Trade Requested Dan Houston [UFA 2027] - wants to head to Victoria

[Jirik13]

1st, Richards is NOT a bloody F2 ffs he's an out of contract 9 game mature age player. Based off the alleged offer from Port and free agency so called formula's then he's a 4th round pick. Not 3rd and definitely not 2nd.

2nd, Luko is ONLY worth a F1 if Sun's offer to finalise his remaining contract they have with him due to back ending it & now wanting to get it off the books. If Sun's don't want to do that and expect Port to carry on with it then he's only worth a 2nd round pick, potentially future 2nd. That's it.

Some real uneducated imbeciles on here

Port down votes are due to your ignorance and lack of intelligence.

Trading Day reported Luko for F1 tomorrow.

 

[Jirik13]

Because they want noble and Collingwood would see Houston as a direct replacement/upgrade if they don't get him noble stays

Perryman replacing Noble?

 

[Pleasedontfail11]

Our F1 would be valued about the same as yours, with us throwing in a F2 and you wanting pick 23 back that's valuing Noble at pick 11 which isn't happening in a million years even with some of the dumb shit GC have done over the years.

Port would 100% take 13 + 36 + Richards for Houston if they could then turn 36 + 39 + 58 into something for luko.

Out: Houston, 39, 58
In: 13, Lukosius, Richards

Brisbanes pick 20 for those picks to be ontraded for a future pick to give to GC for luko would be the how as brisbane need points for ashcroft but brisbane might have a better offer.

I don't think your pick 11 evaluation of Noble is even close. Just because you have to put in overs to get the deal done doesn't mean anything.
GC want players not picks which is why they are dealing with us first. I know a lot of people don't value Noble but GC do. The deal should get done.
To Gold Coast, Noble >>> then Carltons future 2nd. So we get first shot at it.
We won't do 13 for f1 and Noble.
Maybe 13 and 29 for Noble and f1
Maybe 13 for Noble and 36
Maybe 13 and 23 for Noble, 36 and f1.
The negotiations continue.

No Port wouldn't accept 13, 36 and Richards for Houston imo. Carlton will have to give up picks 12 and a f1 imo.

 

[perplexed]

Because they want noble and Collingwood would see Houston as a direct replacement/upgrade if they don't get him noble stays

OMG, I forgot that you guys have the power of Noble.

GC could just trade 29 for Noble and Collingwood would rejoice. The two trades really don't need to be connected.

 

[perplexed]

To resolve this whole pick 13 thing. Would GC take our F1 for 13, 23 and 41? More? Less?

 

[Enviable Tradition]

Mega trade version 2... what do you think?

Port
In: Lukosius, Richards, Pick #13
Out: Houston, F2nd

Collingwood
In: Houston, Gold Coast F3rd
Out: Noble, Richards, F1st

Gold Coast
In: Noble, Pies F1st, Ports F2nd
Out: Lukosius, Pick #13, F3rd

No

On SM-G975F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Pleasedontfail11]

Thats terrible for GC.

To Gc:
Noble > pick 29 (otherwise they would take Carltons deal for their future 2nd)
Port's F1 > Lukosius (bit of a dump imo)
Pies F1 < pick 13
It balances out overall.

I think they Pies get the worst deal and Port make out the best. But certainly a later pick or 2 could go GCs way quite easily to help with Lombards bid both Collingwood and Port have picks in the 49-55 range if I remember correctly.

 

[Enviable Tradition]

I like this version

Port
In : Lukosius, Richards
Out : Houston, F2nd

Coll
In : Houston, Ports F2, Pick 13, Pick 23, GC F3rd
Out : Noble, Richards

Gold Coast
In : Noble
Out : Lukosius, 13,23, F3rd

Lol. As if port should be offering MORE than Houston for Luko and Richards.

On SM-G975F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Enviable Tradition]

Trading Day reported Luko for F1 tomorrow.

Luko and...

On SM-G975F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[GCS in 11]

Maybe 13 and 23 for Noble, 36 and f1.

If you add 52 & 55, I think that’s a decent chance and actually quite fair. You get 23 for Houston, we get enough points for Lombard.

 

[Port2Power]

Trading Day reported Luko for F1 tomorrow.

Fixed this for you

Luko + GC F1 to Port
GC: frees up 2.1 million salary cap space

 

[Pleasedontfail11]

Geez thats shocking for Collingwood.

If they finish bottom 10-12 thats an enormous amount to ship off for Houston.

Agree it's the worst for Collingwood while Port do well. But I feel it's what it would take to get the deal done. GC get what they want future picks a player they want to dump off their list and a player they want on the list. But over all GC do okayish.....

 

[Pleasedontfail11]

If you add 52 & 55, I think that’s a decent chance and actually quite fair. You get 23 for Houston, we get enough points for Lombard.

Maybe with a f3 coming back.

 

[Skull Face]

I don't think your pick 11 evaluation of Noble is even close.
GC want players not picks which is why they are dealing with us first. I know a lot of people don't value Noble but GC do. The deal should get done.
To Gold Coast, Noble >>> then Carltons future 2nd. So we get first shot at it.
We won't do 13 for f1 and Noble.
Maybe 13 and 29 for Noble and f1
Maybe 13 for Noble and 36
Maybe 13 and 23 for Noble, 36 and f1.
The negotiations continue.

No Port wouldn't accept 13, 36 and Richards for Houston imo. Carlton will have to give up picks 12 and a f1 imo.

My pick 11 evaluation is based on points but lets not kid ourselves nobles worth a late 2nd/early 3rd tops

Were both offering F1's, we both want pick 13 so scratch those 2 off the board and you are left with this as the difference between both offers

GC
IN: Noble
Out: 23 + Carlton F2


GC are waiting for you to offer F1 + Noble for pick 13 and that alone and they will take it otherwise its not even remotely realistic, 41 back would be the only cherry they might throw you

 

[Skull Face]

If you add 52 & 55, I think that’s a decent chance and actually quite fair. You get 23 for Houston, we get enough points for Lombard.

why would you need 52 + 55 when you would still have 29 36 41 50 to cover lombard

 

[Heeney2Franklin]

Pick 11 (or in that range) for Houston seems like a very straight forward trade to me

I would give that up in a heartbeat for him

 

[jackag24]

Trading Day reported Luko for F1 tomorrow.

I have no idea why Port would jump the gun and just bust a load with their F1 on day 3 of the trade period.

Especially when you have an outgoing Houston/Soldo.

I'd have to see it to believe it

 

[GCS in 11]

why would you need 52 + 55 when you would still have 29 36 41 50 to cover lombard

I fear we are going to overpay on Rioli by a lot and give over 6 & 29. 36, 41, 50 allows us to only match from pick 10 without going into deficit.

It’s probably roughly where Lombard will go but those two extra picks will mean we have cover if he gets a 5-9 bid on him.

 

[Hawks_Footy]

Curious if the suns are waiting to hear from the Houston camp where he wants to play next year so they can...
1) Bend the club over that's gunning for pick 13
2) Play mr. nice guy at the trade table again

 

[coolidge1000]

OMG, I forgot that you guys have the power of Noble.

GC could just trade 29 for Noble and Collingwood would rejoice. The two trades really don't need to be connected.

It has nothing to do with power it's just replacing one running halfback with another,if they can't get Huston why would you trade out a similar player with no replacement

 

[DocSholl]

Curious if the suns are waiting to hear from the Houston camp where he wants to play next year so they can...
1) Bend the club over that's gunning for pick 13
2) Play mr. nice guy at the trade table again

lol you know it's the latter. They need to work out which big Vic club they are exposing their belly to for tickling

 

[Pure_Ownage]

Mega trade... what do you think?

Port
In: Lukosius, Richards, Pick #13
Out: Houston, F2nd

Collingwood
In: Houston, Port F2nd
Out: Noble, Richards, F1st

Gold Coast
In: Noble, Pies F1st
Out: Lukosius, Pick #13

I doubt gc are that stupid.

 

[Enviable Tradition]

I doubt gc are that stupid.

Or Port

On SM-G975F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Shaucob_Burjan]

North out: #2
North in: Houston, #13

Gold Coast out: #6, #13, Lukosius
Gold Coast in: #2, 2025 FRP (Port)

Port out: Houston, 2025 FRP
Port in: #6, Lukosius

 

[Pleasedontfail11]

North out: #2
North in: Houston, #6

Gold Coast out: #6, Lukosius
Gold Coast in: #2

Port out: Houston
Port in: #6, Lukosius

Richmond would want pick 2 for Rioli.