Draft predictions / Dream Picks

[Barrels]

Hartlett was touch and go for a while. Could never get on the park

True, but always had the ability... IIRC was considered too much of a 'flight risk' by the non-SA clubs.

 

[Joffaboy]

My selections

1. Petracca
21 McCartin
22 Brayshaw
41 Weller

Rookies

Wright
McKenzie
Garlett
Schneider

You know it will happen

 

[Keg on legs]

WANT

1) petracca
21) Duggan
22) R Mac
41) O Mac

THINK
1) petracca
21) R Mac
22) Lamb
41) Miller

 

[Rors]

I put this in the other thread.... If we draft Neal-Bullen, another slowish inside mid to go with Armo, Ross, Curren, Weller, Dunstan, I will be extremely disappointed

No knock on the kid as i rate him well, but he is the opposite of what we need considering we're already going to have Petracca in the bank (so to speak) as well

 

[Armo #20]

IMO there's no way in hell that Duggan or Weller are available and I'd be absolutely shattered if we used Pick 21/22 on McDonald after watching him closely this year.
ND:
1. Petracca
21. Ahern (Neal-Bullen)
22. McKenzie
41. Viojo-Rainbow (Lonie)

 

[Keg on legs]

IMO there's no way in hell that Duggan or Weller are available and I'd be absolutely shattered if we used Pick 21/22 on McDonald after watching him closely this year.
ND:
1. Petracca
21. Ahern (Neal-Bullen)
22. McKenzie
41. Viojo-Rainbow (Lonie)

I agree, hence I had Duggan in my "wants" not my "thinks"

 

[From 45]

1. Petracca
21.ANB
22. Garlett
41. McDonald / lonie

 

[borderbarry]

Emma Quayle has listed Heeney at 1., followed by Wright, Petracca, McCartin. She justifies her decision re Wright by stating that although others will be more ready in 2015, he will be the best player over his career.
Taking this into account, I have selected
1. Peter Wright
21. Cockatoo (If gone Garlett)
22. Lamb or Vickers-Willis (Ah bring back the square dance)
41. Touk Miller or McDonald or Ramsay.

 

[borderbarry]

For you youngsters on here, square dancing was very popular in the 50's, and there were radio shows devoted to it. The best caller in Australia was Jim Vickers-Willis.

 

[Winmar2Lockett]

2nd crack

1- Christian Petracca
21- Reece McKenzie
22- Paul Ahern
41- Connor Menadue
---
Rookie
1- Jack Lonie
19- Elliot Le Grice
37- Jeremy Taylor
55- Adam Schneider

 

[TS74]

1. Patrick McCartin (want Petracca though)
21. Tom Lamb
22. Alex Neal-Bullen
41. Harrison Wigg

 

[Bull3tblitz]

1. Petracca
21. Lamb
22. Ahern
41. Wigg

 

[MCG-Unit]

Dream Draft
1 - Petracca
21 - Weller
22 - Lamb
41 - Touk Miller


Wake up Draft
1 - McCartin
21 - Lamb
22 - Touk Miller / Blakely
41 - Maynard / Daniel McKenzie

 

[SK_MD_#7]

The dream

1: Christian Petracca
21: Liam Duggan
22: Lachie Weller
41: Reece McKenzie

What is more likely

1: Christian Petracca
21: Tom Lamb
22: Reece McKenzie
41: Touk Miller (I hope. )

 

[Kildonan]

Dream draft:

Pick #1 Christian Petracca
Pick #21 Peter Wright
Pick #22 Sam Durdin
Pick #41 Tyler Keitel

Our key positions are set for the next 15 years

Reality draft:

Pick #1 Christian Petracca
Pick #21 Touk Miller / Alex Neal-Bullen
Pick #22 Reece McKenzie
Pick #41 Tyler Keitel (please)

 

[Winners Only]

Okay I have come around to believe the club will pick McCartin at #1 so here is the new group -

1. Patrick McCartin
21. Daniel McKenzie (he adds speed, run & carry)
22. Oscar McDonald (additional developing tall defender/forward)
41. Jack Lonie (classy small forward/midfielder)

Rookies

1. Best available slider
19. Jeremy Taylor (gets nod over Petrenko due his midfield abilities)
38. Shaun McKernan
57. Adam Schneider

 

[Armitage2Riewoldt]

Speaking of nearest the pin, BigFooty is offering $2500 to anyone who can correctly tip the first round of the draft. Probably similar chances to winning the lotto but you still win Platinum/Gold membership if you're the closest. Worth a shot anyway:

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/2014-bigfooty-draft-competition-win-2-500.1081872/

 

[TheLastEmperor]

1. Paddy McCartin
21. Alex Neal-bullen
22. Tom Lamb
41. Jaden McGrath

 

[walshystkfc]

Mines
National
1- McCartin
21-Neal-Bullen
22-Marchbank
41-Lonie

Rookie Draft
Rookies

1. Best player still Avaliable
19. Jeremy Taylor
38. Shaun McKernan
57. Adam Schneider

 

[King_Steele]

1. Patrick McCartin

21. Connor Blakely

22. Tom Lamb/Touk Miller

41. Jake Lonie/Jaden McGrath

Rookie

1. Caleb Daniel

 

[sammm]

Okay I have come around to believe the club will pick McCartin at #1 so here is the new group -

1. Patrick McCartin
21. Daniel McKenzie (he adds speed, run & carry)
22. Oscar McDonald (additional developing tall defender/forward)
41. Jack Lonie (classy small forward/midfielder)

Rookies

1. Best available slider
19. Michael Taylor (gets nod over Petrenko due his midfield abilities)
38. Shaun McKernan
57. Adam Schneider

If McCartin comes in, why pick McKernan?

 

[Winners Only]

If McCartin comes in, why pick McKernan?

Because McKernan will play Stanley's old role, plus it will take a year or so for McCartin to become an AFL lock.

 

[Saint_SF]

1. Paddy McCartin
21. Lachie Weller
22. Dan McKenzie
41. Jack Lonie

 

[Jezzarayman]

Saint_SF I think it may be the same

1. Paddy McCartin
21. Lachie Weller
22. Dan McKenzie
41. Jack Lonie

 

[StMiles1]

Dream Draft:
1. Christian Petracca
21. Lachie Weller
22. Alex Neal-Bullen
41. Jack Lonie

Nearest the Pin
1. Patrick McCartin
21. Tom Lamb
22. Alex Neal-Bullen
41. Jack Lonie