News Insightful and Inciteful - 2022 Media Thread

Remove this Banner Ad

Status
Not open for further replies.
I have no love for Cornes, but he is correct

One thing i have long been kind of critical of, is that we very rarely, if ever, court players publicly to come to the club

Its been suggested that we do a lot of work behind closed doors, and that may be true. But if it is true it isn't exactly working because i would hardly say that we have ever really been what i would call a destination club

And i think a lot of that comes back to the fact that we are so financially stable; we have such good membership and attendance that we don't really need to recruit superstars to generate interest. So that unless someone nominates to come to us, we really don't bother. We never seem to "chase" star players coming out of contract (with the recent exception of Kelly). And at the end of the day, everyone loves a fan. If you are a player looking for a trade do you want to go the club of someone who really really wants you to come there, or a club who is like, meh, if they come, they come?

I would love to see us become much more proactive in the chasing of players. So in the years to come we see something like "Johnny superstar coming out of contract, West Coast chasing hard for his signature", or "2 out of contract young superstars nominate West Coast"

And if we don't the capacity to bring these players to the club, that's also fine. At least it gives us the right of first refusal

This approach works for Sydney, it works for Geelong, it works for Collingwood and it works for Richmond

We need to make it work for us
How’s it worked out for Fremantle?

I’d rather we target who we want instead of a scattergun approach that sees us used by player managers to negotiate a better deal fir their client

Jackson wasn’t a priority for us
 
How’s it worked out for Fremantle?

I’d rather we target who we want instead of a scattergun approach that sees us used by player managers to negotiate a better deal fir their client

Jackson wasn’t a priority for us

Again, we want the right of first refusal

If we can't accommodate someone or they are surplus to requirements, great. But we want to be their first choice
 

Log in to remove this ad.

Again, we want the right of first refusal

If we can't accommodate someone or they are surplus to requirements, great. But we want to be their first choice
Well, that's not great at all.

See Port Adelaide this year.

Had 2x players tour the club and announced they were publicly interested, then had to scrap going for them due to JHF requesting a trade.

Pretty embarrassing/shambolic from Port, tbh.

I can't understand why supporters want this stuff played out in the media.

It wasn't so long ago that everyone was mocking North with their 'war chest'.
 
Eagles have always preferred to build a team through the draft, then top up in a few key areas. No problem with that, though I think we are at the beginning of regular player movement, so the Eagles may need to adjust their thinking.
 
Rz01y-.gif
 

(Log in to remove this ad.)

One thing we need to do is to stop recruiting list cloggers just because they're cheap and simply nominated us, such as Witho, Langdon, SPP, Ah Chee, etc.
Mostly agree. But don’t mind if they just get a one year opportunity or rookie to show their wares. For example JJ looks best 25. But agree the names listed aren’t. Some players do thrive in a new environment.
 
Jones was an SSP tho. Ah Chee was on 1 year contracts since we traded him in. All should get 1 year contracts ideally unless they're a proven B22 player but sometimes they won't move over for a 1 year contract esp if not originally from WA.
 
Jones was an SSP tho. Ah Chee was on 1 year contracts since we traded him in. All should get 1 year contracts ideally unless they're a proven B22 player but sometimes they won't move over for a 1 year contract esp if not originally from WA.
What's any of that got to do with the ever insightful media?
 
One thing we need to do is to stop recruiting list cloggers just because they're cheap and simply nominated us, such as Witho, Langdon, SPP, Ah Chee, etc.

There's also the comparison with who would be available at the draft at the pick used in the trade.

SPS vs the nobodies (and literal nobodies, ie the club passed) drafted at the pick used on him for example.
 


An interesting read on someone playing favourites.


If anything, it shows a good piece of talent assessment.

Naish KILLED us in that Richmond game but he had been a means to an end for weeks anyway due to the injury/COVID situation. The fact that he was getting it 20 times a game was killing us because the lad’s disposal was short of the standard - and that stood out in our team of the first half of ‘22, which is a hell of an achievement really.
 
AFL App has had a crack at our Best 22 for next year (old mate Schmookie)

48415361-0A69-4930-B667-0CB2865C9438.jpeg

It’s actually not too far from the pin I reckon.

He gets points for including Tommy Cole, usually completely forgotten.

Jamaine Jones is probably the biggest omission - but you’d be looking at a 2 man combo of Petruccelle/Waterman/Williams/Jones I think.
 
AFL App has had a crack at our Best 22 for next year (old mate Schmookie)

View attachment 1541014

It’s actually not too far from the pin I reckon.

He gets points for including Tommy Cole, usually completely forgotten.

Jamaine Jones is probably the biggest omission - but you’d be looking at a 2 man combo of Petruccelle/Waterman/Williams/Jones I think.
Can't see us going in with only Nic.

Williams will be in the 22 I'd say
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

Back
Top