Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
AFLW 2024 - Round 2 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
A few clubs sniffing around with North potentially one of them.
OOC 2025.
One of the best in the VFL the past 2 seasons.
Why no opportunity?
Hard to break into a top side as a kid who might not be quite entirely readyA few clubs sniffing around with North potentially one of them.
OOC 2025.
One of the best in the VFL the past 2 seasons.
Why no opportunity?
I imagine aswell with Carltons midfield being filled with bulls or Walsh makes it hard to break in aswell. Havent seen alot of Binns though personallyIMO he’s not physically ready for AFL and also the way he wins his ball in the VFL isn’t as translatable with the quicker and tougher AFL.
Don’t get me wrong he’s developing nicely but it’s fine to take a couple of years to develop at VFL level to improve your game. It shouldn’t be seen as a negative or a failure. He can take the shortcut and potentially get more opportunity elsewhere (in which he and the team he’s traded too will probably soon realise he’s not yet ready for AFL and he’ll end up back in the VFL anyways) or he can round out his game in the VFL and reach the point where he becomes a lock in our best 22. It’s up to him which path he chooses.
I imagine aswell with Carltons midfield being filled with bulls or Walsh makes it hard to break in aswell. Havent seen alot of Binns though personally
Interesting. If wing is that E.Hollands (having a great season) and Achers? still very tough spot. Carlton list in a good spot currently.There’s a wing and/or HFF spot for him to take when he’s physically ready. He will never be a predominant centre bounce/stoppage player at AFL level regardless of which team he is at it IMO. He’s a wing or flank player with some midfield rotations. So he’s not really competing with Walsh, Kennedy, Hewett etc. He’s more competing with Ollie Hollands, Cottrell types both who are a little more physically advanced and rounded at this stage.
Interesting. If wing is that E.Hollands (having a great season) and Achers? still very tough spot. Carlton list in a good spot currently.
He should leave. With 2 x Campo's coming in as well he could conceivably be further down the pecking order next season. Clubs love a father-son debut.
No current season stats available
Have u even watched Binns play lmao?Voss would rather play stooges like David Cuningham.
Not sure it should come as much surprise considering it comes from the same brilliant mind that brought you classics like thinking Pittonet was a better ruckman than Tom De Koning.
Or Holland's who's a potatoIf he can’t get a game over Matt Cottrell he must be a serious battler
Or he just weighs like 70kgs ringing wet and needs some more time to physically develop...If he can’t get a game over Matt Cottrell he must be a serious battler
Or he just weighs like 70kgs ringing wet and needs some more time to physically develop...
Have you ever actually watched Binns play a full game?Or he is just a battler. A witches hat offers more than Cottrell.
Have you ever actually watched Binns play a full game?
And your point being? Binns is not physically ready for AFL footy at this stage. Whether Cottrell is a superstar or a bum it doesn't really change that fact.Nah but I’ve watched cottrell plenty and I would play literally anyone over him.
And your point being? Binns is not physically ready for AFL footy at this stage. Whether Cottrell is a superstar or a bum it doesn't really change that fact.
Cottrell has a stronger body and is more capable defensively. Binns may end up the better player in time but he needs to bulk up significantly so he can stick tackles on the bigger bodies of the AFL
And your point being? Binns is not physically ready for AFL footy at this stage. Whether Cottrell is a superstar or a bum it doesn't really change that fact.
Cottrell has a stronger body and is more capable defensively. Binns may end up the better player in time but he needs to bulk up significantly so he can stick tackles on the bigger bodies of the AFL