracca Houston and Harley Reid locked in yet?

 

[YeoShuey]

So do we have SDK Petracca Houston and Harley Reid locked in yet?

Remember how people were so confident about getting him during this trade period even though he ruled out leaving?

 

[Magruder]

I think your recollection is faulty.

Some were saying, if it happens it’ll be for less than the excessive price some others proposed.

Not sure anyone though it likely

YeoShuey forgot to quote you.