Gary Ayres award (2024)

Remove this Banner Ad

Log in to remove this ad.

HairyO said:
Yep its always been the major flaw with the award. Players from the best teams are at a massive disadvantage.

Either 3 best scores or average the 4 would be the obvious fixes.
Click to expand...

Maybe they should at 25% loading to prelims as well?

Or otherwise make Grand finals double and prelims 50% loading.

kreuze_missile said:
Sam Walsh back to back.
Click to expand...

He wouldn't even get a game at Hawthorn right now.
 
HairyO said:
Yep its always been the major flaw with the award. Players from the best teams are at a massive disadvantage.

Either 3 best scores or average the 4 would be the obvious fixes.
Click to expand...

I wouldn't say it's a massive disadvantage.

In fact, every player that has won the award ever has come from a team that played 3 games, so it really hasn't proven to be a big issue so far.

Players also have come from the best teams, with Sam Walsh the only winner from a non Grand Finalist.

I do agree it has the potential to be an issue and the it should be considered - but it certainly hasn't played out that way so far at all.
 
Guardian Hawk said:
I wouldn't say it's a massive disadvantage.

In fact, every player that has won the award ever has come from a team that played 3 games, so it really hasn't proven to be a big issue so far.

Players also have come from the best teams, with Sam Walsh the only winner from a non Grand Finalist.

I do agree it has the potential to be an issue and the it should be considered - but it certainly hasn't played out that way so far at all.
Click to expand...

Richmond 2020?

I havent looked at any other years...
 
Neale or Tom Green favourite now I think, both had 4-5 votes and could be in for the four games rarely play a bad game.
 
HairyO said:
Richmond 2020?

I havent looked at any other years...
Click to expand...

Ah yes, I missed that one - but it made no difference at all.

Martin scored 28 coaches votes that finals series. Only 1 other player scored more than 10 (Duncan) and his team also played 4 games. Under the current rules (1.5 weighting for the GF), he would have scored 33 votes and been miles clear of 2nd regardless of the extra game.

As would often be the case, Martin scored 0 votes in the game his team lost but was best on ground in the Semi, the Prelim and the Grand Final. Fully deserving.

Certainly not a case of the best teams being highly disadvantaged with the medallist coming from the premier.

I do agree it is a bit of a flaw in the system - it just hasn't manifested that way yet (suggesting it may be pretty uncommon for it to make much of a difference rather than the best teams being highly disadvantaged, especially with the GF weighting in play).
 

Leaderboard​

15 Jai Newcombe (HAW)
14 Dayne Zorko (BL)
10 Jase Burgoyne (PORT)
10 Isaac Heeney (SYD)
10 Max Holmes (GEEL)
8 Hugh McCluggage (BL)
7 Tom Green (GWS)
7 Jesse Hogan (GWS)
7 Shaun Mannagh (GEEL)
6 Cameron Rayner (BL)
6 James Sicily (HAW)
5 Callum Ah Chee (BL)
5 Will Ashcroft (BL)
5 Jarrod Berry (BL)
5 Jake Lloyd (SYD)
5 Jordon Sweet (PORT)
4 Karl Amon (HAW)
4 Mark Blicavs (GEEL)
4 Jack Buckley (GWS)
4 Josh Kelly (GWS)
4 Lloyd Meek (HAW)
4 Lachie Neale (BL)
4 Jack Scrimshaw (HAW)
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

I feel like Newcombe was a little unlucky in the votes for the semi -final.

The coaches have clearly voted very differently. Happy that Jase Burgoyne got BOG but I thought Newcombe was the other one clearly vying for that and very clearly top 2, with a blanket over a few others a long way behind those top 2.

Newcombe had 8 more possessions than anyone else on the ground. He had the most contested possessions of anyone on the ground. He had the most effective possessions of anyone on the ground. He had the (equal) most clearances of anyone on the ground. He also had 6 tackles, 2 goal assists and the most score involvements and score launches for his team.

Thought it was more of an 8-9 vote game than a 5 vote game (as one coach obviously felt and one didn't).
 
Guardian Hawk said:
I feel like Newcombe was a little unlucky in the votes for the semi -final.

The coaches have clearly voted very differently. Happy that Jase Burgoyne got BOG but I thought Newcombe was the other one clearly vying for that and very clearly top 2, with a blanket over a few others a long way behind those top 2.

Newcombe had 8 more possessions than anyone else on the ground. He had the most contested possessions of anyone on the ground. He had the most effective possessions of anyone on the ground. He had the (equal) most clearances of anyone on the ground. He also had 6 tackles, 2 goal assists and the most score involvements and score launches for his team.

Thought it was more of an 8-9 vote game than a 5 vote game (as one coach obviously felt and one didn't).
Click to expand...
I agree, I thought Newcombe was BOG clearly, I didn't see the hype of Burgoyne played well but I thought maybe a little bit too much sauce was put on it being his first big game that he has played well.
 
AFL Coaches Association Gary Ayres Award (Best Finals Player) - Top 5

Players with asterisk won Norm Smith medal

2016

1. Josh Kennedy (Sydney): 18
2. Jason Johannisen (Western Bulldogs): 17*
3. Isaac Heeney (Sydney): 15
4. Liam Picken (Western Bulldogs): 15
5. Joel Selwood (Geelong): 14

2017

1. Dustin Martin (Richmond): 25*
2. Trent Cotchin (Richmond): 15
3. Calling Ward (GWS): 14
4. Brad Crouch (Adelaide): 11
5. Bachar Houli (Richmond): 10

2018

1. Steele Sidebottom (Collingwood): 23
2. Taylor Adams (Collingwood): 18
3. Jack Redden (West Coast): 17
4. Dylan Grimes (Richmond): 10
5. Luke Shuey (West Coast): 10*

2019

1. Dustin Martin (Richmond): 19*
2. Tim Taranto (GWS): 13
3. Bachar Houli (Richmond): 12
4. Joel Selwood (Geelong): 11
5. Jamie Cripps (West Coast): 10

2020

1. Dustin Martin (Richmond): 28*
2. Mitch Duncan (Geelong): 22
3. Nic Natanui (West Coast): 10
4. Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong): 9
5. Shane Edwards (Richmond): 9

2021

1. Jack McRae (Western Bulldogs): 25
2. Christian Petracca (Melbourne): 23*
3. Clayton Oliver (Melbourne): 19
4. Bailey Smith (Western Bulldogs): 17
5. Marcus Bontempelli (Western Bulldogs): 11

2022

1. Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong): 22
2. Jack Crisp (Collingwood): 16
3. Jordan De Goey (Collingwood): 15
4. Lachie Neale (Brisbane): 15
5. Isaac Smith (Geelong): 15*

2023

1. Sam Walsh (Carlton): 23
2. Keidean Coleman (Brisbane): 20.5
3. Bobby Hill (Collingwood): 19*
4. Tom Green (GWS): 17
5. Jack Crisp (Collingwood): 16

2024

1. ??
2. ??
3. ??
4. ??
5. ??

Multiple Winners

Dustin Martin: 3 - 2017, 2019 & 2020

Back to Back Winners

Dustin Martin: 2019 & 2020

Norm Smith/Gary Ayres - Same Year

Dustin Martin: 3 - 2017, 2019 & 2020

Norm Smith/Gary Ayres - In Career

Dustin Martin: 3 - 2017, 2019 & 2020

Premiership/Gary Ayres - Same Year

Dustin Martin: 2017, 2019 & 2020

Patrick Dangerfield: 2022

Premiership/Gary Ayres - In Career

Dustin Martin: 2017, 2019 & 2020

Patrick Dangerfield: 2022

Norm Smith Medal: Best on Ground in Grand Final

Sam Walsh: only Gary Ayres Award winner to not play in Grand Final
 
Last edited:
Lunchtime said:
AFL Coaches Association Gary Ayres Award (Best Finals Player) - Top 5

Players with asterisk won Norm Smith medal

2016

1. Josh Kennedy (Sydney): 18
2. Jason Johannisen (Western Bulldogs): 17*
3. Isaac Heeney (Sydney): 15
4. Liam Picken (Western Bulldogs): 15
5. Joel Selwood (Geelong): 14

2017

1. Dustin Martin (Richmond): 25*
2. Trent Cotchin (Richmond): 15
3. Calling Ward (GWS): 14
4. Brad Crouch (Adelaide): 11
5. Bachar Houli (Richmond): 10

2018

1. Steele Sidebottom (Collingwood): 23
2. Taylor Adams (Collingwood): 18
3. Jack Redden (West Coast): 17
4. Dylan Grimes (Richmond): 10
5. Luke Shuey (West Coast): 10*

2019

1. Dustin Martin (Richmond): 19*
2. Tim Taranto (GWS): 13
3. Bachar Houli (Richmond): 12
4. Joel Selwood (Geelong): 11
5. Jamie Cripps (West Coast): 10

2020

1. Dustin Martin (Richmond): 28*
2. Mitch Duncan (Geelong): 22
3. Nic Natanui (West Coast): 10
4. Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong): 9
5. Shane Edwards (Richmond): 9

2021

1. Jack McRae (Western Bulldogs): 25
2. Christian Petracca (Melbourne): 23*
3. Clayton Oliver (Melbourne): 19
4. Bailey Smith (Western Bulldogs): 17
5. Marcus Bontempelli (Western Bulldogs): 11

2022

1. Patrick Dangerfield (Geelong): 22
2. Jack Crisp (Collingwood): 16
3. Jordan De Goey (Collingwood): 15
4. Lachie Neale (Brisbane): 15
5. Isaac Smith (Geelong): 15*

2023

1. Sam Walsh (Carlton): 23
2. Keidean Coleman (Brisbane): 20.5
3. Bobby Hill (Collingwood): 19*
4. Tom Green (GWS): 17
5. Jack Crisp (Collingwood): 16

2024

1. ??
2. ??
3. ??
4. ??
5. ??

Multiple Winners

Dustin Martin: 3 - 2017, 2019 & 2020

Back to Back Winners

Dustin Martin: 2019 & 2020

Norm Smith Medal/Gary Ayres Award - Same Year

Dustin Martin: 3 - 2017, 2019 & 2020


Norm Smith Medal: Best on Ground in Grand Final

Sam Walsh: only Gary Ayres Award winner to not play in Grand Final
Click to expand...

Feels like Heeney will take it now that Holmes is apparently sick.

I’m still big on “The Chad” for the NS
 
Lunchtime said:
Heeney could do the Norm Smith medal/Gary Ayres Award double (Same year) for sure.
Click to expand...
He was obviously BOG against the Giants. Yesterday was a very even performance across the team. He was still very good. Some might have him as BOG. But it’s not clear cut he’ll get the ten votes.

If the Lions win tonight and Zorko has even a very good (not necessarily BOG) game he’s probably in the box seat by dint of playing four games to any Swan’s three.
 
liz said:
He was obviously BOG against the Giants. Yesterday was a very even performance across the team. He was still very good. Some might have him as BOG. But it’s not clear cut he’ll get the ten votes.

If the Lions win tonight and Zorko has even a very good (not necessarily BOG) game he’s probably in the box seat by dint of playing four games to any Swan’s three.
Click to expand...

Heeney got the 10 votes for his performance against GWS. In terms of the game against Port Adelaide....maybe in the 6 to 8 vote range? You could be right.. he might get the full 10 votes.....depends how the coaches saw the game and how they assess it.
 
Feels unfair when some teams play 3 games and others may get 4.

IMO points should scale at the prelims AND again at the granny (/10 /10 /15 /20). Average is a decent idea but could be controversial if someone misses games. Perhaps average or highest score from wk 1 & 2, or you take the players 3 best scores across the finals series.

Sent from my Pixel 8 Pro using Tapatalk
 
Last edited:

Remove this Banner Ad

Gary Ayres award (2024)

Similar threads

Jeremias
Toast Sam Walsh - 2023 Gary Ayres Award winner
2 3
Replies
58
Views
3K
Corn Cobbers
Corn Cobbers
Teen Wolf
AFLW 2024 Awards
Replies
13
Views
461
Air_Chester
Air_Chester
Lunchtime
Opinion Awards
Replies
0
Views
135
Lunchtime
Lunchtime
WalshistheGOAT
Would a single combined 'MVP' award fix the end of year Awards dilemma?
Replies
12
Views
362
_Mike_
_Mike_
sthmelb_dimmies
  • Poll
Ditching the gala dinner, then which award is a greater achievement?
Replies
5
Views
245
Cleansweep17
Cleansweep17
R
Leigh Matthews Trophy most prestigious individual award
2 3 4 5
Replies
123
Views
4K
the harry
the harry
Toump Ass
Best choke of 2024
2 3 4 5
Replies
121
Views
5K
BigVic
BigVic

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top