List Mgmt. Hawthorn 2018 Trade discussion NO OPPOSITION SUPPORTERS Part 3

[burnside5]

Sorry I clicked the wrong button before actually writing anything before.

Interesting info thanks. I think also what Hawthorn, as a club in general, would look at the actual personality / character of the player in question aside of course from the actual injury itself.

Don't know the bloke but appears the sort of guy that would be running 400's or in the gym after a win when his mates are at the pub (like me).

So in essence, I think a major factor in the decision to pick him up with a very serious injury and will back the bloke in doing the hard yards to make it back to the top level because if he can will be an enormous asset with his run and carry. Impey, Smith etc will also greatly benefit from this obviously taking pressure of them.

On a side note; I wonder where this leads Henderson as I think has been really impressive for us so would hope he keeps a spot in the team as deserves it I reckon.

 

[Ned Ryerson]

On a side note; I wonder where this leads Henderson as I think has been really impressive for us so would hope he keeps a spot in the team as deserves it I reckon.

You’d imagine Hendo would get another year to provide cover for Scully - particularly as he mightn’t start the season.

 

[WWSD]

You’d imagine Hendo would get another year to provide cover for Scully - particularly as he mightn’t start the season.

Smith and Scully starting with Henderson as the third option coming off the bench = winning!

 

[H2F]

I couldn’t give a f**k what Wallet, Dal Santo and other gimps keep saying.

We have won 4 flags under Clarko.

He resigned and that means he believes he can win at least one more. We have the best coach of all time. Believe in him. Media eat a dick, you end up doing so anyone, so why not now!!!

 

[lickmerocks]

What info? Never once did I say that I had inside info on here .

Do I need to buy tickets or just take some mind altering substances to visit the reality you live in?

Try the mind altering substances. It might help you relax a bit.

 

[lickmerocks]

I couldn’t give a f**k what Wallet, Dal Santo and other gimps keep saying.

We have won 4 flags under Clarko.

He resigned and that means he believes he can win at least one more. We have the best coach of all time. Believe in him. Media eat a dick, you end up doing so anyone, so why not now!!!

Absolutely.

There is a lot of wasted energy on here about media predictions on our future.

These guys are paid to have an opinion so who cares what they predict.

From the outside looking in we have a playing list that looks like could be in trouble in age profile and player depth accross key positions and our trading comes with big questions as well such as.....

Scrimshaw- how can a number 7 pick not get games at Goldy?
Scully- Can we get him on the park again and get decent games out of him?
Wingard-Can we get him playing the footy he was playing 3 years back?

Can’t wait to see how the above unfolds and if we are pushing for top 4 again next season.

 

[lickmerocks]

Ned never had any info to be upset about, just his actuary tables, but he doesn't live or die by them

Ned needs a muzzle or he needs to be taken to the pound.

 

[dermott]

You’d imagine Hendo would get another year to provide cover for Scully - particularly as he mightn’t start the season.

I would be surprised if Hendo was not offered another one year contract. He, Smith and Scully offer the run that will be vital with the revised rules. They can also play forward and back as well as wing.

 

[hfc70]

We were having a look at Kieran Collins.....who is now a DFA too.

If the club select guys on their character then this guy is no chance

 

[flinchfree]

Ned needs a muzzle or he needs to be taken to the pound.

Do you never stop chirping?
It's so ****ing tiring to read.

 

[flinchfree]

If the club select guys on their character then this guy is no chance

Can you give us a bit more info for supporters not in the know?

 

[Mitchell54]

We were having a look at Kieran Collins.....who is now a DFA too.

Collins is not a DFA. He got signed by Gold Coast as part of their priority access to state league players.

 

[HawkNation]

Collins is not a DFA. He got signed by Gold Coast as part of their priority access to state league players.

That is Sam Collins

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

If the club select guys on their character then this guy is no chance

Good to know.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

Collins is not a DFA. He got signed by Gold Coast as part of their priority access to state league players.

Wrong.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

All good. Nothing to sort out. Ned is a little upset his info was incorrect and looking for an excuse. Classic 101 on how to deflect when you are wrong.

A simple sorry would have been a better option.

Mate, every time I see you bickering about what others have said or posted I think back to this post of yours quoted below.

You have got me very very wrong. Couldn’t give a flying feck about being right or wrong on Bigfooty.

You clearly care about being right or wrong on Bigfooty, and you really can't let go of the fact that just like you kept telling others that their comments should be taken with a grain of salt until a player was 100% signed, that yours regarding Lynch being a done deal to Richmond were taken in the exact same way.

It's time to suck it up and move on.

 

[Bugs1977]

If Gunston, Wingard and Breust kicked 20-30 I'd be concerned considering that is a 20-30 goal drop from what they're capable of.

Did you see how I put the word ‘around’ in front of 20-30 goals? I don’t expect Breust / Gunners to kick as many as they did this season but I’d hope Roughie/ Poppy not to be as bad as they were this season either.

 

[OnTheRocks]

To err is human and it should be time to bury the hatchet

 

[Maybloomer]

It's the yawning effect coming into play......


anyone think we should pick up Menzel?

I’m thinking Jed Lamb. Dont play him, just use him at training to release Sicily’s frustrations in preparation for the weekends.

 

[Strapping Young Lad]

Ok. So who’s got the pic of Cogs in a Hawks jumper?

 

[Bugs1977]

You’d imagine Hendo would get another year to provide cover for Scully - particularly as he mightn’t start the season.

This is how I see it too. When (don’t like to use if) Scully is back I feel Hendo will slot in wherever Clarko needs him. He’ll probably start on the bench and rotate with one of Smith or Smith when needed. Once Scully is back to 100% and is playing his 95% game time then Hendo will probably have to slot into more of a HF or HB role depending on injuries at the time. It’s all about flexibility.

 

[dermott]

If the club select guys on their character then this guy is no chance

Is that why the Dogs gave him the flick?

 

[Bugs1977]

Ok. So who’s got the pic of Cogs in a Hawks jumper?

I’ve finally caught up in this thread and we’re at this point already with Cogs. I’ll sort it out at work on Monday morning but it might be a little different to what you envisage.

 

[Mitchell54]

Wrong.

Gee. That’s rather blunt.

 

[Gralin]

Gee. That’s rather blunt.

That's because Sam Collins signed with gold coast