List Mgmt. Ivan Soldo requests trade

[Dazalinko1988]

Nah go f*#k a goat soldo ya sour gremlin ya can't handle being second to sweet so ya have a cry and run home catchya c*nt !

 

[cmpower]

Port - Richards
St Kilda - Soldo
Collingwood - Pick 27

Or are the Saints giving up too much?

 

[Schulzenfest]

Port - Richards
St Kilda - Soldo
Collingwood - Pick 27

Or are the Saints giving up too much?

How the **** is the out of contract 25 year old with single figure career games and goals worth pick 27?

 

[cmpower]

How the **** is the out of contract 25 year old with single figure career games and goals worth pick 27?

I think Richard’s is better than ANB who went for Pick 28

 

[davo999]

Port - Richards
St Kilda - Soldo
Collingwood - Pick 27

Or are the Saints giving up too much?

Collingwood getting too much for Richard’s . We should probably ask similar to what we paid for Soldo

 

[VineValerian]

How the **** is the out of contract 25 year old with single figure career games and goals worth pick 27?

I think it was a typo.
He meant 47.

 

[VineValerian]

Port - Richards
St Kilda - Soldo
Collingwood - Pick 27

Or are the Saints giving up too much?

Port certainly is.

 

[all seeing eye]

Port soldo +57
Sts 27

 

[philthy05]

I think Richard’s is better than ANB who went for Pick 28

Based on what?

Anb, while I think an average player has a body of work far bigger and arguably better exposed form , and he’s contracted.

Joe may surpass anb in time, but that isn’t now, and it’s not a given.

 

[Schulzenfest]

I think Richard’s is better than ANB who went for Pick 28

Okay let's recap:

ANB - 176 games, 116 goals, best 22, premiership player, just finished 3rd in Melbourne's B&F, contracted
Richards - 9 games, 6 goals, not best 22, finished so low in Collingwood's B&F that he doesn't show up on their published results, uncontracted

You do realise trade value isn't determined by subjective determinations about who is 'better', right?

 

[rogerjames]

I'm not fussed about this at all. We went all in on rucks to ensure ruck wasn't the disaster for us it had been in 2023. Soldo signed before he knew he'd have a competitor in Sweet. He played some pretty solid footy for us before Sweet got his chance and overtook him. We'll trade Soldo back at a slight loss, but it was worth ensuring we had cover.

Agree but it does seem he has been a bit disrespectful to the club which I'm not happy about.

 

[Doctor Feel]

lol the media covering these two overseas sure is something. You would think this was all designed to get her into the spotlight.

 

[Alberton Proud]

Soldo to St kilda for their 24 , they can have our 36 at a squeeze (upgrade at least for us). Tell his management to work harder if he wants out.

24 to GCS for Luko

Fair Trade for us and GCS get the $$$ relief they're looking for

 

[Wargreymon90]

24 to GCS for Luko

Fair Trade for us and GCS get the $$$ relief they're looking for

I can’t imagine they’d be interested in a pick in the 20s this year given that it will be swallowed up by their academy selections.

 

[1954]

Yea I'm keeping him just for spite and lols

Soldo is coming across as a ginormous dummy spitter who has thrown all of his toys out of the cot.

The club has to show it won't be f***** around by a prima donna who is having a sook, or there is a very real risk it could happen again.
The bloke signed a 3 year contract and if we can't get a decent trade he can get stuffed, play in the sanfl and be made to fight for his place in the Power line up.

 

[JimmyBC]

Six foot 8 with a mullet, a filthy moustache and a head like an old sandshoe I really wouldn't have picked him to end up being the biggest bloody sook we've ever had.

 

[Powerade 08]

Six foot 8 with a mullet, a filthy moustache and a head like an old sandshoe I really wouldn't have picked him to end up being the biggest bloody sook we've ever had.

Playing for a 'big' cringetorian club probably changed him

 

[PeacefulWarrior]

Six foot 8 with a mullet, a filthy moustache and a head like an old sandshoe I really wouldn't have picked him to end up being the biggest bloody sook we've ever had.

He honestly doesn’t come across as the sharpest tool in the shed

 

[Duck Farmer]

Six foot 8 with a mullet, a filthy moustache and a head like an old sandshoe I really wouldn't have picked him to end up being the biggest bloody sook we've ever had.

Looks like he's lost the mo and mullet. Were they ever real or were we dreaming?

 

[Jello_B]

Okay let's recap:

ANB - 176 games, 116 goals, best 22, premiership player, just finished 3rd in Melbourne's B&F, contracted
Richards - 9 games, 6 goals, not best 22, finished so low in Collingwood's B&F that he doesn't show up on their published results, uncontracted

You do realise trade value isn't determined by subjective determinations about who is 'better', right?

Richards didn’t even get a “participation” award in the B&F. Hinkles would definitely not know who Richards is.

 

[DaTBird187]

Looks like he's lost the mo and mullet. Were they ever real or were we dreaming?

What we thought we were getting......

What we got.....

 

[WillemDaDrew]

Looks like he enjoys spending time on the GC with his www.TikTok/Influencer/FansOnly.com WAG.
We should be negotiating with the Suns in a trade for Luko.

 

[davesnothere]

Looks like he enjoys spending time on the GC with his www.TikTok/Influencer/FansOnly.com WAG.
We should be negotiating with the Suns in a trade for Luko.

He's not getting a game at the Suns.

Brisbane? Before Darcy Fort became a cult hero would have been a really good home.

We are dealing with the Saints.

 

[davesnothere]

What’s the big deal? I didn’t even want to go to the BnF. Was a load of rubbish anyways.

You've got to support your mates who had to sit though it. I didn't watch it either but if I were on the list I'm going and enduring it.

 

[Schulzenfest]

We should be negotiating with the Suns in a trade for Luko.

And why should we be doing that?

The Suns could offer us Matt Rowell and Noah Anderson for him if they wanted. Does us no good if Soldo refuses a trade there. Which he would.