Rumour Draft Rumours 2024 - No rumours allowed

[blaisee]

Richmonds flags were built off of priority picks and we are the ones 'used' to them?

And I'd love to know how we have mismanaged our draft hand?

We only effectively traded a R2 pick.

We've taken a heap of talent, a lot which is still to come into the side.

We don't need 8 selections this year.

Of course to you, everything is perfect in kangaroo land

You still think me saying that Nth want to trade Pick 2 and F1

is a "complete and utter fabrication", so of course to you, having pick 2 and 64 is perfect

 

[Sphynx]

It wasn't a knock on Larkey, he's elite. My question was who's quality underneath him? Support for Larkey is literally their biggest need.

**** me North fans are precious.

****ing hell. I asked a simple question and I'm the precious one?

It's not the Richmond board, we are allowed to comment on one of your posts....

This guy?




Xerri, Logue, Will Dawson, Goad and now Darling?



What should North ideally have in your view? A Bulldogs spread of elite young talls?

Why do we HAVE to take this player and ignore best available?

Why couldn't the side develop and we recruit someone in that role by other means like anyone else?

All of Cameron, Danniher and Hogan were traded for by their current clubs.

 

[jthanos]

You are deadset correct on NM.. went begging for assistance picks and got them.
Tigers got overs for all the players they traded and I can't help thinking that the prices paid were media driven!

overs for Baker yes!

Rioli & Bolton no way, they will make both teams much better !!

 

[Sphynx]

Of course to you, everything is perfect in kangaroo land

You still think me saying that Nth want to trade Pick 2 and F1

is a "complete and utter fabrication", so of course to you, having pick 2 and 64 is perfect

It is.

There is zero chance North trade 2 AND F1.

 

[T4P]

Richmonds flags were built off of priority picks and we are the ones 'used' to them?

And I'd love to know how we have mismanaged our draft hand?

We only effectively traded a R2 pick.

We've taken a heap of talent, a lot which is still to come into the side.

We don't need 8 selections this year.

No comment on North's draft hand. Only here to make a comment on Richmond's priority pick history.

From my understanding, it is a stretch to say Richmond's flags were built on priority picks. Our draft hands were more impacted by Carlton and Melbourne's priority picks. Only priority pick I can recall is Rance at 18 in the 2007 draft.

 

[tiger_tough]

****ing hell. I asked a simple question and I'm the precious one?

It's not the Richmond board, we are allowed to comment on one of your posts....

This guy?

View attachment 2164951


Xerri, Logue, Will Dawson, Goad?



What should North ideally have in your view? A Bulldogs spread of elite young talls?

How many of them are legit KPFs?

FMD. North fans.

 

[blaisee]

No comment on North's draft hand. Only here to make a comment on Richmond's priority pick history.

From my understanding, it is a stretch to say Richmond's flags were built on priority picks. Our draft hands were more impacted by Carlton and Melbourne's priority picks. Only priority pick I can recall is Rance at 18 in the 2007 draft.

thats sounds like a " complete and utter fabrication"

 

[Wild Bill]

Except doing it themselves without begging for assistance picks... as it should be!

lol - give it it time - its coming.....


Did you complain with the Judd, Shuey and Darling assistance picks?? Or is your sooking only limited to other teams?

 

[blaisee]

It is.

There is zero chance North trade 2 AND F1.

no no no, do not get it twisted in your mind

Never said they would

I said they wanna

And that, is the "complete and utter truth"

 

[Sphynx]

How many of them are legit KPFs?

FMD. North fans.

Well, im sure you watch some AFL football right? You tell me?

Charlie Comben - 200cm KPD/KPF
Will Dawson - 203cm KPD/KPF
Nick Larkey - 198cm KPF
Griffen Logue - 191cm KPD
Aiden Corr - 194cm KPD
Jack Darling - 191cm KPF
Toby Pink - 194cm KPD/KPF
Tristian Xerri - 201cm Ruck
Brynn Teakle - 203cm Ruck/FWD
Taylor Goad - 207cm Ruck
CCJ - 200cm Ruck/FWD

You never answered my question, how many do sides need?

Here's the previous few premiership KPF combo's (and the runner up):

2024 - Danniher/Hipwood - Amartey/McDonald
2023 - Cox/Mihocek - Danniher/Hipwood
2022 - Cameron/Hawkins - Franklin/Reid
2021 - Brown/McDonald - Naughton/S.Martin
2020 - Riewoldt/Lynch - Hawkins/Rohan
2019 - Riewoldt/Lynch - Cameron/Finlayson
2018 - Kennedy/Darling - Cox/Mihocek



There's some fairly good duo's in that list, but some equally non-existant ones....

If we assume Larkey is at least on the Danniher level and above Brown, Cox etc. How hard is it to find a Cox/Mihocek or a Hipwood or a Finlayson or a Reid?

It would be great to land a Cameron or Kennedy, but if they aren't there and don't represent value, I think I'd just prefer another Dangerfield or Cousins personally. I think as we get better, players will want to move for some finals action, we can pick up a key forward down the track.

 

[Wild Bill]

Problem with nth is that they are used to afl freebies

Not only do they want great picks for unders, but they also want to give up their picks for overs

Why?

Because they have mismanaged their draft hand, and they want the other teams to bail them out

and anyone that thinks otherwise, is part of an AFL led, media conspiracy

Name a club that doesn't want great picks for under's or give up pick for overs?

Bigfooty - at its best......

 

[Andy_Mac]

Well the bids are relevant when we're talking about a pick being top 20 or not, arent they?

As I said it'll be 18/19 off GWS best case, for Norths F1. The point is whether North think that's good enough to find a quality KPF.

It's access to the 15th and 16th best player in the open draft pool.

 

[Andy_Mac]

Yes the Jackson one worked out so well, would hardly use that as the blueprint. Why not take the best mid after Lalor whether that be Draper, FOS, Jagga, etc

Jackson as a player absolutely has. As far as being a pussyvthay sleeps with a nightlight. That's a different thing

 

[T4P]

Well, im sure you watch some AFL football right? You tell me?

Charlie Comben - 200cm KPD/KPF
Will Dawson - 203cm KPD/KPF
Nick Larkey - 198cm KPF
Griffen Logue - 191cm KPD
Aiden Corr - 194cm KPD
Jack Darling - 191cm KPF
Toby Pink - 194cm KPD/KPF
Tristian Xerri - 201cm Ruck
Brynn Teakle - 203cm Ruck/FWD
Taylor Goad - 207cm Ruck
CCJ - 200cm Ruck/FWD

You never answered my question, how many do sides need?

Sides need more than what Richmond currently have...

 

[tiger_tough]

It's access to the 15th and 16th best player in the open draft pool.

Cool. We were talking about a top 20 pick or not.

 

[tiger_tough]

Well, im sure you watch some AFL football right? You tell me?

Charlie Comben - 200cm KPD/KPF
Will Dawson - 203cm KPD/KPF
Nick Larkey - 198cm KPF
Griffen Logue - 191cm KPD
Aiden Corr - 194cm KPD
Jack Darling - 191cm KPF
Toby Pink - 194cm KPD/KPF
Tristian Xerri - 201cm Ruck
Brynn Teakle - 203cm Ruck/FWD
Taylor Goad - 207cm Ruck
CCJ - 200cm Ruck/FWD

You never answered my question, how many do sides need?

Here's the previous few premiership KPF combo's (and the runner up):

2024 - Danniher/Hipwood - Amartey/McDonald
2023 - Cox/Mihocek - Danniher/Hipwood
2022 - Cameron/Hawkins - Franklin/Reid
2021 - Brown/McDonald - Naughton/S.Martin
2020 - Riewoldt/Lynch - Hawkins/Rohan
2019 - Riewoldt/Lynch - Cameron/Finlayson
2018 - Kennedy/Darling - Cox/Mihocek



There's some fairly good duo's in that list, but some equally non-existant ones....

So.....no one good apart from Larkey, hence why North is so keen on yet another one in Tauru. Got it.

North Fans.

 

[aussierulesrules]

100% they will. GWS will be all over it.

GWS won’t be all over North’s F1 with 15/16 if they’ve traded them to us for 8 and change.

 

[Sphynx]

So.....no one good apart from Larkey, hence why North is so keen on yet another one in Tauru. Got it.

North Fans.

That is if you assume we would be recruiting him as a KPF, after about 3 qtrs of football there?

Again, Larkey + anyone breathing is better than Collingwood have managed to put out there and it hasn't prevented them from getting success.

I think the development of Duursma, Sheezel forward of center, Curtis, Zurhaar and hopefully George with some luck, is much more important to our offence than simply another tall forward.

Darling will have to do in the short term and Comben is moving forward by all reports.

Moving Comben forward would be a strange development if you intended on recruiting Tauru, would it not?

 

[aussierulesrules]

Still makes one fall through. I’d be shocked if anyone until our picks remotely wants talls

I’d be shocked if at least 3 haven’t been taken by then (any or all of Tauru, Armstrong, Shanahan, Whitlock x 2, Trainor).

If we split 8 and change for 15 and 16 you can pretty much bet your bottom dollar that we’ll be going tall with at least one of them.

This offseason we’ve lost 6 “talls” from our list and so far haven’t added any. It’s a big need for us.

 

[Andy_Mac]

Cool. We were talking about a top 20 pick or not.

Yes. And the GWS picks will still be in the top 20 after the academy boys.

 

[Andy_Mac]

GWS won’t be all over North’s F1 with 15/16 if they’ve traded them to us for 8 and change.

This is true. But at this point in time it's fiction

 

[SthMelb Tigers]

Richmonds flags were built off of priority picks and we are the ones 'used' to them?

And I'd love to know how we have mismanaged our draft hand?

We only effectively traded a R2 pick.

We've taken a heap of talent, a lot which is still to come into the side.

We don't need 8 selections this year.

This is laughable to suggest Richmond's flags were built off priority picks. Alex Rance was the only priority pick in the last 20 years, and he played in one of the three premierships. Try again.

 

[xroddddddddddddd]

If Carlton take Draper that throws a cat amongst the pigeons. Seems like outside of Draper, the name most heavily linked with Adelaide is Langford?
Hypothetically Lalor 1, Tauru 2, Ashcroft somewhere around 3-5, Carlton take Draper with their pick, Crows take Langford, could leave FOS available at the dees’ pick 5/6. Not to mention Jagga being available at the tiges’ second pick

 

[richoatthedisco]

Surely we'll pass on that deal.

I hope we don't touch our F1, we won't get value for it and will need it next year. It looks to me like the value this year is in pick 20-35 and in trading out of this draft for F1s. I'm not sure there is anyone in the top ten that really suits us. I'd be happy to trade out of this draft for a couple of decent F1s and a couple of second rounders we could use on tall or small forwards this year. I assume the club will be thinking the exact opposite.

That's an interesting take and one I haven't seen before: trade pick 2 for two F1s? And two R2 picks this year? I think you're getting a little greedy! The first part is eminently doable, I imagine. But not with the R2 picks added, that's la-la-land.

So busy richoatthedisco , look at you with ya multiple reply posts.....still luv the tractors....they are getting closer

Flat out like a lizard drinking, old boy!

 

[Sphynx]

This is laughable to suggest Richmond's flags were built off priority picks. Alex Rance was the only priority pick in the last 20 years, and he played in one of the three premierships. Try again.

So only one of your best defenders ever?

Remind me, how did you attain his replacement again? The other young premiership defender? How did you get that Richmond Captain and 200+ gamer in the first place? Oh...

The Richmond priority pick remnants still lives on the Richmond list, he just signed a 7 year deal.