List Mgmt. COLLINGWOOD Trade and F/A Discussion 2023

[Jen2310]

How do we know it's not Ginni's double in Bali?

Conspiracies, I like it.

 

[PieLebo87]

We seem to do well with Fremantle recruits.

 

[sr36]

Hes an elite KPF in the making. I actually rate him higher than the kings as he has a more rounded game.

He went at pick 1 (nga) and has only improved his value.

He would cost at least two top 10 picks. Even then dogs would dig for more

So you think we've kept Kelly as a like for like replacement to get it across the line.

 

[KinderSmock]

Conspiracies, I like it.

Given how boring snoring today was, we really need something to speculate over. Friday won't have much happen given deadline week needs heat.

 

[Mollythedolly]

They won the flag and had pick 18, under the compensation rules, they can't get a pick before their first pick, pick 19 was the best pick they could get. It kinda sucks though, to lose a quality player like that.

AFL specifically changed the rules to allow them to give higher compo if the deal merits it (ie a Buddy deal level). Not sure if they’ve done it yet but others can probably confirm if they have/haven’t, but they have the capacity to do it when apportioning compo.

 

[partypie]

Just did a bit of rough math based on the three Suns bid matches and given they'll need to use 4 picks before 33 and 6 picks before 38 to match we're likely to end up with 33->30 and 38->35 just from the three Suns academy bid matches.

Doesn't look like there are any other bid matches which will affect our current draft picks in a positive manner on draft day.

 

[DasItMayne]

View attachment 1829714

We seem to do well with Fremantle recruits.

 

[Soups]

Can already see the miss spelling of Schultz’s name, is going to be a problem

 

[SchuPie]

FB rumour was Ginni for Hawthorn’s future first. I’d take it.

FWIW I’m hearing schulz for our future first (hope not) and we’ll get Billings late In draft week

Dear God, no
Stop trading away our high-end picks
Bearable this year when we know what the pick is.
What happens if we lose 18 matches by a point in 2024 and end up trading pick 2-5 for Schultz?
Seriously, whether true or not, hearing this makes me so angry

Give our 2023 first, maybe a sweetener, or don’t do trade

 

[partypie]

The change in the rules was specifically made because of the inequity of Buddy’s compo. They’d likely get pick 1 under the current system.

No they wouldn't. One of the ingredients in the secret recipe is the current status of the club involved which is something the committee can factor in at their discretion. Right now the system would produce a result of pick 19 for a first round-worthy contract offer and that is probably where it would stay for the reigning premier.

There would be a massive outcry and it would be contrary to all of the equalisation provisions the league has in place to award the premiers pick 1 for a FA departure.

 

[Fat Jesus]

Dear God, no
Stop trading away our high-end picks
Bearable this year when we know what the pick is.
What happens if we lose 18 matches by a point in 2024 and end up trading pick 2-5 for Schultz?
Seriously, whether true or not, hearing this makes me so angry

Give our 2023 first, maybe a sweetener, or don’t do trade

We will finish top 4 next season.
Great side with a great gameplan

 

[Pedro]

View attachment 1829714

We seem to do well with Fremantle recruits.

And they aren't even close to the best of them

 

[4tone]

No Schultz has toured AIA centre and done a fitness test reports?

 

[Jekyll and Hyde]

They wanted a urine, stool, and semen sample. He mailed back a pair of jocks.

And the pair he mailed back weren't even his!

 

[SchuPie]

We will finish top 4 next season.
Great side with a great gameplan

It’s impossible for us to be any closer to the end of the first round - let’s just trade a known value (in a weak draft)

 

[TakingThePies]

It will go down the Wire with the Shultz Trade

It won't.. but the Pies are occupied, trying to make another deal.

 

[WalterBlaknWhte]

It won't.. but the Pies are occupied, trying to make another deal.

The Steven May to Collingwood story won't go away

 

[TakingThePies]

I have heard a rumour from a semi-connected Hawks supporter that Ginni had a medical at Hawthorn today

He just arrived overseas 3 days ago hahahaa

 

[Antz]

It won't.. but the Pies are occupied, trying to make another deal.

Hopefully, we get the Schultz trade done tomorrow.

 

[Jen2310]

Given how boring snoring today was, we really need something to speculate over. Friday won't have much happen given deadline week needs heat.

I agree, it was already meant to be a slow trade period, and so they are trying to space it out for the final feww days lol

 

[SchuPie]

It won't.. but the Pies are occupied, trying to make another deal.

Picks or player?

 

[gerryg400]

At least Ginni didn’t go to Mad Monday dressed as Clayton Oliver? Now that would have been in poor taste…

He went as Damien Oliver.

 

[KinderSmock]

I agree, it was already meant to be a slow trade period, and so they are trying to space it out for the final feww days lol

Unfortunately. If I was running it, I'd have it as a three day event. First day, free agency, next two are trade. Not long after have a draft. This would turn it into a mega, televisable event and be over and done with in a timely fashion. Never happening as they'd fall out of the news cycle but there comes a point where mind numbing chit chat isn't worth it.

 

[JuniorB]

Can already see the miss spelling of Schultz’s name, is going to be a problem

It's already a problem for Ed Allan

 

[Horaceg]

He just arrived overseas 3 days ago hahahaa

Medical via Zoom