Preview Changes & Pre-match Discussion - Round 21 vs. Hawthorn, MCG Sun 08/08 @ 2:10pm

[Brent24]

Atm Noble is on the wing a role Daicos can very much play to higher standard

Can, but hasn't this season. Daicos has had a pretty underwhelming season after his breakout year last year.
Noble's last month has been superior to anything Daicos has produced this year.

 

[TradeDraft]

Can, but hasn't this season. Daicos has had a pretty underwhelming season after his breakout year last year.
Noble's last month has been superior to anything Daicos has produced this year.

Daicos started to come good half way thru the Season but then sadly Injury Struck.

Yes he did have a Slow Start of the Season

 

[mike123]

Can, but hasn't this season. Daicos has had a pretty underwhelming season after his breakout year last year.
Noble's last month has been superior to anything Daicos has produced this year.

Daicos took a few weeks to hit form and dropped off the last few weeks but he was genuinely good for the middle part.

 

[jackcass]

Atm Noble is on the wing a role Daicos can very much play to higher standard

I don't get all the angst about Daicos having to wait another week.

 

[jackcass]

Can, but hasn't this season. Daicos has had a pretty underwhelming season after his breakout year last year.
Noble's last month has been superior to anything Daicos has produced this year.

Daics has moved into the centre square this year so learning a new role. I think he's been pretty solid for much of the year given that. Not sure why we'd want to shift him back out of that centre square group. Especially when the guy people want him to replace doesn't deserve to be omitted.

 

[mike123]

I don't get all the angst about Daicos having to wait another week.

There’s no angst from me, I’m just pointing out Noble has played on the wing lately, the position Daicos broke out in.

 

[jackcass]

There’s no angst from me, I’m just pointing out Noble has played on the wing lately, the position Daicos broke out in.

Yeah, wasn’t pointing fingers, just making the observation

 

[Ulahoopski]

Unbelievably, Pies still a mathematical chance for finals if they keep winning and other results, however unlikely, fall our way. Barracking for Cats, Suns, North, Sydney, Dogs and lions this week.

How to doom a possibility: post it on BF. The first and most likely result we needed gets thwarted by the Giants. Unbereavable.

 

[Horaceg]

How to doom a possibility: post it on BF. The first and most likely result we needed gets thwarted by the Giants. Unbereavable.

And any chance Harvey had.

 

[MyManLynch]

How to doom a possibility: post it on BF. The first and most likely result we needed gets thwarted by the Giants. Unbereavable.

& we were so close
Put out of the finals by an undermanned Giants team again.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

I don't get all the angst about Daicos having to wait another week.

He’s not coming back from a knee or soft tissue injury that would justify caution.

 

[whiskeytown]

He’s not coming back from a knee or soft tissue injury that would justify caution.

Clearly he is not 100% right in terms of touch, practice etc

Otherwise he’d be in the best 22... cause he’s walkup best 22 when 100%

 

[stormskye]

the fact daicos is left out is a good thing. We have competition for spots. It’s a good problem to have. Another week won’t hurt, though no vfl ruins any plan to ease him back

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Clearly he is not 100% right in terms of touch, practice etc

Otherwise he’d be in the best 22... cause he’s walkup best 22 when 100%

He’ll be the best sub bench player we have had all year.

Surely it’s between him and Wilson

 

[Ron]

With the Suns winning and now North looking like a massive chance to beat the Tigers, we have to win tomorrow to avoid the spoon.
Lose tomorrow, and fail to beat the Lions and Bombers, and if North beat the Crows and hold on today, then we will be 18th

 

[Toecrusher]

With the Suns winning and now North looking like a massive chance to beat the Tigers, we have to win tomorrow to avoid the spoon.
Lose tomorrow, and fail to beat the Lions and Bombers, and if North beat the Crows and hold on today, then we will be 18th

On the same page as this post, we just lost our last chance to sneak into the 8 when GWS won. Now we're finishing with the wooden spoon?
Gee whiz it's a tight season!

 

[TradeDraft]

With the Suns winning and now North looking like a massive chance to beat the Tigers, we have to win tomorrow to avoid the spoon.
Lose tomorrow, and fail to beat the Lions and Bombers, and if North beat the Crows and hold on today, then we will be 18th

Richmond Shown Up now.

Beat Hawks then we Gurantee to miss the Spoon

 

[Toecrusher]

Ultimately Harvey rates John Noble ahead of Josh Daicos.

Embarrassing !

If Daicos comes in, it's not necessarily Noble he'll replace.
He might come in and give Grundy a rest, meaning Harvey prefers Daicos over Grundy.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

With the Suns winning and now North looking like a massive chance to beat the Tigers, we have to win tomorrow to avoid the spoon.
Lose tomorrow, and fail to beat the Lions and Bombers, and if North beat the Crows and hold on today, then we will be 18th

This dated well.

 

[MyManLynch]

the fact daicos is left out is a good thing. We have competition for spots. It’s a good problem to have. Another week won’t hurt, though no vfl ruins any plan to ease him back

He is playing in VFL scratch match this weekend.

 

[TradeDraft]

Win today and we go above Carlton on the Ladder

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Win today and we go above Carlton on the Ladder

?

 

[Jen2310]

 

[MyManLynch]

Win today and we go above Carlton on the Ladder

GoldCoast, we are 8 points behind Carlton

 

[MyManLynch]

So Maynard gives him a hug, later in the day will smash him…