List Mgmt. COLLINGWOOD Trade and F/A Discussion 2023

[gouki88]

I think back to adams comments re the daicos tag at half time during the hawthorn game, something along the lines of ‘he needs to learn to deal with it if he wants to play midfield’, at the time they seemed odd comments as it looked like he was having a crack at daicos for struggling that day, in hindsight perhaps they were a sign of a player frustrated that he had moved down the midfield pecking order.

That one struck me as poor when I saw it live. Good call

 

[Scodog10]

I’m just going to put it out there again

I’ve softened since Friday on this a touch with the news it’s a 3 year contract. It certainly puts 23 in play, IMO.

 

[Chrispiesssss]

Hawks wanted Titch out. We don't want Adams out. So he probably has more trade value.

I don’t think they publicly stated that they wanted Titch out. It was more “we don’t mind if he leaves” similar vibe to Adams.

 

[haydenboii]

I would ask the question of Will Hayward. Much improved defensively over the last two years and can contribute 30 goals or more.

Like this a lot very good overhead. But doubt Sydney would be willing to let him go

 

[DopeMaster]

So what’s the master plan here? Obviously this has been going on in the background for some time.

I find it difficult to believe we would weaken our 22 when B2B is a prospect.

Have a feeling something is in the works here, and this is just the first domino to fall…..

 

[Moore of the Same]

23 should be in play for Adams. Swans are looking to recruit a contracted, best 22 player at the best team in the league, to be a best 22 player at their club. Anything less feels like unders.

 

[Moore of the Same]

I don’t think they publicly stated that they wanted Titch out. It was more “we don’t mind if he leaves” similar vibe to Adams.

I think the way they used him last year was a very public statement that they didn't want him at Hawthorn any more.

 

[KinderSmock]

I don’t think they publicly stated that they wanted Titch out. It was more “we don’t mind if he leaves” similar vibe to Adams.

No. Hawthorn were pushing for Mitchell to leave and chipped in. We're not going to be chipping in to pay Adams' salary.

 

[adammania9]

Pies: North 2024 2nd round compensation

Swans: Grundy, Adams

North: Pick 23 (SYD), Stephens

Demons: Pick 31(SYD) & Pick 36 (Pies)

Not sure the Roos can trade that pick as I believe their additional picks will come under review next year should they improve

 

[ADD72]

Why can't we go for Sydney's pick 11?

Adams and our pick 18, 36 to Sydney
Picks 11, 23 and possibly a future 3rd to Collingwood
Offer 11 and 23 to the Suns for pick 4 plus a future 2nd or 3rd pick

Suns need points for this year possible 3 top 15 academy picks

 

[swoop42]

We'll aim for 23 then we'll look to bundle 18 and 23 to see if we can get within the first dozen in the draft.

Might target a selection GC gain after trading out pick 4.

Doesn't mean we can achieve it.

Much rather hold Adams to his contract than accept a rubbish pick 44 we wont even use.

 

[Sub_Zero]

I’ve softened since Friday on this a touch with the news it’s a 3 year contract. It certainly puts 23 in play, IMO.

Ok Mr Footy Expert

 

[JuniorB]

This on Fox Sports:
"while the out-of-contract Finlay Macrae has shown enough in the seconds to warrant an AFL opportunity"

Just the type of crap journalism you expect from them.
As we all know, he's not out of contract and will get his opportunity next year.

 

[SwanBet]

We will end up with 23. He is contracted and while the club will want to fulfil his request, it's a massive bargaining tool. Sydney won't back out of the trade, for a guy they have really targeted over an 8 pick gap in the 20's/30's.

For Collingwood, flat to be losing Tay, but it opens the door for some talented depth to stake claims on an AFL spot (Fin/Reef/Ed) and will give us two draft picks well inside the the top 30 to bring in some talent.

 

[swoop42]

Not sure the Roos can trade that pick as I believe their additional picks will come under review next year should they improve

I'm 99.9% sure they can trade them this year and the AFL ruling is a subtle way of suggesting they should in case they lose them next season.

 

[Scodog10]

Ok Mr Footy Expert

How on earth did you guess my surname??

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

Suns need points for this year possible 3 top 15 academy picks

11 and 23 (2144 points) are similar in total points to pick 4 (2034)

 

[Eric Shin]

If I’m Wrighty I’m asking for Pick 23 in exchange for Adams and taking on Grundy’s full contract. I’ll also throw in Kelly and Treloar’s remaining contract as a sweetener.

Luckily for the Swans I’m not Wrighty.


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com

 

[Jelly Bean]

Won't be spoken about much but Aidan O'Driscoll (younger brother of Nathan) won the 20m at the combine. We historically take the kid who wins it (have since 2020). Lance Collard second.

Really? So we've got three 20m sprint winners? Reef, Allan, and who?

 

[Scodog10]

11 and 23 (2144 points) are similar in total points to pick 4 (2034)

Bulldogs offer for 4 will trump that.

 

[Kawenda]

I may need to grow up, but I least I'm not online claiming to be an inside source posting stuff like this.

Is taking the pies this guy?

That's hilarious

 

[cakewalk06]

We better give it a quick polish and black the tyres

Quick polish... HJs.. what have i walked into, Pistol?

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

This on Fox Sports:
"while the out-of-contract Finlay Macrae has shown enough in the seconds to warrant an AFL opportunity"

Just the type of crap journalism you expect from them.
As we all know, he's not out of contract and will get his opportunity next year.

No idea. I think Fly has senior footy next season lined up for Macrae....

 

[Scodog10]

Really? So we've got three 20m sprint winners? Reef, Allan, and who?

HH

2021 AFL Draft Combine Test Results

 

[Dead Eye Didak]

Bulldogs offer for 4 will trump that.

I guess so, unless we can conjour up another first rounder.