D4 Division 4 - 2012

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.

Log in to remove this ad.

Vic Roads said:
Can someone from Mt Lilydale confirm if they had a forfeit last round in the reserves and if so will they have enough players for this saturday, not being smart would just like to know thanks in advance.
Click to expand...

I'm not from ML but they did forfeit the 2's last weekend. We were informed at around midday friday giving us plenty of time to make changes to our clubbies side.
 
This thread has died in the ass!

Anyways good to see that Chaddy player going up before the tribunal this week, hope he gets life from all reports on here.

Tips R14:
SM by 10 goals over MC (SM to bounce back after EP beat them)
BHN by 1 goal over MTL (RM to dominate)
EP by 15 goals over PC (EP to smash PC after beating SM and PC being level with chaddy at 3/4 time??!!)
NB by 5 goals over WB (NB to make it 1-1 this season in the local derby)
SU by 20 goals over CH ( SU way too good)

Reserves:
SM,BHN,EP,WB,SU.
 
I am curious to know more about the Chaddy vs PC game. Was PC taking it easy? Chaddy have threatened at times but only for the odd quarter. Perhaps injuries may have brought them back to the field?

SM will be keen to atone for their only loss. MC have been ok but SM should record a comfortable 50 win, the battle of the full forwards will be worth watching. McPherson 9 last week Albrecht only 2

MTL struggling at the moment and BHN seemed competitve although at arms length. Perhaps BHN by 8 points

EP struggling before their upset win over SM, PC different proposition at home and Marsh makes them 5 goal better team. PC by 20pts

NB similar to MC have had some very competitive results. WB are all over the place. Wet home deck might not be enough, NB by 27pts

Brave Chaddy last week against PC, the task of SU on their home deck is a far different proposition. SU by a fair margin 60+
 
The
Getyahandoffit said:
You have got to be joking me mate, you have completely ignored the initial statement that a cobras player hit this player first this meaning he got a towel up. This guy and other players were instructed to target him and in hindsight was a very silly idea. If it was me and I started a dust up with a bloke and he gave me a flogging Im telling you I would accept it as it was my own doing.

And as for your attack on the club itself this bloke wasn't reported by an umpire not sent off for any amount of time the club took it upon themselves to send him to the showers even at the time the game was very close. This was done for his own safety and the safety of the opposition.

For you to have the audacity to cry victim is a touch out of line he didn't king hit anyone or anything UNLIKE a cobras player who clearly kicked a player in the head whilst on the ground unprovoked. Hang ya hat on that one boys ohh and to quote ya coach again " that's why you don't get a game with us because you do stupid things like that all the time" biggest dog act in football please don't preach about what is thuggery when you clearly have a pretty ordinary culture yaself!

An
Click to expand...
Tribunal has spoken - Gone from the VAFA for good - so Get your hand off it!
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

Slow week!
Tips R15:
SM by 10 goals over NB
EP by 25 goals over CH
MC by 5 goals over BHN
PC by 10 goals over WB
SU by 30 goals over MTL

Reserves:
SM,EP,BHN,WB,SU
 
Given 12 teams in D3 at what point does the VAFA need to look at sending a couple of D4 clubs back to the clubbies and making it so it's only 10 in each grade?
 
Cosmo21 said:
Given 12 teams in D3 at what point does the VAFA need to look at sending a couple of D4 clubs back to the clubbies and making it so it's only 10 in each grade?
Click to expand...

Interesting idea, who would you have go down though? And how would they get back up to D4? I know this came up at the end of last year and Chaddy are a proud club and no way want to go down to the clubbies, they want that breakthrough win to come in D4. Box Hill North were pushing for finals only a couple of years ago and Mt Lilydale came from D3 last year, Manningham have got their act together and playing decent footy, WB also came from D3. So it would seem very harsh to relegate a club from D4 just to bring the numbers down from 12 to 10. I could understand Chaddy going back to clubbies and building up like Mt Lilydale did.
 
Milney_Legend said:
Interesting idea, who would you have go down though? And how would they get back up to D4? I know this came up at the end of last year and Chaddy are a proud club and no way want to go down to the clubbies, they want that breakthrough win to come in D4. Box Hill North were pushing for finals only a couple of years ago and Mt Lilydale came from D3 last year, Manningham have got their act together and playing decent footy, WB also came from D3. So it would seem very harsh to relegate a club from D4 just to bring the numbers down from 12 to 10. I could understand Chaddy going back to clubbies and building up like Mt Lilydale did.
Click to expand...

I think Chadstone have had long enough and need to go back, MtL are the interesting one, although they have come back from D3 they seem to have some massive issues, huge form slumps and forfitting 2's games??
 
Cosmo21 said:
I think Chadstone have had long enough and need to go back, MtL are the interesting one, although they have come back from D3 they seem to have some massive issues, huge form slumps and forfitting 2's games??
Click to expand...

Chadstone - don't know where they are at. Numbers seem to be OK & while numbers are OK I don't see them going to Clubbies. As I understand it they are not bad financially either. That's just what I hear...

Mt Lilydale - I think you'll find that they have had a season to forget in terms of injuries. There are a few older guys out there (I think) that may be coming towards the end. If that is the case & they're unable to get new blood in the door it may make their situation interesting. As I said though, I believe their situation to be injury related as much as anything...

Also - I thought that it was the VAFA that changed things up 12-24 months ago & it was their stated preference to have 12 teams in D3.
 
Cosmo21 said:
That's a really good point how the hell can you tip WB??
Click to expand...

West Brunswick are a not a bad bet, but just noticed RM always tips against PC, no matter where the game is played.
 
Ruck Machine said:
I tipped PC in in round 13!
Click to expand...
Against a side that hasn't won for a few years?!! No disrespect for chaddy, but you tipped every other side to beat PC
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Similar threads

B
D1 Division 1 2025
2
Replies
43
Views
6K
footy2016
F
P
Division 1 2024
9 10 11 12 13
Replies
317
Views
80K
Lionspride2000
L
womack
D2 Division 2 2024
14 15 16 17 18
Replies
435
Views
87K
localfootylegend23
localfootylegend23
Big Unit 30
D1 Division 1 - 2023
31 32 33 34 35
Replies
858
Views
113K
Phantom Strobler
P

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top