List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade and FA

[3rdMan]

Its all a bit over the top when they describe hawthorn trading pick 14 for a future first as a stunning move

More so because the Eagles wanted that pick for Barass. It's like Cats trading away the pick we wanted for Henry.

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

There’s no necessity for Collingwood to get involved in the Lukosous trade . If that’s direct between port and Suns it should have no bearing on what we are trying to achieve

 

[upnsmoke]

Probably not if we don't get Houston

Ah... it's the other way around.

No Pick 13... then No Houston

 

[CheckerTrade666]

I’m sorry but if we can’t get this deal to work with Gold Coast which will lead to us getting Houston, then surely we keep Noble. Losing Noble and not getting Houston will be a failure which will weaken us, unless somebody like Will Parker really steps up next year which is possible.

 

[upnsmoke]

Just ask GC for a F1 or Humphries for Noble, if they don't want to trade Pick 13 and 23.

 

[Jen2310]

Listening to the Leppa interview, he sad we definitely have a limit of what we would pay for.1 player, and if push comes to shove if its more than what we're willing to pay, we won't do it.

Also indicated Perryman likely will play half back. Will get opportunities through the midfield overtime given the age of our midfield. But may not be right away

 

[RedMamba]

Here is my elaborate scenario that gets us Houston and moves us up in the draft without being greedy. It involves lots of pick swaps but Gold Coast shouldn’t mind as they are primarily concerned about points for their academy prospect.

PORT GET
Lukosious
Richards
Pick 13
Pick 29

PORT GIVE
Houston
Pick 39 (Pick 31 equivalent in Points)
Pick 58

PORT PICKS: 13, 29

GOLD COAST GET
Noble
Collingwood 2026 1st Round Pick
Pick 52 (Pick 31 equivalent in points)
Pick 55
Pick 58

GOLD COAST GIVE
Lukosious
Pick 13
Pick 29

GCS PICKS: 23, 41, 50, 52, 55, 58, 78
(6 Used In Rioli Trade)
(Pick 4 equivalent in Points. Can trade Pick 23 for more points similar to RICH/BRIS trade)

COLLINGWOOD GET
Houston
Pick 39

COLLINGWOOD GIVE
Richards
Noble
Collingwood 2026 1st Round Pick
Pick 52 (Pick 39 equivalent of points)
Pick 55

COLLINGWOOD PICKS: 36, 39

2025 Collingwood Summary
IN
Perryman
Houston
Pick 36
Pick 39

OUT
Richards
Noble
Collingwood 2026 1st Round Pick

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Wonder If we find a New Trade Target to try and get or just happy with Perrymen at the moment?

Then look at Hayes and Tomlinson as DFA

Think Houston stays at Port Now

I think we will get Houston but if it does break down we will safe our bikkies on big names to spend in a years time, and top up with a combination of DFAs and draft picks. Or just delist one fewer player.

 

[HFF]

Everyone else gets one of those too. Making it sound like we have something special.

Lol what are you on about?
It’s called capital to use

 

[The Royal Sampler]

Noble is not worth pick 13.
They would only need to satisfy a trade for Noble.

Maybe but our future first is worth considerably more than #29.

 

[The Royal Sampler]

I’m sorry but if we can’t get this deal to work with Gold Coast which will lead to us getting Houston, then surely we keep Noble. Losing Noble and not getting Houston will be a failure which will weaken us, unless somebody like Will Parker really steps up next yea which is possible.

Yep we’d keep Noble and Joey can decide between returning to the Pies or playing for the Tigers as a PSD pick.

 

[The Royal Sampler]

There’s no necessity for Collingwood to get involved in the Lukosous trade . If that’s direct between port and Suns it should have no bearing on what we are trying to achieve

And the Luko trade could have a bearing on the picks available for a Rioli trade which could have a bearing on the picks available for a Noble trade.

 

[Bianconeri]

Nice summary. He seems to have matured a lot since his “Aisho going nowhere” days.

I wouldn’t mind a Goey going no where post to stop posters on here from bringing it up.

 

[swoop42]

If we get Houston me and Fat Jesus are going to sing Never Tear Us Apart in the middle of Rundle Mall while going full on Requiem for a Dream.

 

[Piewithsauce13]

We need to get something like this out in the media world but for Noble.

“Noble staying at pies now not a stretch!”

 

[TradeDraft]

Listening to the Leppa interview, he sad we definitely have a limit of what we would pay for.1 player, and if push comes to shove if its more than what we're willing to pay, we won't do it.

Also indicated Perryman likely will play half back. Will get opportunities through the midfield overtime given the age of our midfield. But may not be right away

Port has gone over what we pay

Unless we find Late 1st - Early 2nd round pick we not doing the Houston Trade

Perryman could play Houston Postion as port was planning to do with Perryman

 

[3rdMan]

If the strongest they're going with is "not a stretch Houston stays in Port", it's very unlikely he stays.

 

[TradeDraft]

There’s no necessity for Collingwood to get involved in the Lukosous trade . If that’s direct between port and Suns it should have no bearing on what we are trying to achieve

We can find another Club that could help us possibly get Houston

 

[Fat Jesus]

If we get Houston me and Fat Jesus are going to sing Never Tear Us Apart in the middle of Rundle Mall while going full on Requiem for a Dream.

Sounds good to me brother. Just the two of us, you and I.
We shall run amuck.

 

[HFF]

Why don’t we look at trading our F1 for Essendons current first?

That way they safeguard their ability to have effectively 3 F1s over 2 year period and we can get into the top 10 this year?

 

[Pragmatic Shill]

Why don’t we look at trading our F1 for Essendons current first?

That way they safeguard their ability to have effectively 3 F1s over 2 year period and we can get into the top 10 this year?

Aren't they looking to get up the draft order ahead of a Kako bid?

 

[HFF]

Aren't they looking to get up the draft order ahead of a Kako bid?

They cant unless they pay a lot more than they have which they won’t

 

[stormskye]

we are still negotiating a complex three way trade. Nothing has changed. This was never going to get done in week one.

Relax and let it play out.

Stop reading twitter.

 

[Tarkyn_24]

Here is my elaborate scenario that gets us Houston and moves us up in the draft without being greedy. It involves lots of pick swaps but Gold Coast shouldn’t mind as they are primarily concerned about points for their academy prospect.

PORT GET
Lukosious
Richards
Pick 13
Pick 29

PORT GIVE
Houston
Pick 39 (Pick 31 equivalent in Points)
Pick 58

PORT PICKS: 13, 29

GOLD COAST GET
Noble
Collingwood 2026 1st Round Pick
Pick 52 (Pick 31 equivalent in points)
Pick 55
Pick 58

GOLD COAST GIVE
Lukosious
Pick 13
Pick 29

GCS PICKS: 23, 41, 50, 52, 55, 58, 78
(6 Used In Rioli Trade)
(Pick 4 equivalent in Points. Can trade Pick 23 for more points similar to RICH/BRIS trade)

COLLINGWOOD GET
Houston
Pick 39

COLLINGWOOD GIVE
Richards
Noble
Collingwood 2026 1st Round Pick
Pick 52 (Pick 39 equivalent of points)
Pick 55

COLLINGWOOD PICKS: 36, 39

2025 Collingwood Summary
IN
Perryman
Houston
Pick 36
Pick 39

OUT
Richards
Noble
Collingwood 2026 1st Round Pick

Perryman has nothing to do with the arrangements here and shouldn’t be included in assessing the outcome of them?

 

[satanshoof101]

Just ask GC for a F1 or Humphries for Noble, if they don't want to trade Pick 13 and 23.

He will probably be played out of position for the next five years, share the love GC. I really rate Will Graham as well.