MVP Carlton v Brisbane Round 12 2011

[Sin City]

5. Chris Judd
4. Andrew Walker
3. Marc Murphy
2. Lachie Henderson
1. Zach Touhy

BYP: Zach Touhy

Rookie of the year eligible
Zach Tuohy
Ed Curnow
Chris Yarran
Nick Duigan
David Ellard

 

[Team Mo']

Possibly the toughest yet. Will decide after the game. The Rookie of the year is almost impossible for todays game...

 

[Stig O'Hara]

Gunna have to check the cheat sheet.

Culled it down to around 14 players atm.

 

[Sin City]

Possibly the toughest yet. Will decide after the game. The Rookie of the year is almost impossible for todays game...

Sure was, could've easily given Simpson, Scotland, Jamison, Robinson, Ellard, Betts votes.

 

[Team Mo']

5. Murphy
4. Walker
3. Jamison
2. Henderson
1. Judd

BYP - Ellard. In and under was great; tackled like a man possessed.

Unlucky: Scotland, Carrazzo, Simpson, Betts and probably a few more.

**** forgot Robinson. He deserves at least a vote for his attack on the ball...

 

[Malifice]

5. Jamison
4. Walker
3. Judd
2. Robinson
1. Carrazzo

Apologies: Simpson, Scotland, Tuohy

 

[BluesMan]

5. Murphy
4. Walker
3. Judd
2. Scotland
1. Ellard

roty, ellard, touhy take your pick

 

[PooMonkey]

5. Murphy
4. Judd
3. Walker
2. Scotland
1. Robinson

BYP: Ellard

 

[Stig O'Hara]

5. Judd
4. Walker
3. Murphy
2. Robinson
1. Tuohy

BYP Tuohy

 

[juddsentant517]

shit this is hard. A true 21 player performance (a bit unfair to put Bower one out on Brown, after a season out on the game ).

5 - Chris Judd - 5 inside 50's in a quarter. Really tore the game apart in the 3rd quarter. Was outstanding as always
4 - Marc Murphy - Another 4 quarter performance. Fast becoming the best player in the AFL. Has he had a poor game this season?
3 - Mitch Robinson - I GET KNOCKED DOWN, AND I GET UP AGAIN. YOU NEVER GONNA SEE ME DOWN. - song illustrates his performance perfectly.
2 - Andrew Walker - 11:0 in two games. In a fairly inaccurate team, it's nice to be able to rely on someone as a certainty to kick the goal
1 - Michael Jamison - The only way Brisbane were a chance was if Brown fired. Jamison (with heaps of helped) stopped that.

BYP: Extremely tough - thought David Ellard was fantastic. Surprisingly, he is a great kick (in field and at goal).

Unlucky - Everyone - more specifically - Heath Scotland (mr consistency) Eddie Betts (was everywhere) Kade Simpson (mr consistency x2) Lachie Henderson (Played his role perfectly, started out on fire, where does Waite play now?) Zac Touhy (Man = potential. Fantastic goal) and Shaun Hampson (was probably the best game i've seen him play. Great hanger)

 

[zeeCFC]

5. Robinson
4. Judd
3. Walker
2. Murphy
1. Betts

BYP - Ellard

Very tough to decide

 

[AndyWalkersGirl]

Great game by so many of our boys today, well done Blues. Welcome back to Hendo and Kreuzer who gave more than what we could have asked for. Bower to improve each week.

5. Judd
4. Robbo - his enthusiasm just lifts the others.
3. Jamo - held a superstar.
2. Walker.
1. Ellard.


Carlton, I love you

 

[lionel_luthor]

5.Robinson
4.Jamison
3.Judd
2.Walker
1.Tuohy

 

[aristeas]

5 Murphy - Great game, was targeted and got roughly dealt with two or three times and bounced back like a champ.
4 Walker - 5 goals with perfect accuracy & a towering mark. Did the early damage again that broke the other side.
3 Betts - has been improving week by week, now just so skillful and smart all around the ground, made several goals.
2 Jamison - No Brown, no Brisbane. take off Jamo - Brown starts scoring goals.
1 Gibbs - Just another brilliant performance. 1 in a 100.

RookieOTY: Yarran (Tuohy very unlucky)

Unlucky:

Hampson - more than skillful in the ruck, starting to show real promise - if only he could kick straight...

Henderson - Marked well all day and gave real hope for depth in our froward line - Say goodnight Irish.

Yarran - Speed and skill with a football brain - it's all upside.

Robinson - Mitch was great early but faded after two heavy knocks - never gonna develop a football brain if you don't protect your head.

Garlett - brilliant game again, slick and slippery in the forward line.

Scotland, Simpson, Thornton, Ellard, Curnow - great work all day. Reliable and sharp, skillful and gutsy.

 

[juddsentant517]

5 Murphy - Great game, was targeted and got roughly dealt with two or three times and bounced back like a champ.
4 Walker - 5 goals with perfect accuracy & a towering mark. Did the early damage again that broke the other side.
3 Betts - has been improving week by week, now just so skillful and smart all around the ground, made several goals.
2 Jamison - No Brown, no Brisbane. take off Jamo - Brown starts scoring goals.
1 Gibbs - Just another brilliant performance. 1 in a 100.

RookieOTY: Yarran (Tuohy very unlucky)

Unlucky:

Hampson - more than skillful in the ruck, starting to show real promise - if only he could kick straight...

Henderson - Marked well all day and gave real hope for depth in our froward line - Say goodnight Irish.

Yarran - Speed and skill with a football brain - it's all upside.

Robinson - Mitch was great early but faded after two heavy knocks - never gonna develop a football brain if you don't protect your head.

Garlett - brilliant game again, slick and slippery in the forward line.

Scotland, Simpson, Thornton, Ellard, Curnow - great work all day. Reliable and sharp, skillful and gutsy.

Surely Judd makes at least the 'unlucky' section.

 

[TerryWallet]

5. Ellard
4. Robinson
3. Walker
2. Gibbs
1. Judd

Rookie: Ellard


20 odd good players today. No-one stood out. Our pressure and tackling was the stand out factor today so i voted somewhat accordingly.

Observation: Gibbs is starting to remind me of one of my favorite players Jimmy Bartel. They are 1 on 1 players and win 8/10 1 on 1's. Great balance and can overhead mark in pressure contests. Also consistent and durable.

Kudos to Ratten, i think he pegged Gibbs as this kind of footballer and not a pure onballer before everyone else.

 

[Curnowed]

5 Judd
4 Murphy
3 Jamison
2 Walker
1 Robbo

Rookie Yarran

 

[zeeCFC]

Ellard had a massive game...most tackles and 2 goals? should be everyone's BYP

 

[Laybel]

5 Robinson
4 Judd
3 Murphy
2 Walker
1 Ellard

 

[Wickzki]

5. Marc Murphy -- Brilliant. This kid is the best player in the game right now. No doubt in my mind.

4. Michael Jamison -- absolutely obliterated Jon Brown. Made him look like a second rate over the hill vet who should be set out for pasture.

3. Andrew Walker -- Can a non-power forward win the Coleman medal? If he keeps up this form and sticks with the Blues he's a dark horse next year.

2. Chris Judd -- Typical Judd game.

1. Zach Tuohy -- Awesome performance capped off by a beautiful goal.

Unlucky: Lachie Henderson

Rookie: Zach Tuohy

 

[The Grover]

5. Murphy
4. Walker
3. Jamison ( only slid down to 3 due to sub off )
2. Robinson
1. Gibbs

BYP: Ellard

 

[berisha]

5 :: Murphy
4 :: Judd
3 :: Scotland
2 :: Tuohy
1 :: Hampson

 

[Judderson]

5- Jamison
4- Murphy
3- Robinson
2- Judd
1- Henderson

BYP: Ellard

Unlucky: Ellard, Tuohy, Hampson, Scotland, Simpson and many others

 

[blues4flag]

Truth be told, no idea.

5. Mitch Robinson (thought he was ridiculously good with his attack on the footy)
4. Michael Jamison (slaughtered Brown when he was on him)
3. Marc Murphy (played forward almost exclusively in the 2nd half, picking up 28 touches and kicking 2)
2. Andrew Walker (5.0 after 6.0 last week )
1. Lachie Henderson (thought he was brilliant early)

ROTY: David Ellard

 

[NWTYRX]

5. Walker
4. Judd
3. Murphy
2. Henderson
1. Jamison

BYP - Tuohy