EDFL Division 1

[Canplaythisguy]

S

surely eds would have signed kite on a 2yr contact as they tried so hard to get him. If not more fool then

You'd think so but Who knows!!

 

[1061]

Just keeping it real. Fact is first year up everyone wanted them to go well until they played them the 1st time and realised the way they went about their footy. Not 1 club would've walked away from Mutton Reserve saying "what a good day of local footy that was" , win or lose. The simple fact that they had to remove players from their club is justification of my comments. This year without 1 of the Caruso boy's and exodus of players they didn't compete at all, and some of the behavior from their reserves was disgraceful - late punches/elbows/knees, kicks, spitting, abusing umpires - Fact - Not up to EDFL Premier League standard. I feel for the good people there who volunteer their time to keep the place afloat. Mick Caruso and others are genuine gun's, but for him to turn his back was the last straw for me.
The truth cannot be ignored

Make your mind up, did the Club remove the players or did they have an exodus?

The Club has been through hell and you are dancing on their grave ..... literally!

 

[NO1FAN]

Who are the challengers to Shylo smith for the best in comp? If there are any? Who runs 2nd and 3rd?

Young or Paige for best in Comp!!!

 

[Canplaythisguy]

Young or Paige for best in Comp!!!

who got invited to the evening ?
Shylo smith and who else?

 

[Uneedakleenex]

S

surely eds would have signed kite on a 2yr contact as they tried so hard to get him. If not more fool then

Will be watching this very closely how this plays out if kite is on a 2 year contract and wants to leave ,
How will EDS handle it ?
You would think the way they carried on with solicitors letters to glenroy that if he wanted to leave they would clear him with no hesitation and won't fight to keep him as that's what they expected from glenroy !
Will be interesting to follow

 

[EDFL knowitall]

who got invited to the evening ?
Shylo smith and who else?

I think Someone from oak park got invited not sure who. At a guess maybe rajab or German

 

[Old Cat]

S Smith getting B.O.G in the grand final tells you something about possible voting in the B&F in comp..

 

[Uneedakleenex]

S Smith getting B.O.G in the grand final tells you something about possible voting in the B&F in comp..

First qtr was out standing maybe the umps had a good memory

 

[theaussieone]

Will be watching this very closely how this plays out if kite is on a 2 year contract and wants to leave ,
How will EDS handle it ?
You would think the way they carried on with solicitors letters to glenroy that if he wanted to leave they would clear him with no hesitation and won't fight to keep him as that's what they expected from glenroy !
Will be interesting to follow

Yes, i too will be watching this one real close. could be interesting if he wants to leave

 

[NO1FAN]

First qtr was out standing maybe the umps had a good memory

1 Qtr shouldn't get u BOG!!

 

[Old Cat]

First qtr was out standing maybe the umps had a good memory

Mate u may as well give him the B&F now if that's how umpires assess games.... Good player being made into a Superstar by default...

 

[Canplaythisguy]

Mate u may as well give him the B&F now if that's how umpires assess games.... Good player being made into a Superstar by default...

Shylos first half was brilliant and yes I agree probably was a bit lucky to win the medal. But the guy is the best player in the comp. but from some of your previous posts you've never had anything good to say about Shylo anyway. If he does go on to win the medal he deserves it. And deserves to play premier football next season

 

[Uneedakleenex]

Shylos first half was brilliant and yes I agree probably was a bit lucky to win the medal. But the guy is the best player in the comp. but from some of your previous posts you've never had anything good to say about Shylo anyway. If he does go on to win the medal he deserves it. And deserves to play premier football next season

Will be in the AFL next year if wallis gets his way !

 

[theaussieone]

Will be in the AFL next year if wallis gets his way !

Shit, what will EDS do if Shylo plays AFL, Kite leaves, Carey retires?

 

[Old Cat]

Shylos first half was brilliant and yes I agree probably was a bit lucky to win the medal. But the guy is the best player in the comp. but from some of your previous posts you've never had anything good to say about Shylo anyway. If he does go on to win the medal he deserves it. And deserves to play premier football next season

Well if you trying your best to get a player rubbed out at the tribunal why would one be positive...

 

[Old Cat]

Think I'm too old school.. S Smith is a good player no doubts....

 

[Canplaythisguy]

Shit, what will EDS do if Shylo plays AFL, Kite leaves, Carey retires?

Carey has retired. Shylo won't play AFL he is a Gun local player. Let's all be honest here.

 

[theaussieone]

Carey has retired. Shylo won't play AFL he is a Gun local player. Let's all be honest here.

yeah your probably right about Shylo. What about Kite and company? will they all stay and play Premier League?

 

[Uneedakleenex]

Well if you trying your best to get a player rubbed out at the tribunal why would one be positive...

Short memory , rnd 1 ring any bells ??

Pretty sure player A put player B in this day !

 

[Turbos mail]

Well if you trying your best to get a player rubbed out at the tribunal why would one be positive...

Mate get over this criticism of Shylo. I'm not sure why you dislike him and I don't think your accusation is true anyhow. Shylo is a good, fair, respected player.

As for Wallis saying Shylo should be given an opportunity to play AFL, well clearly he was on the frothies when he said this, as let's keep it in perspective it's b grade his playing after all.

 

[Canplaythisguy]

yeah your probably right about Shylo. What about Kite and company? will they all stay and play Premier League?

You'd like to think kite and co would stay and give premier a crack expecially after how had Douttas worked to get him across.

 

[theaussieone]

You'd like to think kite and co would stay and give premier a crack expecially after how had Douttas worked to get him across.

Yeah i agree, EDS would be really pissed off if they all leave, but who knows these days!

 

[Time to relax]

I've heard Kite staying, also heard he played the GF with a broken wrist. Great Effort following a rigorous fitness test on the Tuesday before the game.

 

[Old Cat]

Mate get over this criticism of Shylo. I'm not sure why you dislike him and I don't think your accusation is true anyhow. Shylo is a good, fair, respected player.

As for Wallis saying Shylo should be given an opportunity to play AFL, well clearly he was on the frothies when he said this, as let's keep it in perspective it's b grade his playing after all.

Mate open forum we are all here to comment as we see it... My accusation is 100% spot on but anyways we move forward now... Good player no doubt all the best in the Premier division...

 

[Old Cat]

Short memory , rnd 1 ring any bells ??

Pretty sure player A put player B in this day !

Let's go bck to 1988 player A put player B in that day too... Long memory...