List Mgmt. Contract, Trade and Draft Discussions - 2024 Post Season

Whose future picks would you have preferred?


  • Total voters
    216

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
  • Thread starter
  • Moderator
  • #2


Quick links



Trade period
In:
12, F1, F2, F3, 73, Baker, Owies, Graham*
Out: 3, 63, F4, Barrass, Darling

*Free agent

Done deals

  • Jai Culley, Alex Witherden and Coby Burgiel delisted






  • Zane Trew, Jamaine Jones and Jordyn Baker delisted

 
Last edited by a moderator:
I very much hate to say this but I genuinely think Dockers can go flag if they get Shai. Lots of close losses last year, great list profile age wise, improving still. I mean I hope as always they fall horribly short but yeah they will be very decent if they can add his dynamic attacking play to that mix. You’d think he’d be keen for that kind of action that could be pretty immediate if he joins Freo
Brisbane and Sydney are so far ahead of the rest its absurd. Even without Joe Daniher, Brisbane just miles ahead.
 
100% not from the press conference. Its across the board. I mean we still havnt made our delistings yet..... What are we waiting for here?
They don’t know how many picks they will be taking to the draft until our trades are done. Surely that’s not that difficult to understand.
Couple that with things like not getting or publically asking for a priority pick
Maybe AFL house shut the door on it privately. No point coming out making a big noise about requiring assistance if you have already been told it’s not happening. Would burn bridges in AFL house, the media would have a field day and we would look like fools. Fight the battles you are a chance of winning.
We don’t know what’s happening behind the scenes. Simply guessing.
 
I thought the same however multiple Gold Coast fans have mentioned that they want players rather than picks this year, and they have multiple academy prospects next year. I personally think the Suns would be better off trading 6 for a future first and giving Richmond what they want out of the rest of their picks. It does seem like they can get more for 13 than Rioli though so maybe they are better off giving up 6 to Richmond and trying to get back an F2 (I know I said 20 but I think an F2 might be better for the Suns).

Liam Ryan to Suns.

Will Powell to Eagles.

Dusty won't be playing there and they need a headline grabbing player to trade in. Marketing would love it.

Just do it.
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Im not denying my victim complex but more then 1 agreed with them for sure

100% not from the press conference. Its across the board. I mean we still havnt made our delistings yet..... What are we waiting for here? Couple that with things like not getting or publically asking for a priority pick, targetting players and missing out on them again and also lack of direction as a whole and its been a bad start

J Jones and Trew have signed with WAFL clubs and didn't retire. They were delisted.

Darling gone.

Barrass about to go.

Gaff retired.

So 5 confirmed departures so far.
 
We'll need future picks for 2025. Especially for Wes.
Trade

Barrass for 14 F2.
3 to bombers 9 and F1st.
F1 to tigers for 6 and baker.

2024

6 best mid
9 Lindsay
14 Allen
23 Urquhart
Champion.

It does leave saints in between us with 7 8, so likely they take TT unless we pull the trigger on him at 6.

2025
Bombers F1 - death ride the second half of the yr!
Hawks F2
Our F2 F3 F4

All three of these are perfect for the FS and academy bids.

On Pixel 6 Pro using BigFooty.com mobile app
 
Brisbane and Sydney are so far ahead of the rest its absurd. Even without Joe Daniher, Brisbane just miles ahead.

Freo beat both this year, one of those was Sydney away. With the age of their mids and forwards in particular they are going to continue to improve. Shai in that mix certainly helps their attack. I would be shocked if they get Bolton and can’t go top 4 at least in 2025.

I do not enjoy writing this by the way, but they are very close to a genuine tilt now
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Brisbane and Sydney are so far ahead of the rest its absurd. Even without Joe Daniher, Brisbane just miles ahead.
They say that about every premiership team. Let's not forget that Brissy was 40 odd points down against GWS in the semi final and pretty much everyone thought they were done. Form and confidence makes a huge difference.

Not that I want Freo to win a flag, but I could easily see them top 4 next year if they get themselves sorted. That's a big if though.
 
They say that about every premiership team. Let's not forget that Brissy was 40 odd points down against GWS in the semi final and pretty much everyone thought they were done. Form and confidence makes a huge difference.

Not that I want Freo to win a flag, but I could easily see them top 4 next year if they get themselves sorted. That's a big if though.
Thats true but we also cant ignore they are about to add Coleman, Doedee, Levi, McCarthy, McInerney, Gardner to the team that won the Grand Final.

They won a flag and no team will get more talent into the team then them this off season
 
They don’t know how many picks they will be taking to the draft until our trades are done. Surely that’s not that difficult to understand.

Maybe AFL house shut the door on it privately. No point coming out making a big noise about requiring assistance if you have already been told it’s not happening. Would burn bridges in AFL house, the media would have a field day and we would look like fools. Fight the battles you are a chance of winning.
We don’t know what’s happening behind the scenes. Simply guessing.
I just can't agree with this.

The supporters really should know if PP's were applied for.

You don't have to make a "big noise" about it.
Just come out and say we applied and were refused.

I for one would feel better knowing we at least had a crack.

As for "burning bridges", they give us **** all as it is.
 
Liam Ryan to Suns.

Will Powell to Eagles.

Dusty won't be playing there and they need a headline grabbing player to trade in. Marketing would love it.

Just do it.

Ryan was keen to move to Queensland until he discovered neither team wanted him


Sent from my iPhone using BigFooty.com
 
Calls are we need to take an elite mid at the top end of the draft to pair with Harley.

I see reasonable question marks on every mid in the top 5 this year and as much as I'd like to fast track us to not being such a basket case anymore I'd prefer to build our next premiership team.

For that reason, I have zero interest in including our F1 in considerations this year preferring to keep our powder dry next year for warner or just take Rodriguez. My preference this year is to maintain our number of picks and get in the elite runners/footballers that are going to support our future elite midfielders.

My preferred offer for baker is a slide back 3-6 with a F3 if needed.

6 Travaglia
14 Lindsay
2x Barrat, O'Farrell
5x Unwin/Urqhardt

I'm resigned to the fact that our ruck situation remains unchanged for 2025.

Next year I'm targeting either Warner or Rodriguez and Swadling

year after take another mid with R1
Good man. My favourite two Bendigo players from this year.
 
Freo with Bolton would be near favourites for the flag 2025 but they aren't they have , Brisbane , Hawthorn, Sydney , Giants , Carlton , Geelong , Western Bulldogs , Collingwood .....all in front of Freo as favourites .
Port Adelaide are ranked lower then Freo .

Gold Coast I think can play finals at least .
Good draft picks again this draft ...surely they can threaten.
 
I'm wetting the bed hard about this whole baker for 14. We really don't need him.

Get parfitt, owies for free, along with Graham that's 3 serviceable players in the 26/27 age bracket.

Trade: Barrass, 26 for 14, 33, Haw F1.
Trade: Haw F1, WCE F2, 33 for 13, 23

Go to the Draft with 3, 13, 14, 23, 63, 68


3 - Fos/jagga/Lalor
13,14 - Two of Lindsay, Tauru/Trainor, Berry, Allan
23 - KPD/Dodson
63, 68 Champion match
 
Thats true but we also cant ignore they are about to add Coleman, Doedee, Levi, McCarthy, McInerney, Gardner to the team that won the Grand Final.

They won a flag and no team will get more talent into the team then them this off season
Good point. They've done a good job with their rebuild.
 
I just can't agree with this.

The supporters really should know if PP's were applied for.

You don't have to make a "big noise" about it.
Just come out and say we applied and were refused.

I for one would feel better knowing we at least had a crack.

As for "burning bridges", they give us **** all as it is.
Having a good relationship with AFL house will be beneficial as there are other things currently in play after the equalisation review. No will mean no so what’s the point in poking the bear and looking like a beggar that’s being turned away. It would be a poor look for the club putting its hand out for assistance and being told no. We would get zero support from the AFL media just like during the COVID era and that was a poor look for our club. Surely that one is recent enough to remember what having a whinge looks like in the VAFL landscape.
 
"Even though there has been 0 trades for 23 days we still have a HUGE day with some MASSIVE guests on Trade Radio - coming up after 9 hours of ads we have Max King back to talk about St Kilda for an hour. Stay tuned for the BIGGEST week of the year"
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top