List Mgmt. Collingwood Trade Talk 2016 Part 4 - The Final Day: Sailing into the abyss ...

[Maggie5]

Here's a selection of what Collingwood list manager Derek Hine said post the trade period.

On Hoskin-Elliott:

“I think he’s going to be a lot more balanced back home, amongst family and friends. One thing that really stood out to us with Will was his performances on the MCG have just been really consistent and at a high level.

Not that I am knocking his selection but what a silly thing to say. So how good is he at Eitihad, or on WA, SA, Qld or NSW grounds?

 

[barrackers]

Hoping they keep him on and work closely with him. Let him have all the time wants and try get him to stay.

With Marsh if his personal reasons are mental health related are we able to add him to the long term injury list and promote a rookie?

 

[Dubaimagpie]

Sorry if this has been asked before but do we have enough points for Brown and Daicos?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[Baird]

Langdon - Dunn - Maynard

Good lord...

 

[Magpie Monopoly]

then don't get rid of him for peanuts. the guy has played well at afl , is young and quick. how many 105 picks have played 1 game of AFL?.
Answer is zero.

His rapid decline and falling out with the coaching staff, and how we went from boarderline AA to essentially De-listed at our club tells me there was more going on than we know about.

Because your right, one face value it doesn't make sense. He was a very good player amd in less than 12 months we essentially threw him out the door. Not only that, no one wanted him

 

[TW Sherrin]

Marley Williams for 105 / Cloke for 79???
in hine we trust, more like in hine we bust.

hine confirmed Williams was being delisted so the pick was irrelevant.

Brett Anderson talking about cloke costing the dogs pick 76 said something like..."thats a lot for a vfl player"..

 

[Tassiepies83]

Spin Mayne at 4x5 to me in a positive way.

I am the Joel Embiid of Collingwood supporters but I have nothing.

It's not 4x5 though! Positive lol

 

[Soups]

With Marsh if his personal reasons are mental health related are we able to add him to the long term injury list and promote a rookie?

Not sure, may be worth delisting him and placing him on the rookie list?

 

[TW Sherrin]

Very curious what happens with Marsh now.

Did i miss something or is he still a pie?

has been appointed our WA scout for 12 months.

 

[si tacuisses]

This is the first post I've made about Palmer. If you don't like what I'm posting then put me on ignore. Otherwise gagf.

Oh wait, sorry! Totally mixed you up with someone else who kept posting that same point, my bad

 

[Tassiepies83]

Good lord...

Looks better than
Langdon brown Maynard!!

 

[TradeDraft]

Not that I am knocking his selection but what a silly thing to say. So how good is he at Eitihad, or on WA, SA, Qld or NSW grounds?

Our Home Games at the MCG

 

[TradeDraft]

https://audioboom.com/posts/5184779-derek-hine-on-nab-trade-radio

 

[Apex36]

then don't get rid of him for peanuts. the guy has played well at afl , is young and quick. how many 105 picks have played 1 game of AFL?.
Answer is zero.

Edit: Primetime Pricey beat me to it.

 

[Kirby]

then don't get rid of him for peanuts. the guy has played well at afl , is young and quick. how many 105 picks have played 1 game of AFL?.
Answer is zero.

The club don't want to keep him and don't want him around. We won't use the pick.

 

[Maggie5]

Our Home Games at the MCG

But that is not the only place we play all our games. That is what I mean.

 

[Breakthelines]

Good lord...

Ramsey - Dunn - Maynard either way it's not as bad as many are making out!

 

[Visions]

Not that I am knocking his selection but what a silly thing to say. So how good is he at Eitihad, or on WA, SA, Qld or NSW grounds?

Considering he has only played 5 games at the G, you have a decent point.

 

[TW Sherrin]

I'd be pretty happy if I was a suns supporter. they add Hanley (potential AA), a 1st ruck and a midfielder.

then they have picks 4,6,8,10 this year and a stack of 2nds in 2017.

they lost a bloke who hasn't played for 2 years and a handy mid.

 

[Breakthelines]

But that is not the only place we play all our games. That is what I mean.

Nah just 14 a season.

 

[deck]

hine confirmed Williams was being delisted so the pick was irrelevant.

Brett Anderson talking about cloke costing the dogs pick 76 said something like..."thats a lot for a vfl player"..

Anderson is very strong on the modern game of teams going more mobile forward and back.

Didn't seem to think Brown or Frost were big losses. Actually thought our backline was ok for the modern hybrid talls if we can get a good run with injures.

 

[Reens]

FB Tom Langdon - Ben Reid - Jeremy Howe

HB Josh Smith - Matthew Scharenberg - Jackson Ramsey

C Steele Sidebottom - Adam Treloar - James Aish

HF Alex Fasolo - Darcy Moore - Travis Varcoe

FF Chris Mayne - Jesse White - Will Hoskin-Elliott

Followers Brodie Grundy - Scott Pendlebury - Daniel Wells

Interchange Taylor Adams - Jack Crisp - Rupert Wills - Jamie Elliott


Thoughts?

 

[Buckley is my hero]

His rapid decline and falling out with the coaching staff, and how we went from boarderline AA to essentially De-listed at our club tells me there was more going on than we know about.

Because your right, one face value it doesn't make sense. He was a very good player amd in less than 12 months we essentially threw him out the door. Not only that, no one wanted him

He was always a poor decision maker and poor kick. You only noticed that this year.

 

[Justlokan]

1 thing I just Relised is that we picked up are good Kicks

we'll turn them into bad kicks. take that to the bank

 

[Apex36]

But that is not the only place we play all our games. That is what I mean.

No, but it's where we play more games than any other venue. I think the point Hine was trying to make though is that he seemed to perform better when he was back in Melbourne around family and friends.