Traded James Aish [traded to Collingwood for #26 and St Kilda's 2016 second round pick]
- Thread starter Madagascar
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Joel Tippet (Sister players netball for QLD Firebirds, from gold coast) & Aaron Black or pick 28 (Brisbane need a key forward) for James Aish.
Jaimes Aish will go on to replace Dal Santo / Wells as the silk in the midfield in 2 years and play alongside our midfield brigade Cunnington, Bastinac, Cunnington, Harvey, etc, etc.
Win / Win / Win
Then north will trade their first round pick and Brad McKenzie for Charlie Dixon
Jaimes Aish will go on to replace Dal Santo / Wells as the silk in the midfield in 2 years and play alongside our midfield brigade Cunnington, Bastinac, Cunnington, Harvey, etc, etc.
Win / Win / Win
Then north will trade their first round pick and Brad McKenzie for Charlie Dixon
Joel was already a lion a few years ago. Was rookie listed between 07' - 09' until he was delisted. Highly doubt we would be interested in him.Joel Tippet (Sister players netball for QLD Firebirds, from gold coast) & Aaron Black or pick 28 (Brisbane need a key forward) for James Aish.
Jaimes Aish will go on to replace Dal Santo / Wells as the silk in the midfield in 2 years and play alongside our midfield brigade Cunnington, Bastinac, Cunnington, Harvey, etc, etc.
Win / Win / Win
Then north will trade their first round pick and Brad McKenzie for Charlie Dixon
Aaron Black is a decent forward but he isnt the power forward you could build a team around. Standing at 192cm he
isn't a no. 1 forward. We have guys coming through that will have the 2nd and 3rd tall forward spots taken. I can't see him being a need either.
If Clubs decide to bid on our academy players, I'm quite happy letting Hipwood or Keayes go and then reaming the club that tried to **** us over in 2 years when they want to play for us. It will send a precedent in future for clubs not to steal other players Academy kids. Getting Dixon is more important. I'm happy getting Hipwood or Keayes in 2 years time for a 4th round pick if it means getting Dixon this year.
Who knows that once they become entrenched in the club that drafts them they would want to come back? They may want to play for the club now but we can't say for sure they would come back in 2 years. Both were born in Melbourne and have family there. If we rate them, we match the bid and be thankful we have 2 very talented Queensland kids on the list.
You mean like stealing Dixon in the PSD as has been suggested by some Lions supporters in this thread?
It would only be because of such an act that we would come after your academy players anyway.
what's the saying, if you play with fire?
- Aug 16, 2010
- 10,745
- 7,638
- AFL Club
- Brisbane Lions
Apparently we're no longer chasing Dixon according to Jon Ralph Fremantle are favorites to get him so take easy on us after we gave you Jarrad Brennan
Apparently we're no longer chasing Dixon according to Jon Ralph Fremantle are favorites to get him so take easy on us after we gave you Jarrad Brennan
Ouch,
Brennan or a huge steaming pile of shit, hmmmm tough decision, can we have pick 5 back please
Re Dixon, he is supposed to be close to a new contract with us, which could be complete crap. I think the journo's just make it up as they go
It gets worse. They also gave Gold Coast pick 10 which turned out to be Gorringe...
yeah carlton are still after him, considered front runners for him at this moment in time
- Dec 5, 2012
- 13,657
- 37,077
- AFL Club
- Richmond
- Other Teams
- Knicks, Giants
Treloar to the pies is getting stronger so i would suggest that we are going hard at Aish
Lions fans - if Aish decided he wanted to go to the Saints how would you feel about pick 6 for Aish and your 2nd (pick 20?)
Bucking Beads
Brownlow Medallist
We would jump at that but we need the 2nd rounder for the academy kids.
Okay, just swap pick 20 for Hanley then...
askdotcom
All Australian
- Oct 25, 2014
- 879
- 722
- AFL Club
- GWS
deal if you change pick 6 to bruce, billings and pick 6.
Last edited:
TheLastEmperor
Cancelled
- Sep 10, 2009
- 8,400
- 7,721
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
Brissy need picks for the academy kids this year.
I'd do 6 and 60 for Aish and Brissy's 2016 2nd and 3rd rounders.
I doubt Hipwood or Keays get bids before 6 so they could bank that pick for somebody else.
Brissy could be looking at something like:
1 - Weitering/Schache
6 - Mathieson/Tucker
Hipwood
Keays
I reckon they just about win the draft with that haul.
I did consider they will need picks for academy prospect Allison next year but I wouldn't be surprised if he's bid on top 3 anyway so Brissy will likely have to use their first.
I'd do 6 and 60 for Aish and Brissy's 2016 2nd and 3rd rounders.
I doubt Hipwood or Keays get bids before 6 so they could bank that pick for somebody else.
Brissy could be looking at something like:
1 - Weitering/Schache
6 - Mathieson/Tucker
Hipwood
Keays
I reckon they just about win the draft with that haul.
I did consider they will need picks for academy prospect Allison next year but I wouldn't be surprised if he's bid on top 3 anyway so Brissy will likely have to use their first.
Apparently you can't trade a 1st round and then 2nd and 3rd round the following year. You can do 1st and 1st or 2nd and 3rd like for like. There was a big chain going on about it last night.
Madagascar
All Australian
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #494
HBFlanker you owe me an apology for your rude and ignorant presumption, OP was spot on, and nailed many of the things we were discussing. Here's a break down... I wait for your apology.
and then this...
and my response...
and then...
From the last post you were wrong on three counts. Pies will get Treloar. So you were wrong there. Aish seems to favours a move to Victoria and will be at Carlton next year, would have been Collingwood IMO, but I rightfully claimed that Collingwood's priority will be Treloar who we WILL get.
And I did my research, and posted a very good James Aish trade thread. You were rude, obnoxious and wrong... now I await my spology...
and then this...
and my response...
and then...
From the last post you were wrong on three counts. Pies will get Treloar. So you were wrong there. Aish seems to favours a move to Victoria and will be at Carlton next year, would have been Collingwood IMO, but I rightfully claimed that Collingwood's priority will be Treloar who we WILL get.
And I did my research, and posted a very good James Aish trade thread. You were rude, obnoxious and wrong... now I await my spology...
Madagascar
All Australian
- Thread starter
- Banned
- #495
Carlton will get Aish for their second rounder perhaps plus a fringe player, the best Brisbane can hope for is for these Menzel rumours to be true then a three way deal could be on the cards.
The thing that hurts Brisbane is that there is so much player movement, movement to Victoria, and each Vic club has their finger in different pies, Pies have their finger in one pies Adam Treloar.
So to break it down. Pies after Treloar. Tiges into Motlop. Cats into Dangerfield. Dees/Saints into Prestia. Hawks have no cap room, and have a late pick, and NM and Dogs have later picks also. This means that because of this, if these Vic clubs have gentlemen agreements, they can get unders for certain players.
Carlton should get unders for Aish.
Collingwood to get unders for Treloar.
Dees will use pick 5 or so on Prestia.
Tiges first rounder for Motlop.
Cats into Dangerfield.
That leaves, WB, NM, Saints, Ess, Hawks and
No way Essendon would be in the race. WB and NM would not be his preferred destination and they'd have a pick between 10-15. Hawks unlikely, no cap space, and they'd only have pick 18 anyway. That leaves the Saints as the Lions best bet to create some bidding system. Saint pick 6 for Aish would be a dream, but even then, I'm not sure the Saints would be interested in parting with pick 6 for Aish, he's just not worth it.
The more I read into it, the more Carlton's second rounder might get the job done, or they can hope to salvage a three way trade through either Yarran and Menzel, although word is Yarran is only worth a second rounder on the market.
The thing that hurts Brisbane is that there is so much player movement, movement to Victoria, and each Vic club has their finger in different pies, Pies have their finger in one pies Adam Treloar.
So to break it down. Pies after Treloar. Tiges into Motlop. Cats into Dangerfield. Dees/Saints into Prestia. Hawks have no cap room, and have a late pick, and NM and Dogs have later picks also. This means that because of this, if these Vic clubs have gentlemen agreements, they can get unders for certain players.
Carlton should get unders for Aish.
Collingwood to get unders for Treloar.
Dees will use pick 5 or so on Prestia.
Tiges first rounder for Motlop.
Cats into Dangerfield.
That leaves, WB, NM, Saints, Ess, Hawks and
No way Essendon would be in the race. WB and NM would not be his preferred destination and they'd have a pick between 10-15. Hawks unlikely, no cap space, and they'd only have pick 18 anyway. That leaves the Saints as the Lions best bet to create some bidding system. Saint pick 6 for Aish would be a dream, but even then, I'm not sure the Saints would be interested in parting with pick 6 for Aish, he's just not worth it.
The more I read into it, the more Carlton's second rounder might get the job done, or they can hope to salvage a three way trade through either Yarran and Menzel, although word is Yarran is only worth a second rounder on the market.
Last edited:
Nice edit.
pulpdriver
Brownlow Medallist
Hughey to Aish on his Footy Show segment: "Where's James Aish? You don't say much do you either? Why not? Too busy thinking about where you're going to be next year?"
lachie charm
Cancelled
- Feb 8, 2015
- 1,283
- 2,198
- AFL Club
- Carlton
there's no menzel rumours. It's just pure uninformed hypotheticals.
lachie charm
Cancelled
- Feb 8, 2015
- 1,283
- 2,198
- AFL Club
- Carlton
There are none.
