List Mgmt. Hawk's List Management 2023

[FB19]

I actually forgot about Bramble. Can replace O'Hara with him in that case.

After his game against St Kilda that’s an easy thing to do.

 

[Walshawk]

Delisting ohara before a fair shake is a terrible look for the Irish experiment

How long is a fair shake? Do you think he will make it?

 

[Walshawk]

Do we have that many new players coming in? With our first pick, then using later picks to match any bid for McCabe? Probably would be a smaller list turnover this year?

We need to delist at least four (we are one over at the month and need three spots for the draft) plus we will want at least one spare spot For the MSD. Reckon we delist Lynch, Morris, Bramble, Jeka and Greene and/or Wingard (Trade).

 

[eldorado]

How long is a fair shake? Do you think he will make it?

he's Cat B, so he's not really taking a list spot.

If there are real prospects in our academy, he may be in trouble, but if it costs us little to keep him for another year, why not?

 

[theiaofseed]

How long is a fair shake? Do you think he will make it?

How long into his stay did people want Nash gone?

On SM-G955F using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[PenAndPaper]

Any team that needs depth in their key forward stocks would have some interest in Kosi, even as a delisted free agent.

Regardless, I'm still anticipating that unless we acquire Riccardi, draft a Caddy type and unexpectedly retain Jeka, then Kosi will be a Hawk next year. Potentially as a re-rookie situation.

Currently I envision the outs to be Jeka, Morris, Lynch, O'Hara, Brockman and potentially Greene.

We are a team that needs depth in key forward stocks haha

 

[Blackhawk42]

We are a team that needs depth in key forward stocks haha

Agreed. That's why I'm expecting us to heavily target that area this off season, or retain Kosi.

 

[dermott]

Delisting ohara before a fair shake is a terrible look for the Irish experiment

Agree. He is a Cat B rookie so his spot is only available to another Cat B.
Patience is needed with Irish imports as they are learning a new game and whilst there are no guarantees of success must be treated as a medium term investment not unlike ruckmen and KPPs.
Imagine if we delisted Conor Nash after two years as I recall some “experts” on BF recommend.

 

[hfc70]

Why should we keep O’Hara ?
Just because he’s from Ireland ? So what ?
Was close to going home last year anyway.

 

[Dewnior]

Agree. He is a Cat B rookie so his spot is only available to another Cat B.
Patience is needed with Irish imports as they are learning a new game and whilst there are no guarantees of success must be treated as a medium term investment not unlike ruckmen and KPPs.
Imagine if we delisted Conor Nash after two years as I recall some “experts” on BF recommend.

Other than CJs brother, do we have any other NGA talent draftable this year? If my Math is correct we have one Cat B spot available with Fionn and Bennetts holding the other two spots. My understanding is that if an NGA slips through to the rookie draft we can preselect as Cat B

 

[streetspirit]

Only get two Cat B spots now dewnior so Bennett’s and Ohara are the full allocation.



Worpel and Weddle comments in the Hun last night like we’re sitting on our hands smells like manager induced BS to me

 

[lethalselbow]

Greene gone?

Ripping guy but can't see a place for him.

We'll give him a year for sure.

Yep. One year at a time for Chad.

Has played brilliantly after a stint at Box Hill and no contract, in his back pocket, to laze about on.

Is his body still an issue. Some people had him retiring a month or so back, due to injury.

 

[Walshawk]

he's Cat B, so he's not really taking a list spot.

If there are real prospects in our academy, he may be in trouble, but if it costs us little to keep him for another year, why not?

How long into his stay did people want Nash gone?

On SM-G955F using BigFooty.com mobile app

So, how long is a ‘fair shake’? Another year? Two more? Three?

 

[peetoo]

Looks like glass and Nash got a handful of games each in second year

Glass on a wing and Nash FP
Ohara has had more time off injured and less slots available in the seniors

So who knows?

 

[Billyc]

Kosi is still the most interesting piece of our list management puzzle.

He showed vast improvement in the ruck yesterday. Also clunked everything that came his way.

He's now also played in our 3 best wins of the season (St.Kilda, Brisbane and Collingwood) and contributed in each one.

Is he, quite unexpectedly, the ruck/fwd we've been hoping for after all?

The key issue for Kosi is how Sam sees our best side structuring up. Is it with two specialist rucks or one specialist ruck and part timers who plays other roles?

If the latter Kosi should survive

I haven’t seen anything to believe Reeves/Meek in the same side is our best structure moving forward. On what I’ve seen, I think it is Reeves and a part timer

 

[Roger Rogerson]

Why should we keep O’Hara ?
Just because he’s from Ireland ? So what ?
Was close to going home last year anyway.

I think that is key - how is he feeling about another season if we offered him one?

 

[lyger]

I think that is key - how is he feeling about another season if we offered him one?

having Nash around and seeing his progression will hopefully drive him to success.

 

[OhhhhhCyril]

Any news on worps, very surprised he hasn’t put pen to paper yet..

 

[hawkmang]

Any news on worps, very surprised he hasn’t put pen to paper yet..

Game 100 this week, could be a double banger announcement

 

[kingcobey78]

We need to delist at least four (we are one over at the month and need three spots for the draft) plus we will want at least one spare spot For the MSD. Reckon we delist Lynch, Morris, Bramble, Jeka and Greene and/or Wingard (Trade).

Jeka could be a good trade to Eagles. Wingard's stocks have gone up over the last month so could get a decent young player for him.

DGB might be on the trade table also given he can't seem to make a go at it at AFL level.

I know Breust is playing as good as ever but he is now 32 turning 33, do we do what we have done with Hodge, Lewis, Mitchell etc. in the past and move him on even though he's signed to end of 2024? He still has some trade power.

 

[kingcobey78]

On what I’ve seen, I think it is Reeves and a part timer

Ramsden has been a decent forward option for Box Hill. Could be worth a look for the second ruckman/tall forward option.

 

[TheFourPillars]

Jeka could be a good trade to Eagles. Wingard's stocks have gone up over the last month so could get a decent young player for him.

DGB might be on the trade table also given he can't seem to make a go at it at AFL level.

I know Breust is playing as good as ever but he is now 32 turning 33, do we do what we have done with Hodge, Lewis, Mitchell etc. in the past and move him on even though he's signed to end of 2024? He still has some trade power.

eldorado we haven't seen this in a while perhaps your threats are wearing off. Time to reinstill the fear

 

[kingcobey78]

eldorado we haven't seen this in a while perhaps your threats are wearing off. Time to reinstill the fear

What did I say?

 

[badgrill]

Jeka could be a good trade to Eagles. Wingard's stocks have gone up over the last month so could get a decent young player for him.

DGB might be on the trade table also given he can't seem to make a go at it at AFL level.

I know Breust is playing as good as ever but he is now 32 turning 33, do we do what we have done with Hodge, Lewis, Mitchell etc. in the past and move him on even though he's signed to end of 2024? He still has some trade power.

 

[Birdland]

Agree. He is a Cat B rookie so his spot is only available to another Cat B.
Patience is needed with Irish imports as they are learning a new game and whilst there are no guarantees of success must be treated as a medium term investment not unlike ruckmen and KPPs.
Imagine if we delisted Conor Nash after two years as I recall some “experts” on BF recommend.

This is Fionn's 3rd & final year as a Cat B so it's either de-listed or a contract offer.