Geelong vs. St Kilda - Who do you want to win?

[Wonaeamirri33]

Would have to say St Kilda...

 

[footyfreak]

I don't really care who wins. Don't really get why people support a team in the GF if their teams not playing. I don't see the need to feel apart of the day and support a team i really don't care about for one game.

It is the supporters of those teams playing day. I can't support another team on unless there is benefit for my team (i.e. the bulldogs coz i would have preferred to play them in a GF than St Kilda had we won). And even then i wasn't too concerned although i felt really bad for the doggie supporters, well as bad as i could.

My only exception has been 97/98 where i openly went for the crows coz i had a mate playing for them. Helped a little being a south aussie i guess but it was really coz he was playing.

Since then i haven't given two stuffs who won outside of 02/03.

 

[Jascave]

I'm going for St Kilda to win, but only by 3 points. But what price a draw-the first since 1977?

 

[outabounds]

Geelong deserve another Flag- it would not be right for them to come out of this era with only one.

 

[JeffDunne]

Nobody ever 'deserves' a flag.

 

[outabounds]

Nobody ever 'deserves' a flag.

WTF- So are you saying nobody ever deserves to win it?

 

[JeffDunne]

You 'earn it', nobody 'deserves it'.

I could make a disparaging remark about it being no surprise who you support but . . . oops!

 

[Timmy from Thomastown]

Nobody ever 'deserves' a flag.

They do if they link arms.

 

[outabounds]

You 'earn it', nobody 'deserves it'.

I could make a disparaging remark about it being no surprise who you support but . . . oops!

16 premierships to 1- i think we know about which club knows how to do it.

 

[Xtreme]

I honestly hope we see a few draws leading to 2 - 3 grand final replays over the next few weeks.

I don't want Geelong to win, as it would make a mockery of the media's "best team this decade" tag. And it will be hilarious to see Ablett turn on the woe is me waterworks

I don't want St Kilda to win as it would be great to see their premiership drought continue. I'd also like to see Nick have a cry about something else, and add Maxie to that list too . Not to mention there are a few scrubs (one being Milne) who don't deserve the 'premiership player' tag.

 

[Majinbuu]

I think geelong will win, but I'm cheering for the saints

 

[JeffDunne]

16 premierships to 1- i think we know about which club knows how to do it.

The club might, but the latest generation of bandwagon supporters clearly don't.

Find me a Carlton supporter that didn't start following on the back of a GF win and I'll show you someone born into Carlton. You attract a certain type.

 

[Truetiger]

St. Kilda.
Collingwood supporters are the worst supporters in Victoria, and I would hate to see them win anything.

Thats better. How can a Collingwood fan say another club have the worst fans... Look at your own. Geelong to win

 

[dan warna]

Clearly st kilda but im incredibly nervous, the cats looked impressive saturday night, they put the pies down brutally, and the saints looked solid against the pies and scratchy against the dogs.

both teams were comfortably catered for by the cats in this series.

the real cats are about after a snooze since round 14.

 

[outabounds]

The club might, but the latest generation of bandwagon supporters clearly don't.

Find me a Carlton supporter that didn't start following on the back of a GF win and I'll show you someone born into Carlton. You attract a certain type.

Does that mean that you can only be a true supporter if you follow a team with a woeful record like the Saints?
I forgot to mention that one of the biggest reasons that i'm going for the cats is that you are the single most provocative tool in Big Footy.

 

[JeffDunne]

Does that mean that you can only be a true supporter if you follow a team with a woeful record like the Saints?

Of course not.

TBH, it is so typical of the mindset I was describing that you'd automatically assume history has a major bearing on the decision.

I forgot to mention that one of the biggest reasons that i'm going for the cats is that you are the single most provocative tool in Big Footy.

Why thank you.

Quite a compliment.

 

[outabounds]

I thought you would appreciate it

 

[graden]

I would like to see the Saints win it purely for the true supporters of the club. Sure there are a lot of arrogant Saints supporters but there are also a lot of true supporters who have stuck with them through the bad times.

Geelong tasted success two years ago so their supporters have the memory of it.

Most St Kilda fans aren't so lucky.

Good luck to both teams anyway.

 

[remedi]

Im going for the saints just cause out of the players playing, nick riewoldt would be my favourite. He's a champ and he deserves it after the year he had.

 

[The Sloane Ranger]

my head and heart says the Cats

 

[WhyAlwaysMe]

I'm staying with a Geelong family when I go to Melbourne later in the week so I'll have to pretend Geelong but I really want the Saints to win

 

[Hard Ball Get]

At the start of the finals series I said if the dogs don't wim it then I don't care who does as long as it's not St. Kilda.

Go Cats.

 

[NoName]

I hope the Saints get smashed - so therefore GO CATS.

 

[wce4premiership]

I want Saint kilda to win, always had a soft spot for them.

 

[Military_man]

st kilda but should be a great game of footy and these two sides both deserve to be there.