Greatest Ever Sitcom Voting Thread Round 1

[Captain Sensible]

Edit: Executive decision. I call shenanigans. Dad's Army will go against Men Behaving Badly and one other show in a 3 way contest in round 2.

A repercharge? You beauty!

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

I Dream of Jeannie 5 vs The Larry Sanders Show 5
Yes Minister 1 vs Frasier 6
The Good Life 1 vs To The Manor Born 1
Sex And The City 1 defeated by Everybody Loves Raymond 7
Taxi 0 defeated by Seinfeld 7
The Odd Couple 4 vs Murphy Brown 0
Gilligan's Island 4 vs The Wonder Years 1
Andy Griffith 0 defeated by Blackadder 7
Welcome Back Kotter 5 vs Alice 0
Til Death Us Do Part 0 vs The Honeymooners 0
The Office (UK) 1 vs The Golden Girls 0
Malcolm In The Middle 1 vs McHale's Navy 0
Gomer Pyle USMC 0 vs The Nanny 1
The Goodies 1 vs Mind Your Language 0
Red Dwarf 0 vs Scrubs 0
Saved By The Bell 0 vs 3rd Rock From The Sun 0 vs Frontline 0
Hogan's Heroes 0 vs The Addams Family 0


Remember to keep voting for matchups you have not voted for yet, until one of them reaches 7 and eliminates the other.

 

[Howard Littlejohn]

The Office (UK) vs The Golden Girls - surely has to be 7-0
Malcolm In The Middle vs McHale's Navy
Gomer Pyle USMC vs The Nanny - don't remember GP, but it has to be better than The Nanny
The Goodies vs Mind Your Language
Red Dwarf vs Scrubs
Saved By The Bell vs 3rd Rock From The Sun vs Frontline
Hogan's Heroes vs The Addams Family

Dwarf, Goodies, Frontline, The Office - there's some A grade material in that batch.

 

[drew_j]

Yes Minister 1 vs Frasier 6
The Odd Couple 4 vs Murphy Brown 0
Gilligan's Island 4 vs The Wonder Years 1
Welcome Back Kotter 5 vs Alice 0
The Office (UK) 1 vs The Golden Girls 0
Malcolm In The Middle 1 vs McHale's Navy 0
Gomer Pyle USMC 0 vs The Nanny 1
The Goodies 1 vs Mind Your Language 0
Red Dwarf 0 vs Scrubs 0
Saved By The Bell 0 vs 3rd Rock From The Sun 0 vs Frontline 0
Hogan's Heroes 0 vs The Addams Family 0

 

[Howard Littlejohn]

Wow. I really can't believe the timeless brilliance of Yes, Minister has been knocked out by the adequate but average Frasier.

 

[drew_j]

Wow. I really can't believe the timeless brilliance of Yes, Minister has been knocked out by the adequate but average Frasier.

Yes Minister was boring when it came out and it aged poorly. Can't stand it and never could.

 

[Warwick]

Yes Minister 1 vs Frasier 6
The Good Life 1 vs To The Manor Born 1
The Odd Couple 4 vs Murphy Brown 0
Gilligan's Island 4 vs The Wonder Years 1
Welcome Back Kotter 5 vs Alice 0
The Office (UK) 1 vs The Golden Girls 0 - easiest choice so far.
Malcolm In The Middle 1 vs McHale's Navy 0
Gomer Pyle USMC 0 vs The Nanny 1
The Goodies 1 vs Mind Your Language 0
Red Dwarf 0 vs Scrubs 0 - Toughest match up so far.
Saved By The Bell 0 vs 3rd Rock From The Sun 0 vs Frontline 0
Hogan's Heroes 0 vs The Addams Family 0

There is no way that Men Behaving Badly was a better sitcom than Dad's Army. No way at all!

 

[rupert pupkin 87]

Yes Minister 1 vs Frasier 6
The Good Life 1 vs To The Manor Born 1
The Odd Couple 4 vs Murphy Brown 0
Gilligan's Island 4 vs The Wonder Years 1
Welcome Back Kotter 5 vs Alice 0
The Office (UK) 1 vs The Golden Girls 0 - easiest choice so far.
Malcolm In The Middle 1 vs McHale's Navy 0
Gomer Pyle USMC 0 vs The Nanny 1
The Goodies 1 vs Mind Your Language 0
Red Dwarf 0 vs Scrubs 0 - Toughest match up so far.
Saved By The Bell 0 vs 3rd Rock From The Sun 0 vs Frontline 0
Hogan's Heroes 0 vs The Addams Family 0

There is no way that Men Behaving Badly was a better sitcom than Dad's Army. No way at all!

Yes Minister
The Odd Couple
Gilligans
The Office
Malcolm
The Goodies
Scrubs
Frontline
Hogans Heroes

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

There is no way that Men Behaving Badly was a better sitcom than Dad's Army. No way at all!

There are extenuating circumstances to that match up. Both will go through to round 2 and go up against each other in a 3 way matchup.

 

[apollo_creed]

The Honeymooners
The Nanny
3rd Rock From The Sun
Scrubs

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

I Dream of Jeannie 5 vs The Larry Sanders Show 5
Yes Minister 1 defeated by Frasier 7
The Good Life 1 vs To The Manor Born 2
The Odd Couple 7 defeated Murphy Brown 0
Gilligan's Island 6 vs The Wonder Years 2
Welcome Back Kotter 7 defeated Alice 0
Til Death Us Do Part 0 vs The Honeymooners 1
The Office (UK) 4 vs The Golden Girls 1
Malcolm In The Middle 4 vs McHale's Navy 1
Gomer Pyle USMC 3 vs The Nanny 2
The Goodies 5 vs Mind Your Language 0
Red Dwarf 3 vs Scrubs 2
Saved By The Bell 0 vs 3rd Rock From The Sun 1 vs Frontline 4
Hogan's Heroes 1 vs The Addams Family 3


Remember to keep voting for matchups you have not voted for yet, until one of them reaches 7 and eliminates the other.

 

[apollo_creed]

Not sure. Do we get enough people visiting the board to increase it that much?

As you can see, such numbers will be easy to attract.

As this thread grows in popularity and subsequents numbers it's integral the number of votes required to win also wins in order to get the most accurate results.

Going up in 2 is probably best/easiest.

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

As you can see, such numbers will be easy to attract.

As this thread grows in popularity and subsequents numbers it's integral the number of votes required to win also wins in order to get the most accurate results.

Going up in 2 is probably best/easiest.

9 in Round 2 and 11 in round 3, then open poll threads thereafter.

 

[apollo_creed]

9 in Round 2 and 11 in round 3, then open poll threads thereafter.

Even better.

Polls open for a week?

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

The Office (UK)
McHale's Navy
The Nanny
The Goodies
Scrubs
3rd Rock From The Sun
Hogan's Heroes

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

Even better.

Polls open for a week?

No Round of 16 polls for a day, Qtr Finals for two days, Semi Finals for 3 days and Final for a week.

I am sure I will tire of doing it if it goes on too long!

 

[SouthSwans]

The Office (UK) vs The Golden Girls
Malcolm In The Middle vs McHale's Navy
Gomer Pyle USMC vs The Nanny
The Goodies vs Mind Your Language
Red Dwarf vs Scrubs
Saved By The Bell vs 3rd Rock From The Sun vs Frontline
Hogan's Heroes vs The Addams Family

 

[Cousin Jed]

The Office
Frontline
Scrubs
Giligans Island. (Finish that one off!)

The great part about this thread is seeing mutliple shots of Reese on every page

 

[AndSmithMustScore]

I just came acorss this thread, and iv'e not seen Father Ted in the list?

How can there. be a sitcom thread without Father Ted involved!

 

[apollo_creed]

I just came acorss this thread, and iv'e not seen Father Ted in the list?

How can there. be a sitcom thread without Father Ted involved!

Agree.

Definitely in my top 5.

Hopefully sense prevails and it's added.

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

I just came acorss this thread, and iv'e not seen Father Ted in the list?

How can there. be a sitcom thread without Father Ted involved!

Quite simply ran out of spots. I had a brief look at it though. I could add it to another matchup for a 3 way.

I have added a couple to that original list.

 

[AndSmithMustScore]

Agree.

Definitely in my top 5.

Hopefully sense prevails and it's added.

Definately.

Some sitcoms are funny, Father Ted was hilarious.

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

The great part about this thread is seeing mutliple shots of Reese on every page

Indeed.

 

[The Old Dark Navy's]

I Dream of Jeannie 5 vs The Larry Sanders Show 5
The Good Life 1 vs To The Manor Born 2
Gilligan's Island 7 defeated The Wonder Years 2
Til Death Us Do Part 0 vs The Honeymooners 1
The Office (UK) 7 defeated The Golden Girls 1
Malcolm In The Middle 5 vs McHale's Navy 2
Gomer Pyle USMC 3 vs The Nanny 4
The Goodies 7 defeated Mind Your Language 0
Red Dwarf 3 vs Scrubs 5
Saved By The Bell 0 vs 3rd Rock From The Sun 2 vs Frontline 6
Hogan's Heroes 3 vs The Addams Family 3

 

[AndSmithMustScore]

Yes Minister 1 vs Frasier 6
The Good Life 1 vs To The Manor Born 1
The Odd Couple 4 vs Murphy Brown 0
Gilligan's Island 4 vs The Wonder Years 1
Welcome Back Kotter 5 vs Alice 0
The Office (UK) 1 vs The Golden Girls 0 - easiest choice so far.
Malcolm In The Middle 1 vs McHale's Navy 0
Gomer Pyle USMC 0 vs The Nanny 1
The Goodies 1 vs Mind Your Language 0
Red Dwarf 0 vs Scrubs 0 - Toughest match up so far.
Saved By The Bell 0 vs 3rd Rock From The Sun 0 vs Frontline 0
Hogan's Heroes 0 vs The Addams Family 0

Ok my votes would be for:

Yes Minister
The Good Life
The Odd Couple
Gilligans Island
Welcome Back Kotter
The Office
Malcolm in the Middle
Gomer Pyle
Mind Your Language
Red Dwarf (only because when Cat says "you mean i'm really dwayne dibbley" is one my my fave lines in a sitcom ever)
Frontline
Hogans Heroes