Elimination Final vs Adelaide - Changes?

Remove this Banner Ad

Dave The Man

Cancelled
Collingwood Magpies - Alan Didak 2009 Player Sponsor
Sep 17, 2006
9,697
12
Vic
AFL Club
Collingwood
Other Teams
Storm,Victory,Blue Jays
Changes:

In:Wood Burns Thomas Wakes

Out:Bryan Stanley Cook Presti/Brown
 

Log in to remove this ad.

  • Thread starter
  • Banned
  • #7
whats the deal with big anth? if he is fit he should be in....

gees i hate that our club wont play dids and shaw... would be a certainty id believe with those too...

1-3 Weeks but he won't be Match Fit
 
In: Wood, Thomas

Out: Bryan, Cook

If Burns is able to play, bring him in for Stanley.

If Rocca is somehow able to play he comes in for Dawes.

On form, you'd probably be inclined to drop Brown for Wakelin but I don't think we need to against Adelaide based on their forward set-up. Plus, I'd prefer he plays the rest of the season for confidence reasons.
I'd also consider bringing in Wellingham for Stanley, meaning we need Leon and Thomas to play as much in the midfield as they can.
 
OUT: Stanley, Cook, Wakelin.
IN: Burns, Thomas, Presti.

I'm just hoping that Burns is ready, otherwise we won't win IMO.

Presti was okay last week, but Wakelin will be fresh, and has better disposal. After not playing all year, I'd rather have the guy who has played nearly every match. Presti will be in next year for sure though.
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

In: Thomas, Wellingham, Burns

Out: Stanley, Cook, Cox


If Rocca is 70% fit, he comes in for dawes

And those who believe that obree will be dropped must be taking some illegal narcotics, because 1) he is crucial to our clearances, especially without burns and 2) mick loves him
 
In: Thomas, Wellingham, Burns, Wakelin

Out: Stanley, Cook, Cox, Brown

Above mimimum. Maybe Wood for Bryan and if we are going to roll the dice with Rocca then out goes Dawes.

Oh and Didak and Shaw in for whoever :thumbsu:
 
I'd say Wood may come in (he played good in the VFL yesterday) for Bryan, Thomas, Burns (if fit), and Wakelin.

Can't say who'll come out out. People who are calling for Cox to come out: he was in our best on Friday and has played great since the late inclusion against Sydney. I'd say he'd be in for sure.

Didak and Shaw are definitely not coming in (see Mick's comments in the press conference after the match) so it's no use calling for them. Look forward to seeing them in 2009 (hopefully in the Collingwood jumper).
 
In: Thomas, Wellingham, Burns

Out: Stanley, Cook, Cox


If Rocca is 70% fit, he comes in for dawes

And those who believe that obree will be dropped must be taking some illegal narcotics, because 1) he is crucial to our clearances, especially without burns and 2) mick loves him

COX? COX? He has been probably our best for the past 2 weeks. People hold grudges around here, at least my grudges (rhys shaw) should be dropped. Cox is playing very well you clown
 
COX? COX? He has been probably our best for the past 2 weeks. People hold grudges around here, at least my grudges (rhys shaw) should be dropped. Cox is playing very well you clown


I will second you on that. Cox has a few things to work on with his game but his skill level is good and I'm yet to see him put in a bad game. I wish the same could be said for the Stanleys, Shaws, Cooks and Wellinghams
 
I don't think Wakes in against Adelaide is a smart move. They have a quick forward line and Wakes aint that type of defender.
Could say the same thing about Presti
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Elimination Final vs Adelaide - Changes?

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top