Traded Chris Yarran [to Richmond for Pick 19]

[Theseventhhamster]

Seedsman?

Works for me.

 

[SickQwon]

"I can't tell the difference between complete fabricated bullshit i made up in my head & objective fact" - tonywilson43

 

[Tony_Clifton]

Ummm, I'm late to discussion.
Why aren't West Coast and Freo interested in him given his ties to Walters and Nic Nat. Freo don't have many players capable of disposing of the ball like Yarran. What is a realistic view of his worth in terms of draft pics? Apologies but there are 126 pages of threads devoted to him.

 

[THE_GUN]

I believe that Carlton are well within their rights to ask for a 1st round selection, I rate yarran at around pick #20 but we dont have that and cant see sos accepting #30+.

I think deal will be done for #12 for yarran and probably carltons 3rd coming back , Lets be honest he was a #6 and if we are prepared to offer up $450k a year for a contracted player - We will get the deal done and should be around the 1st pick which is in itself #12

We will have a Gun & He is in his prime and ready to tear it up

 

[My name geoff]

I believe that Carlton are well within their rights to ask for a 1st round selection, I rate yarran at around pick #20 but we dont have that and cant see sos accepting #30+.

I think deal will be done for #12 for yarran and probably carltons 3rd coming back , Lets be honest he was a #6 and if we are prepared to offer up $450k a year for a contracted player - We will get the deal done and should be around the 1st pick which is in itself #12

We will have a Gun & He is in his prime and ready to tear it up

I commend you

 

[gandaal]

This is a very long thread for a discussion about a late second round player.

 

[Bic]

I believe that Carlton are well within their rights to ask for a 1st round selection, I rate yarran at around pick #20 but we dont have that and cant see sos accepting #30+.

I think deal will be done for #12 for yarran and probably carltons 3rd coming back , Lets be honest he was a #6 and if we are prepared to offer up $450k a year for a contracted player - We will get the deal done and should be around the 1st pick which is in itself #12

We will have a Gun & He is in his prime and ready to tear it up

Firstly, thank you for speaking sense.

I could also see something around:

Carlton: Pick #12, Pick #30
Richmond: Yarran, Pick #20ish (Bell), Carlton's 3rd

 

[Sydswans0512]

Firstly, thank you for speaking sense.

I could also see something around:

Carlton: Pick #12, Pick #30
Richmond: Yarran, Pick #20ish (Bell), Carlton's 3rd

Will you get pick 20 for Bell?

 

[Talidorian]

Clearly he'll just walk to the PSD...

 

[Bic]

Will you get pick 20 for Bell?

I think Brisbane could end up with 3 picks around 20-23.

Assuming one of them would come to us for Bell.

 

[Bic]

Clearly he'll just walk to the PSD...

I'm going to ignore your poor attempt at a troll and remind you he is contracted.

 

[Sydswans0512]

I think Brisbane could end up with 3 picks around 20-23.

Assuming one of them would come to us for Bell.

To be honest I don't think Bell very good

 

[Bic]

To be honest I don't think Bell very good

Has shown rapid development, a fierce desire for the contest, and runs all day.

He lacks a lot of polish.

A high half forward who runs all day and can have stints in the midfield - would finish top 10 bnf at the Lions.

I think he is worth pick 20ish

 

[Sydswans0512]

Has shown rapid development, a fierce desire for the contest, and runs all day.

He lacks a lot of polish.

A high half forward who runs all day and can have stints in the midfield - would finish top 10 bnf at the Lions.

I think he is worth pick 20ish

Just doesn't have a football brain
Can't see him getting any better

 

[Suma Magic]

Pick 20 about right for Yarran. Overs for Bell.

 

[Bic]

Just doesn't have a football brain
Can't see him getting any better

I thought the same thing 3 years ago, 2 years ago, and this year. Has proved me wrong every time!

Until he bucks the trend, got to back him in!

 

[Sydswans0512]

I thought the same thing 3 years ago, 2 years ago, and this year. Has proved me wrong every time!

Until he bucks the trend, got to back him in!

Reminds me a lot of Cam Ellis Yollmen

 

[Barnzy]

Firstly, thank you for speaking sense.

I could also see something around:

Carlton: Pick #12, Pick #30
Richmond: Yarran, Pick #20ish (Bell), Carlton's 3rd

LOL. Bell is not worth pick 20 and he's not wanted I would imagine. You won't be getting pick 12 either. Yarran was in the reserves for a wooden spoon team picking up sub 10 disposals in the latter half of the year. His management has already said he won't be playing for Carlton next year and wants to leave. Contracts are not worth much these days in trade stakes because clubs rarely hold players against their will and there's been a lot of bad press between Carlton and Yarran.

McKay said the Blues were unlikely to try to persuade players to stay at the Blues.

“If people don’t want to play for Carlton there’s no point them being there to be quite honest,” he said.

Richmond are also interested and strong suitors for Harley Bennell. A similar type but just miles better. If a first round pick is going anywhere, it's for him. Tipping you'll get our second round pick or we'll just trade for Bennell.

 

[Barnzy]

Ummm, I'm late to discussion.
Why aren't West Coast and Freo interested in him given his ties to Walters and Nic Nat. Freo don't have many players capable of disposing of the ball like Yarran. What is a realistic view of his worth in terms of draft pics? Apologies but there are 126 pages of threads devoted to him.

Because while he moves like a gazelle and his kicking action looks sublime, when you look a little closer and analyze his actually output, he's just not that good.

 

[Bic]

LOL. Bell is not worth pick 20 and he's not wanted I would imagine. You won't be getting pick 12 either. Yarran was in the reserves for a wooden spoon team picking up sub 10 disposals in the latter half of the year. His management has already said he won't be playing for Carlton next year and wants to leave. Contracts are not worth much these days in trade stakes because clubs rarely hold players against their will and there's been a lot of bad press between Carlton and Yarran.

McKay said the Blues were unlikely to try to persuade players to stay at the Blues.

“If people don’t want to play for Carlton there’s no point them being there to be quite honest,” he said.

Richmond are also interested and strong suitors for Harley Bennell. A similar type but just miles better. If a first round pick is going anywhere, it's for him. Tipping you'll get our second round pick or we'll just trade for Bennell.

Time will tell. To be honest I plucked pick 20 from what I have been reading across the Carlton/Brisbane boards.

Why would Bennell want to come to Tigerland? Party with Dusty? I think Bennell heads to WA.

Yarran will be all the Tigers have left to chase after losing out on Treloar/Motlop/Bennell. Worrying signs if your "window" is currently open.

 

[Sweet Jesus]

I believe that Carlton are well within their rights to ask for a 1st round selection

Sure, they can ask.

Lets be honest he was a #6

Lets be honest Jack Watts was a #1

 

[Sweet Jesus]

Why aren't West Coast and Freo interested in him given his ties to Walters and Nic Nat.

I'm not sure that's a reason to recruit a player.

 

[Tiger2709]

Time will tell. To be honest I plucked pick 20 from what I have been reading across the Carlton/Brisbane boards.

Why would Bennell want to come to Tigerland? Party with Dusty? I think Bennell heads to WA.

Yarran will be all the Tigers have left to chase after losing out on Treloar/Motlop/Bennell. Worrying signs if your "window" is currently open.

The only thing that would stop Bennel would be a desire to return home to his family in WA, we have proven with Martin that we can deal with troubled players and we dont have players requesting release so one would assume we would be a good place for him.

Our only issue in attracting someone like Treloar is we wont pay overs for players, which Im personally happy about.

 

[Cringle]

Just doesn't have a football brain
Can't see him getting any better

Received 2x 3 votes (BOG) in a team that came 18th.

You've probably watched a handful of Carlton games this year... or perhaps a few passages of play here and there and come up with a conclusion from that.

inb4 "nah i watched every carlton game this year and he's not good"

 

[Sydswans0512]

Received 2x 3 votes (BOG) in a team that came 18th.

You've probably watched a handful of Carlton games this year... or perhaps a few passages of play here and there and come up with a conclusion from that.

inb4 "nah i watched every carlton game this year and he's not good"

98% of people would agree with me
The 2% would be Carlton supporters