That didnt happen the vote agaimst Geelong is increasing daily, nice try.
You seem to be getting your knickers in a knot, you do realise that on the bay few people read past the first few lines, do try and cut your diatribe to readable lengths.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Moved Thread how do you rate and compare the past two premiers?
- Thread starter geelong_crazy26
- Start date
- Tagged users None
You seem to be getting your knickers in a knot, you do realise that on the bay few people read past the first few lines, do try and cut your diatribe to readable lengths.
- Thread starter
- #1,527
I never reffered to the polls, please read my comment above.
I have provided evidence of the entire bigfooty forums on club boards which is a big enough sample to represent the footy population of those clubs, they all run down Richmond’s premiership playing group saying if you can win it they can too.
Gill mchlachlan has come out since the bulldogs and Richmond flags and said equalisation has been achieved and how happy he is, he even says that after seeing Geelong and hawthorn dominate, we are now seeing an even system in place. Hmmmm what could he possibly be meaning by this?? Is he saying that we have possibly weaker sides at the top as everyone is more even?? I believe so, he sure didn’t mention equalisation when hawthorn and Geelong won flags, he stayed quiet.
The footy players; these are the true experts of the game, massively involved with tactics and enriched to the eyeballs with data and opposition analysis, they all rate Richmond to be the big sliders of 2018 and don’t rate your team.
It’s all there the evidence that these past two teams are the worst premiership teams in history and nobody rates them as anything but mediocre sides
Comparisons with teams from previous years will not work for various reasons, including rule changes, the advent of GWS and GC, and indiscriminate umpiring to name a few. Geelong had a dynasty. Richmond are the latest premiers and were otherwise a non-event in the last decade until last year. If last year marks the start of a consistent run in September for them, then we'll see where they go, but the dogs, as are many other premiers, are proof of one-hit wonders.
- Thread starter
- #1,529
If you struggle to read 3-4 paragraphs then that’s your problem not mine to dumb down.
Your free to leave anytime you want, it’s obviously bothering you or you wouldn’t be here. All I have done is give honest facts and posted opinions that are widely spoken across bigfooty about the last two premiers, nobody thinks anything of them talent wise
No you have provided nothing but opinion.
The fact that you think the players are experts is the biggest hole in your argument, first thing is they watch less football than most and when on the ground they dont see the big picture. The other issue is you are using predictions of how players believe we will go this year to state that our last years game was weak, there is no correlation between the two.
Sorry but you havent convinced me of anything, the only real fact we have is a poll that clearly shows Geelong 07 as the weakest.
Its not bothering me at all that Geelong are the weakest ever but it does bother me that you havent learnt how to compact your posts into a concise and factual argument, all you keep bringing is opinions no proof.
Im just trying to help you out as I know its important to you to have a long running thread, as a Cats supporter you suffer the minnow effect, you Geelols are so salty about our victory because you know it condemned your drug fueled flags to anominity, it is a little sad to see you Cats so upset Im just trying to.lift your spirits a little.
Richmond are after all the peoples club, were here for all footy supporters.
- Oct 7, 2012
- 15,839
- 24,198
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
Why do you care so much bro?
You are on a hiding to nothing. Comparing teams across years let alone decades is impossible and pointless.
So Geelong dubiously won* three flags with the help of cheap father sons, convicted drug cheating coaching staff and a drug addict coaching them. Its nothing to get carried away about.
- Oct 7, 2012
- 15,839
- 24,198
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
Lol
Your drug program and cheap father sons were that good that you could even win finals away from KP...;-) back then.
We did warn people that all the ninthmond, microwave etc jokes would come back to bite you on the bum.
Remember if your going to poke the sleeping giant you better be wearing flame proof underwear.
Its understandable after two brilliant and clean flags in 16 and 17 that the Cats would fear there own tainted flags would be diminished but goodness you've been more salty than the Crows supporter that made that laughable video about free kicks, a little sad really.
Every flog has his day. Of *course* one day Richmond would pull a rabbit out of a hat. Richmond will go #Back2Hack in due course.
It's funny how quiet a majority of Tigers supporters were when the going was tough though, isn't it?
I think all these reports of Myer being on the brink of closing down are unfounded. Microwave sales will go through the roof come July.
Your opinion is not a determination. Opinions are like assholes, everyone has one.
On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app
- Jan 6, 2018
- 10,660
- 12,194
- AFL Club
- Adelaide
- Other Teams
- Norwood
lol .. Freudian slip or predictive spelling?
Yeah even a flog riddled minnow like Geelong had its day and for a couple of years shook off the handbag tag, then you go and lose 7 out of 10 finals and handbag sales have boomed in Corio Bay area again, welcome back handbaggers, things feel right again.
You just stay safe and now that our games will be at our ground for a change dont you be getting a fright from all those nasty hordes in the Tiger Army
Well done genius, as we have more members than any other team, unless we have a fair few using the colostomy bags it would figure that we have more arseholes than any other team, rectums may be a better term though?And the Richmond member base has more arseholes than any other team
I agree with you that no group of supporters who's club wasn't good enough to pay in a grand final have been so utterly triggered by the eventual premiership club.
Thank you Geelong 'supporters', you have helped make this summer even more wonderful for us. I feel that you have payed back all the heart break you have delivered us in recent years with interest, and in just a few months.
What makes you even more wonderful is that their is no sign that your tears and the incessant posting of your fear and loathing is any where nearing an end.
Long may you continue, whilst the rest of us point and laugh at you and revel in your suffering
Can I just remind Geelong supporters that Richmond's finals series was the most dominant this century. Obviously much more impressive than anything that drug addled Geelong ever delivered.
Thanks again guys.
The stupidity and arrogance of Richmond fans after one gifted Premiership is astounding, thankfully the AFL will move on to their GWS baby and we won't have to worry about how bad BF would get if the Tiggies pinched another flag.
- Thread starter
- #1,548
Adelaide were no where near unbeatable, they even lost a few games at Adelaide oval lol by decent margins lol. Just an ok decent side.
GWS are still in incubation and several years off their best. Wait till their main core is 25-28 years of age with another bracket underneath between 22-25. We will see their best then. They are not there yet.
That Richmond side beat average sides in the finals.
- Oct 7, 2012
- 15,839
- 24,198
- AFL Club
- Western Bulldogs
Only exceeded by the bitterness of Cat fans unwilling to acknowledge that their own club only makes up the numbers come finals time.
Keep the bitter tears flowing. Enjoyable.
Similar threads
