Do we need May and why, or not

[TradeDraft]

If we buff up our backline we improve 3-4 goals. He is right age, and our time is now. We need our 2019 Jolly and Ball (and some luck) and we are away.

Was Thinking in the Spa that May could have simmlar effect Jolly gave us.

Would you do same Trade in 1st and 3rd Round Pick for May?

 

[unplugged]

Not sure if serious????

Not sure if serious that you're asking me if I'm serious!

 

[Adz]

First round and Langdon.

Get the deal done.

 

[TradeDraft]

I want him. I feel like he'll cost our first round and Greenwood.

I'd throw in Oxley for Jack Martin though...

I happily do that Trade

 

[TheGreatGrundy]

Hes exactly the type of player we need. Solid KPD that I feel would get even better in a good team. Perfect compliment to a backline consisting of Howe, Maynard, Crisp and Sharenberg. Dunn probably only has 1 more year in him. He would be a great replacement.

Scharenberg? Wishful thinking. Think 2020 and he may be in the line up.

 

[MagpieJoel]

It would be great if someone could post some footage because I have no clue who he is.

You say that about anyone that doesn't play for Collingwood.

 

[NT.Thunder]

Scharenberg? Wishful thinking. Think 2020 and he may be in the line up.

Agree - won't play next year

 

[left at home]

First round and Langdon.

Get the deal done.

Really?

 

[Sea fog]

So are people assuming the pick we receive for trading Moore will be on-traded to GC for May?

 

[left at home]

So are people assuming the pick we receive for trading Moore will be on-traded to GC for May?

Nope

 

[Sea fog]

Really?

Frustrating we have to give up a first rounder in a great draft. Apparently they want pick in the top five which seem overs. Would be better with our later pick and say Moore, Greenwood, Aish etc. The players would have to agree to go to Qld though.

 

[neilk]

Would May be that much better than Mihocek in defense if we played him there? They’re about the same size.

 

[Sea fog]

Would May be that much better than Mihocek in defense if we played him there? They’re about the same size.

Similar builds too. May is more thickset than athletic.

 

[Shaneprice97]

I want him. I feel like he'll cost our first round and Greenwood.

I'd throw in Oxley for Jack Martin though...

Not sure if serious????

Martin was a mini draft pick mate, basically the equal to a number 1 or 2 pick. He would cost alot to trade in.

 

[left at home]

Frustrating we have to give up a first rounder in a great draft. Apparently they want pick in the top five which seem overs. Would be better with our later pick and say Moore, Greenwood, Aish etc. The players would have to agree to go to Qld though.

What l understand lately is we cannot use this years first in a trade, we have to keep it, so next years will be offered.and a player like smith.

 

[Sea fog]

What l understand lately is we cannot use this years first in a trade, we have to keep it, so next years will be offered.and a player like smith.

That might be better, though future draft picks are very speculative.

 

[elpickle]

need? no
want? yes

 

[left at home]

That might be better, though future draft picks are very speculative.

I think they all are, a talented kid does not always transfer to the afl

 

[unplugged]

I was obviously joking about Oxley for Jack Martin, sheeesh

 

[Shaneprice97]

May looks like a more solid Reid.

Gotta feel for GC potentially losing their book ends... lol.

An athletic Lynden Dunn?

 

[SpongePie]

I guess our ability to trade will depend on,
- if Moore goes (I hope not)
- where we think Kelly and Quaynor sit and how many points we need
- if we can trade our 2019 first rounder

I can't see May being released for anything less than 2 first rounders. I'd like to think it would be less, but I doubt it.

 

[Obese Arachnid]

I was obviously joking about Oxley for Jack Martin, sheeesh

That was obvious, we'd need to get something decent back in that trade.

 

[Sea fog]

I guess our ability to trade will depend on,
- if Moore goes (I hope not)
- where we think Kelly and Quaynor sit and how many points we need
- if we can trade our 2019 first rounder

I can't see May being released for anything less than 2 first rounders. I'd like to think it would be less, but I doubt it.

Two first rounders are too high a cost.

 

[Roverjg]

Marcus Adams wants out of the Dogs

My concern with Adams is twofold. He has averaged 9 games per year over his 3 years in the AFL because of chronic injuries and he allegedly wants a change of scenery. The only change of scenery he would have if he came to us was walking out of the Doggy's medical rooms and into ours. We cannot afford to add another constantly injured player to our list. Also he is only 191cm so I doubt he would be the FB that we need.

 

[Wooljay]

Similar builds too. May is more thickset than athletic.

May is surprisingly quick though, much better athlete than Checkers I'd say.