Banter Who will be better in 2025, Carlton or Collingwood? Part 3

[South of the Yarra]

And the under 24s we are supposed to be afraid of outside of Daicos are:
McReery, Dean, Macrae, Parker, Begg, Eyre, McInness, Long, Steene, Harrison, Allan, Ryan, Jiath, Smit and Demattia.

15 players who you will need to rely on to fill the gaps left by the 30+ year olds in the next year or two and only 3 of them have played 20+ games at AFL level. And only a further 2 between 10-19 games...

Sweet

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

thats not how it works, we will recruit for our needs because we have smart recruiters

Schultz?????

 

[Pistol Night]

Schultz?????

At least you didnt say Beams

 

[HeathySure]

Schultz?????

you are obsessed with shultz lol He was recruited for a reason and when our talls came back to knock the ball down to our smalls he played very well. Our coaching and recruiting staff know what they are doing, you coaching team likes to kick the ball sideways when you have 2 of the best 5 talls in the forward line.

 

[HeathySure]

At least you didnt say Beams

lets not forget Grundy Stephenson and Treloar and giving away salary cap and a number 2 draft pick to GWS, yet we won a flag.
how did we manage that? Absolute fluke obviously

 

[Pistol Night]

you are obsessed with shultz lol He was recruited for a reason and when our talls came back to knock the ball down to our smalls he played very well. Our coaching and recruiting staff know what they are doing, you coaching team likes to kick the ball sideways when you have 2 of the best 5 talls in the forward line.

Kicked 24 goals. Hell improve

 

[carlton_99]

thats not how it works, we will recruit for our needs because we have smart recruiters

every team recruits for their needs - no doubt you will do the same

 

[carlton_99]

Kicked 24 goals. Hell improve

One of the few things I'll agree with Pies fans on here about - will end up being a good deal

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

you are obsessed with shultz lol He was recruited for a reason and when our talls came back to knock the ball down to our smalls he played very well. Our coaching and recruiting staff know what they are doing, you coaching team likes to kick the ball sideways when you have 2 of the best 5 talls in the forward line.

Mate Matt Owies has kicked more snags than that spud. Putrid footballer

 

[leon123]

Remind me what the Pies were doing last weekend?

Having few beers and having a laugh at a team that nearly didnt even score for an entire half of footy. 60 zero, and u reckon ya better than the pies

 

[South of the Yarra]

Mate Matt Owies has kicked more snags than that spud. Putrid footballer

The question is will Sam Walsh ever score another goal?

 

[HeathySure]

Mate Matt Owies has kicked more snags than that spud. Putrid footballer

ithink you will find almost all Freo supporters rate him

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Having few beers and having a laugh at a team that nearly didnt even score for an entire half of footy. 60 zero, and u reckon ya better than the pies

Oldest list in the AFL by a country mile with 0 youth outside of Nicky showing any signs of potential, no first round pick and no links to anyone decent.

Pies are cooked mate

 

[leon123]

Oldest list in the AFL by a country mile with 0 youth outside of Nicky showing any signs of potential, no first round pick and no links to anyone decent.

Pies are cooked mate

Id , say we are mature not old. I'm confident that our VFL side would at least get a point, even just one, just one.. like a rushed behind would do. I think our mature side has beaten your mob twice this year, is that correct?

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Mate Matt Owies has kicked more snags than that spud. Putrid footballer

Owies still doesn't have a contract. What's going on there?
Be just like Carlton to lose their only half decent small forward and keep all the other spuds.

 

[WalshistheGOAT]

Owies still doesn't have a contract. What's going on there?
Be just like Carlton to lose their only half decent small forward and keep all the other spuds.

Half decent? He's almost as bad as Schultz

 

[South of the Yarra]

Am I right in saying two entire generations have never seen Carlton win a Premiership? This can't be right. Surely?

Different generations and their approximate birth years:

1. The Greatest Generation (GI Generation): Born 1901–1927
2. The Silent Generation: Born 1928–1945
3. Baby Boom Generation: Born 1946–1964
4. Generation X: Born 1965–1980
5. Millennial Generation or Generation Y: Born 1981–1996
6. Generation Z or iGen: Born 1997–2010
7. Generation Alpha: Born 2010-2024

 

[Cleansweep17]

Pendlebury - 37
Sidebottom - 34
Howe - 34
Cox - 34
Mihocek - 32
Elliot -32
WHE - 31
Crisp - 31
Titch - 31
Mcstay - 29
Cameron -29
Degoey - 29
Moore - 29


Boy oh boy wowee. #retirementvillage

Ginnivan knew what he was doing. Guy is genius for leaving that sinking ship.

 

[Cleansweep17]

Am I right in saying two entire generations have never seen Carlton win a Premiership? This can't be right. Surely?

Different generations and their approximate birth years:

1. The Greatest Generation (GI Generation): Born 1901–1927
2. The Silent Generation: Born 1928–1945
3. Baby Boom Generation: Born 1946–1964
4. Generation X: Born 1965–1980
5. Millennial Generation or Generation Y: Born 1981–1996
6. Generation Z or iGen: Born 1997–2010
7. Generation Alpha: Born 2010-2024

Now do a breakdown of Pies flags during those generations.

Also when did TV come to Australia? You should know.

 

[Fadge]

Am I right in saying two entire generations have never seen Carlton win a Premiership? This can't be right. Surely?

Different generations and their approximate birth years:

1. The Greatest Generation (GI Generation): Born 1901–1927
2. The Silent Generation: Born 1928–1945
3. Baby Boom Generation: Born 1946–1964
4. Generation X: Born 1965–1980
5. Millennial Generation or Generation Y: Born 1981–1996
6. Generation Z or iGen: Born 1997–2010
7. Generation Alpha: Born 2010-2024

Oops.

It seems Richmond have also had two consecutive generations not see a flag at a stage during their bleak history.

Now we can see why Falcon has rushed to the defence of the Carlton folk...

 

[South of the Yarra]

Now do a breakdown of Pies flags during those generations.

Also when did TV come to Australia? You should know.

Yes, Collingwood won a flag in every generation except one. Thanks for proving my point. Sorry can't help you, was born in the bush on a river. Didn't have electricity let alone a TV.

 

[leon123]

Ginnivan knew what he was doing. Guy is genius for leaving that sinking ship.

If pies are sinking, richmond is the titanic

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Half decent? He's almost as bad as Schultz

He's your best small forward.
Why no contract yet?
He better not be coming to Collingwood ffs!

 

[Scritchyscroony]

Ginnivan knew what he was doing. Guy is genius for leaving that sinking ship.

Meanwhile at Richmond......Baker, Rioli, Graham and Bolton all jumping onto the trade request life raft.
Spoon threepeat incoming.

 

[South of the Yarra]