MRP / Trib. De Goey hit on Elijah Hewett

[_Mike_]

Stay on topic thanks, that also means ending the thread derailing posts & silly troll comments

 

[Smokey17]

Go on, explain how it's different other than the direction of the stripes

So you think that someone raising their elbow and collecting someone directly in the cheek, is the same as someone with their albow tucked in (like everyone is taught how to bump) is the same?

He collected him high with the shoulder. If that was a bigger bloke that's a fair bump. In saying that tho, he chose to bump, collected him high and will deservedly get minimum 3 weeks..

But very similar to Stewart? Give me a spell

 

[My Tilly]

Should be 4 weeks but who knows with the AFL

 

[Mitchell Madness]

Deserves 3-4
Will probably get 1

 

[ep2018]

High, late, Hewett out with concussion. 3 weeks imo

 

[Dave]

Will michael christian apply the big vic club discount?

More likely the black and white discount…..

 

[Vindicater]

Concussion means this will be 4 weeks. Maybe three.

Would get off with Carlton's lawyers.

 

[BF Tiger]

I don't think as bad as Stewart on Prestia last year, but only slightly so. Stewart would probably (I'd hope) get six weeks this year so I'm thinking at least four for DeGoey.

 

[The_Todd07]

So you think that someone raising their elbow and collecting someone directly in the cheek, is the same as someone with their albow tucked in (like everyone is taught how to bump) is the same?

He collected him high with the shoulder. If that was a bigger bloke that's a fair bump. In saying that tho, he chose to bump, collected him high and will deservedly get minimum 3 weeks..

But very similar to Stewart? Give me a spell

Stewart has his elbow tucked in you muppet.

They are exactly the same. Ball gone, chose to bump, head contact, player subbed off.

 

[Smokey17]

Stewart has his elbow tucked in you muppet.

They are exactly the same. Ball gone, chose to bump, head contact, player subbed off.

Yeah you're right... elbow shoulder...same same

 

[Reppie]

Yeah you're right... elbow shoulder...same same

 

[The_Todd07]

Yeah you're right... elbow shoulder...same same

If you want to split hairs, Stewarts foot was down at the point of contact, De Goey had left the ground.
Prestia tapped the ball on so Stewart didn't even have the choice to tackle, Hewitt had the ball so tackling was an option.
Starting to look like maybe Jordan deserves more than 4

Or they are the same, I don't particularly care either way

 

[adammania9]

More likely the black and white discount…..

Name one time a Pies player has gotten off easy at the tribunal

 

[Smokey17]

If you want to split hairs, Stewarts foot was down at the point of contact, De Goey had left the ground.
Prestia tapped the ball on so Stewart didn't even have the choice to tackle, Hewitt had the ball so tackling was an option.
Starting to look like maybe Jordan deserves more than 4

Or they are the same, I don't particularly care either way

Yeah give him 6... longer mid season preseason to get him prime for September!

 

[BG32]

Name one time a Pies player has gotten off easy at the tribunal

Does Joffa avoiding jail time count?

 

[Geelong_Bisons_#36]

Will be 2 or 3.

 

[adammania9]

Does Joffa avoiding jail time count?

Average comment

 

[JasRulz63]

Will be 2 or 3.

Would be very surprised if he only got two weeks given Hewett is off with concussion.

 

[BF Tiger]

Does Joffa avoiding jail time count?

You win BigFooty today. Shut it down for the night.

 

[Smokey17]

View attachment 1703640

Thanks for showing me that Stewart's elbow to the head was as dirty an act I have seen in a long time.

 

[HugeJohnson]

6 weeks please

 

[Gumby2Hurley]

2 at least

 

[Stumpy Pete]

If we are looking for similar incidents for this year I’d suggest we go to round 1 and look at Franklin (1 week) and Pickett (2 weeks). Report is both of those should have got about a week more than they each did. He’ll get 3 (and rightly so) but for the same of consistency it should be 2 max.

Regards

S. Pete

 

[BF Tiger]

If we are looking for similar incidents for this year I’d suggest we go to round 1 and look at Franklin (1 week) and Pickett (2 weeks). Report is both of those should have got about a week more than they each did. He’ll get 3 (and rightly so) but for the same of consistency it should be 2 max.

Regards

S. Pete

Were either of those players concussed?

 

[ConcreteWaters]

Intentional, high impact, high contact. Enjoy the holiday tool

 

[Magma]

bali's calling