Fev requests to go to Pies or Saints - Confirmed

[Teak_Pies]

Would the Pies give up Cloke? I would take him and 14

deal

 

[GMJ345]

Would the Pies give up Cloke? I would take him and 14

I would never take Cloke we wont accept a trade from them they dont have any stand out big fowards and pik 14 would be nice but i hope if he does goes, he goes to Sydney and we get somthin like O'Keefe and pik 6 i think it is

 

[Cruiser23]

Pick 14 and Nathan Brown

 

[Rooiginal]

Dogs wouldn't make the top 4 without Lake...

Stupid trade for them. The Dogs should give whatever Lake wants because there is no player in the league that would be as much value to the Dogs as Lake. Take him out of their backline and they are in deep trouble.

The picture inside your profile is the greatest thing I have witnessed visually in all my time.

 

[hawk life]

I watch a lot of Carlton as my wife is a mad Carlton fan and you do need a forward if you trade fev.

Would Carlton fans entertain the idea of trading Fev for Travis Cloke?

I know Fev is better and Travis is a bit hit and miss but at least you will have a target.

Sorry just read the posts prev.

 

[Malifice]

Pick 14 and Nathan Brown

Id be looking for a top 6 pick and Brown personally.

Or a three way deal that gets us McKinley and Brown.

 

[Cruiser23]

Id be looking for a top 6 pick and Brown personally.

Or a three way deal that gets us McKinley and Brown.

Obviously would be better with a top 10 pick and Brown but the Pies don't have it nor can i see how they/we could obtain one unless Roos is talking shite...

 

[hammers_2]

Fevola + 2nd rounder to Sydney for pick 6 + ROK + Veszpremi

 

[Malifice]

Obviously would be better with a top 10 pick and Brown but the Pies don't have it nor can i see how they/we could obtain one unless Roos is talking shite...

Pick 6 (or is it 7?) from WCE for say... Leon Davis and pick 14 or 30?

 

[BlueDevil]

if the carlton board are serious and commited to trading fev, i dont think they'll even bother talking to the pies fearing a massive supporter backlash. just saying. this isn't heath scotland we're talking about here.

 

[ThePieMan]

As I said in another post, Eddie McGuire has been "councelling" him since the Brownlow!

********, it ``counselling''. We can f**k off the other Cloke to you duds for him!

 

[Canyouhearthedrums]

I would never take Cloke we wont accept a trade from them they dont have any stand out big fowards and pik 14 would be nice but i hope if he does goes, he goes to Sydney and we get somthin like O'Keefe and pik 6 i think it is

Cloke had a bad year but I think he has alot of talent. he also gets ****ed by MMs game plan.

I had forgotten about N Brown, I like the look of him too.

Ideally, Fev is worth a top 5-6 pick but I wonder wherhe we could get it from?

 

[Cruiser23]

Pick 6 (or is it 7?) from WCE for say... Leon Davis and pick 14 or 30?

Potentially...

Who knows though, VERY interesting week next week.

 

[favourites]

Cloke had a bad year but I think he has alot of talent. he also gets ****ed by MMs game plan.

I had forgotten about N Brown, I like the look of him too.

Ideally, Fev is worth a top 5-6 pick but I wonder wherhe we could get it from?

He will be 29 before the season starts. Lloyd has just retired at 31, so he may only get 3 years. I doubt many teams would give up a hell of a lot for 3 years of Fev. (ie we will not give up pick 14 and Leon for him)

 

[CUG81]

We wont get much for him cuz no one is going to offer their better players and draft picks for him.

This whole thing is just F'd!

 

[Thommo 42]

Here it is.

for

+ Pick 14

(promise his shoulders are fine)

 

[AlecDuncan]

I'd trade Fev to Saints for Kosi, doubt they would though.

Fevola+ ??? + ??? for Kosi, Cahill & Maguire

Someone tell me what Kosi has done lately, because I suspect it's 1/10 of **** all.

 

[The Exorcist]

Someone tell me what Kosi has done lately, because I suspect it's 1/10 of **** all.

Tend to agree with AD here, Kosi ain't bad but he's only a support act

 

[blueblooded]

****en muppets take a step back and realise that if we trade Fev to the Pies we will hand them a flag!!! THIS IS RIDICULOUS!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Keep Fev, help him, this is a lose lose situatuion for us. The whole comp is laughing at us!

Sack the board if he goes to Collingwood, bunch of incompetents!

 

[The Exorcist]

Here it is.

for

+ Pick 14

(promise his shoulders are fine)

Thommo 42 that nearly makes me puke

... if such a trade goes ahead I don't think i could go to a Pies / Blues game until Fev retires

 

[BlueDevil]

Thommo 42 that nearly makes me puke

... if such a trade goes ahead I don't think i could go to a Pies / Blues game until Fev retires

yep, cant see us dealing with the pies if we're dead serious. would be disrespectful to us supporters.

 

[Warnock2Judd2Fev]

We wont get much for him cuz no one is going to offer their better players and draft picks for him.

This whole thing is just F'd!

i agree , which makes me lean towards Fev still being a Blueboy in 2010

 

[CUG81]

Someone tell me what Kosi has done lately, because I suspect it's 1/10 of **** all.

agreed, he does nothing..takes a grab here and there but seriously is behind many FF in the.

Blueblooded, the pies need more than Fev to win the flag!

 

[Thommo 42]

Thommo 42 that nearly makes me puke

my suggestion of course wouldn't get it done. But as far as puking goes...

 

[The Exorcist]

my suggestion of course wouldn't get it done. But as far as puking goes...

That one makes me puke