List Mgmt. COLLINGWOOD Trade and F/A Discussion 2023

[Hardas]

Not Really much else to talk about now

I get that, Dave.
Much more about my state of mind than criticism of others.
It DOES make it easier to wait, knowing we've got great operators in charge though, hey.

 

[Hazz]

sad he has to miss out on back to back after missing out with Geelong

He can still go b2b. It’ll just be 4peat for the rest.

 

[loki04]

Had him, wasn't a huge fan. Glad he got a bit better for you guys.

He is a flawed player and we often lost momentum when he was in the ruck but played his role in our flag and is now a premiership player for life.

 

[Hardas]

FYI,
OUR CURRENT 2023 PICKS: 19, 33, 38 & wait for it, 79.

Plus, all of 2024's, of course.

Anybody got any other possible trade targets, or DFA's for this year besides Shultz & Haynes?

 

[soreplums]

Such a shame we didn't have more leverage then, I'm assuming that was The Giants?

That was my mail. Pre prelim

 

[nahnah]

FYI,
OUR CURRENT 2023 PICKS: 19, 33, 38 & wait for it, 79.

Plus, all of 2024's, of course.

Anybody got any other possible trade targets, or DFA's for this year besides Shultz & Haynes?

If we rated Spicer ahead of McCreery and Ginnivan at time of draft we might look at him as a rookie if North havent completely cooked his development imo

 

[Bogsey]

He is a flawed player and we often lost momentum when he was in the ruck but played his role in our flag and is now a premiership player for life.

He is. I'm not his biggest fan, but honestly, how many rucks in the AFL can you say AREN'T flawed. To me, he sits between the best 15-20 rucks in the game.
Although, if our game allows for us to get away with that level of play, then I say stick with him, but we could obviously upgrade if the opportunity was there.

 

[Mick F]

Could losing out on the captaincy have had some role in his decision to leave? (along with all the other reasons)

He just likes playing midfield, like bowlers like bowling.

 

[MooreDaicos]

FYI,
OUR CURRENT 2023 PICKS: 19, 33, 38 & wait for it, 79.

Plus, all of 2024's, of course.

Anybody got any other possible trade targets, or DFA's for this year besides Shultz & Haynes?

What about...



Sorry, stupid copy and paste lol

Emerson Jeka?

 

[KinderSmock]

If we rated Spicer ahead of McCreery and Ginnivan at time of draft we might look at him as a rookie if North havent completely cooked his development imo

Spicer was overhyped. Another talent claimed to be the next Rioli but nothing special in the end.

 

[Apex36]

If we rated Spicer ahead of McCreery and Ginnivan at time of draft we might look at him as a rookie if North havent completely cooked his development imo

We got Beau, Hill, Ginnivan and within the next week, Schultz since then. I see no reason for us to pursue Spicer anymore, even if Hine did like him a few years ago.

 

[TradeDraft]

Spicer was overhyped. Another talent claimed to be the next Rioli but nothing special in the end.

and just been De-Listed

 

[nahnah]

We got Beau, Hill, Ginnivan and within the next week, Schultz since then. I see no reason for us to pursue Spicer anymore, even if Hine did like him a few years ago.

We also have Harrison lol but I just view it as replacing Murley on rookie list if they rate him

 

[upnsmoke]

Lol

Sure Pies can get Ugle Hagan...

But it will cost them De Goey plus.


So doubt Pies do that nor Bulldogs also.

 

[KinderSmock]

Lol

Sure Pies can get Ugle Hagan...

But it will cost them De Goey plus.


So doubt Pies do that nor Bulldogs also.

It's a Facebook rumour. Very unlikely at this stage unless Bevo decides to pick on JUH and cause some trade fireworks. If the Dogs miss finals again, I would expect more than one player to leave.

 

[KinderSmock]

What about...

View attachment 1829544

Sorry, stupid copy and paste lol

Emerson Jeka?

Nothing special again. Hawks were happy to let him go.

Rather than trying to recycle straight out of the system, why not hit the state leagues? North signed Toby Pink, who had a great year in the SANFL. Reckon we do that rather than finding a player who is out as is. I know Oleg paid off but for every Oleg there is someone who ends up out of the system straight away.

 

[Jen2310]

We also have Harrison lol but I just view it as replacing Murley on rookie list if they rate him

Markov would replace Murley on the rookie list. Unless we do a rookie upgrade


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[JuniorB]

2017 draft. A few of these players on the move..O'Brien delisted; SOS and his recruiting lol

Top 20

Rayner
Brayshaw
Dow (geez)
LDU
Cerra
Stevo
Hunter Clark
Coffield
Naughton
O'Brien
Bonner
Fogarty
Brander
Ling
Bailey
Richards
Higgins
Starcevich
Powell
CCJ

I still shake my head that we picked Stevo over Naughton.

 

[danielnajdek]

I still shake my head that we picked Stevo over Naughton.

Hindsight it was a shit decision.

 

[nahnah]

Markov would replace Murley on the rookie list. Unless we do a rookie upgrade


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

I mean in terms of number of players on our list that would play as smaller forward half players

 

[JuniorB]

Too much. I have no idea what the contract is worth but given their logo appears in every single graphic put out by the AFL on social media, it surely is a fair amount of money.

My car came fitted with Conti tyres - good grip, but they were rooted after 20K.

 

[soreplums]

why did the Holmes rumours die, I want him

Might be extending

 

[Venkman]

I still shake my head that we picked Stevo over Naughton.

And we've needed a marking player since forever. Stevo not a bad pick though really, just not the type of player you use a high pick on.

 

[unplugged]

I still shake my head that we picked Stevo over Naughton.

I don't. Stevo nearly won us a flag.

 

[Pistol Night]

I don't. Stevo nearly won us a flag.

Ironically the 2018-2019 Stevo with confidence and 2 years in Flys system would be a huge weapon in this side. Sliding doors moment I know considering his career trajectory now.