List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade and FA

[Pistol Night]

Is SDK a defender or ruck?

Key defender. And a gun one at that

 

[Pistol Night]

**** Houston, let's get TDK

Seeing his brother lives in Melbourne it would be piss weak of Geelong not to let SDK head “home” to be near family for a token draft selection I would of thought?

 

[nahnah]

**** Houston, let's get TDK

 

[danielnajdek]

Do people really think Geelong and Mackie would deal fairly with us. He was a douche with Ollie Henry trade.

 

[Ugene41]

As great as SDK would be for us, Geelong are dickheads at the trade table and will 100% ask for our next 5 first round picks and Nick Daicos as the steak knives

I think it'll be ok if it's a 3 way trade with Clarry going to Geelong and SDK plus a pick out.

 

[Pistol Night]

Do people really think Geelong and Mackie would deal fairly with us. He was a douche with Ollie Henry trade.

Flog on field and he’s carried it on beautifully to the list management position

 

[RobJD]

Is SDK a defender or ruck?

That's a question that the Cats are asking. Seems like he's lost a lot of confidence as a fullback after his facial fracture last year and struggled at times this year - they gave him a run in the ruck and he was badly beaten by his brother. Had Knee issues late in the year and he couldn't win back a spot even after regaining fitness in the VFL - I'd be cautious on him, could be a bust.

 

[live fast pieyoung]

I don't care how much players earn and would prefer the media didn't talk about it. I find it crass. Especially when they talk about it once the player is playing under that contract.

 

[Aussie pie]

Besides Beams 2.0, who do you guys think has been our worst acquisition in the last 10 years?

Freeman/sharenberg, McLarty in draft picks in Trades, Russell from Carlton my god that was bad.

 

[TheVillageIdiot7]

What would Noble be on? Does a part of his contract balance out Perryman’s over the next couple of years?

You'd have to assume that Noble contract (and the possibility of Richards leaving) would have been included.
Taking draftees would be an immediate cap savings for both Noble & Richards.

So it stands to reason that is why we entered the race and would also allow us to front load it using Noble/Richards coin.

That is unless we're planning on using the Noble cap space as a sweetener to help get pick 12.

 

[NMBB]

Flog on field and he’s carried it on beautifully to the list management position

In the 99th percentile of those pleased with themselves

 

[peter9789]

Why would Geelong let SDK go? Quality key position players are rare as hens teeth (note Gold Coast signed up Mac Andrew for a gazillion dollars and 10 years or so).

On the other hand, mid fielders with "medical" issues are pretty common I'm told.

Would love SDK but thinks its simply not feasible - but I've been wrong before

 

[peter9789]

We really need to nail the appointment of our next footy boss.
Davies and Daly staying is a blow.
Wright now also being hunted by crows to do the role he didn’t want to do anymore is also a slap in the face.

It’s a critical piece of the puzzle and appointment we really need to get right

Yes I agree.

Finding someone who can work under Ned I think is the challenge. I get the feeling he likes control and that may not sit well with some of the talked about candidates.

 

[Cousin of Daicos]

Sounds like Bartel is gettable as a footy boss

I swear I JUST saw someone in this thread or another saying we should get him

 

[GreekLunatic]

why doesn’t Cornes crack it at Geelong for how they recruit

 

[NMBB]

Yes I agree.

Finding someone who can work under Ned I think is the challenge. I get the feeling he likes control and that may not sit well with some of the talked about candidates.

Football managers talk amongst themselves - would have thought the club would have learned previously that others overreaching into bits that aren't their domain doesn't help (if this is an issue)

 

[thommo_legend]

why doesn’t Cornes crack it at Geelong for how they recruit

Probably because it has worked well for so long.

 

[gouki88]

Trade Radio suggesting whispers that Sam De Koning is gettable. Might help Geelong acquire Clarry.

If so, we should definitely try get in here. I would trade our F1 and Noble pick (20?). Hope that gives them 2x firsts to go offer Melbourne for Clarry plus change.

Stealing SDK would be a pretty good outcome. Not sure if Dan H actually has mail, but we'd have to ask a few questions if it's true.

Still not quite sure what his best position is though

 

[Roverjg]

Trade Talk LIVE: The clubs in the Oliver race, Crows eye Bomber

Follow all the news and live updates as the 2024 Continental Tyres AFL Trade Period approaches

www.afl.com.au

 

[sideswipe]

The issue with the Daniher contract was the triggering of the band 1 compensation and had nothing to do with his UFA or RFA status.

If we were to adjust Perryman’s contract in 2026 it will be investigated because of the compensation received by GWS. Being in the laws of the game does not preclude it from being something that the AFL can make a ruling and how open FA is to manipulation hence the greater transparency of FA contract reporting.

It’s a similar story to Buddy’s contract being enforceable under the salary cap even if he’d retired after 7 years and he’d forgone payment.

Enforceable isn't the word you are looking for - maybe try "would form part of the salary cap".

But this is off on a tangent - what you seemed to be trying to suggest was that journos reporting of contract amounts would be more likely to be accurate because it was an FA contract. This is nonsense - all contracts go to the AFL.

 

[Bianconeri]

**** Houston, let's get TDK

You want a ruck when we’ve already got that position covered with Cameron over the best half back in the comp?

 

[JLC]

Watch the darlings of the media in Geelong get Oliver for practically nothing.

 

[manicpie]

You ruck when we’ve already got that position covered with Cameron over the best half back in the comp?

Full back

 

[Danthepiesman]

This TDK news is HUGE!!!!
I would drop our interest in Peatling and focus on TDK
Surely our future 1st + swap of this years 2nd round picks would suffice???

 

[Piewithsauce13]

Watch the darlings of the media in Geelong get Oliver for practically nothing.

While extending SDK for next 13 years