List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2016 Part 4 - The Final Day: Sailing into the abyss ...

Remove this Banner Ad

I'm ok with a future second rounder
Me too. Treloar and Adams would have provided us with good inside info about the worth of all the players that GWS put up for trade. Most other clubs who have acquired players from GWS don't have that inside knowledge in making/pricing their selections.
 
14561889_631841410308701_2850205198876409856_n.jpg
 

Log in to remove this ad.

The complaining is unreal, and ridiculous.
WHE is a fair trade and so was Witts.

All the other trades like vardy and Stewart for high picks are fair as well, if Collingwood gave away pick 40-50 for either of them.id think we'd be hard done by. Stop over rating every single player, you're saying pick 70's for average players who could potentially be delisted is fair and a steal which is ridiculous
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Seems a no-brainer, but like Black and Richards they don't seem to have much interest or rate him.
I had a look at Black, Stewart & X Richards stats and what stood out is that Black in his best year (25 games in 2014) had a disposal efficiency comparable to T Cloke (both in high 60s). Richards career DE 70%. Stewart career DE 60%.
 
Me too. Treloar and Adams would have provided us with good inside info about the worth of all the players that GWS put up for trade. Most other clubs who have acquired players from GWS don't have that inside knowledge in making/pricing their selections.

Treloar and WHE are best mates.

I'd wager Bucks has picked Treloar's brain on the type of player/trainer/general person WHE is.
 
At the end of the day WHE will be best 22 for us if he stays injury free, so I can cop that.
Almost everyone leaving is not.

It didn't help that GWS had a clear out of players that saved them cap space so they would have been quite content keeping WHE in the end.
 
Sad to see Clokey go. Our best forward since big Sav and we might not see someone as good as him in the Black and White for a while. Maybe Darcy can get to Clokes level in time.

Reckon he will thrive with Dogs better delivery. 40-50+ goals for 2017
Anthony Rocca? I'd have him and Cloke on a similar level. AR 220 games 404 goals, TC 246 games 441 goals.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2016 Part 4 - The Final Day: Sailing into the abyss ...

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top