with Lobb, that will be 3.5, maybe 4.
-
AFLW 2024 - Round 10 - Chat, game threads, injury lists, team lineups and more.
Traded Jesse Hogan [traded with #65 to Fremantle for #6 and #23]
- Thread starter Bunk Moreland
- Start date
- Tagged users None
Unless we're playing St Kilda when we kick 13
We'll see how it pans out.
Either work in the scheme of things for us, as long as we can get May with one of the picks. If GC only want May for 5 then I'm sure we let you know we need that to be part of the deal.
But if GC would be happy with 8, then 8 and 11 is a win for everyone. We aren't likely keeping the earlier pick so it shouldn't matter to us. Though huge bonus if GC are happy with 11, which I doubt.
You guys get a first
We get May and 11
GC get an early first.
Point values should only matter if you need to use points instead of picks.
- May 7, 2015
- 678
- 1,440
- AFL Club
- Fremantle
- Other Teams
- Tottenham Hotspur
Too much common sense for bigfooty during trade time
- Apr 29, 2016
- 13,768
- 12,039
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
Looking forward to keeping Hogan, kick us 60 next year, then picking up May the year after and then working with WCE to work out a deal for hogan while freo watch taberner kick 20 goals and finish bottom 4. 
Because West Coast will have anything remotely better to work with than what Freo have? But you want more than what Freo had?Looking forward to keeping Hogan, kick us 60 next year, then picking up May the year after and then working with WCE to work out a deal for hogan while freo watch taberner kick 20 goals and finish bottom 4.
Looking forward to keeping Hogan, kick us 60 next year, then picking up May the year after and then working with WCE to work out a deal for hogan while freo watch taberner kick 20 goals and finish bottom 4.
As long as you're not bitter about life or anything.
Iva Bigun
Brownlow Medallist
Suns wont do that, a certain top 5 pick as compo next year, if we can get the outside result (5) this year then its worth our while, otherwise we are better off keeping him.
Looking forward to keeping Hogan, kick us 60 next year, then picking up May the year after and then working with WCE to work out a deal for hogan while freo watch taberner kick 20 goals and finish bottom 4.
I would keep Hogan if I were Melbourne. They already have the kid and he is damn good. Shut down the talks and move on to other targets. I see why Fremantle want him, but realistically they don't have the picks. It would've taken picks 5 and 6. They traded 6 away. I assume Melbourne are only still speaking to them out of goodwill now.
- Jun 14, 2017
- 4,011
- 6,583
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
- Other Teams
- Liverpool, AC Milan, North Adelaide
Yes it is, he is not worth two firsts.
I’m not sure you can command 5 and 6 for a suspected druggo with a busted foot. We’re trying to turf out a known druggo with busted calves and he’s barely worth anything any more.
If we don’t get Hogan then we’ll use one of our picks to get Lobb, who balances us out more anyway, and go to the draft with the rest of the picks.
To be fair, Freo can offer 11 and next years first with a future 3rd coming back. It’s definitely not freo’s best offer
Demon bhoy
Club Legend
- Oct 7, 2017
- 1,665
- 1,495
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
Then don’t make the offer if you can’t afford the product, but if you do expect to get laughed at for being a bit of a knob
Juzzk1d
Senior List
- May 1, 2015
- 177
- 345
- AFL Club
- Melbourne
Melbourne would prefer Hogan to stay, as would most Melbourne supporters. The fact of the matter is, we all know Hogan will go back to WA eventually. Hogan wants to do right by us, as we do for Jesse.
The best thing to do is trade for him now so we get the most out of his worth now instead of waiting till he is out of contract end of next year and the ball is less in our court. Or worse, resigns and eventually becomes a restricted free agent and he leaves, we finish high without winning a flag and get something around pick 16+ as compensation.
Iva Bigun
Brownlow Medallist
Might have to be if you want Hogan (and everyone knows you do) , Neale is going and has threatened to go public (according to TR) not every deal can be a lopsided Freo win like the Weller trade. 5 is not unreasonable
I don't expect that it would be Weller one sided. Simply that Neale as a contracted player requires 2 firsts. How that is structured I don't know but I think that's what Brisbane will need to pay this year. As you've said its no secret that Freo want Hogan, no way we can get him this year without more picks. Fremantle want to have a pick this year in the first round. It all hinges on the Neale trade and so far Brisbane (despite Noble's assurance he'll get him) haven't come to the table with a suitable offer.
5 and 24 is not unreasonable, 5 by itself is.
Hang on, you guys want to get rid of Hogan and get May.
Hogan wants to go to WA?
Has any other club offered for him?
We made the best offer we can currently afford for him and it was our first offer. (cant trade a future first ATM)
Brisbane need to satisfy us with the Neale deal before we can make our second offer
Go and vent on the Lachie Neale thread
Iva Bigun
Brownlow Medallist
As long as your then happy to pass on 5 and 11. Hogan > Neale
So you would prefer Hogan go to WCE next year for something you would imagine is considerably less than what was our first offer just to make a point??? - clever trade strategy you have there danster.Looking forward to keeping Hogan, kick us 60 next year, then picking up May the year after and then working with WCE to work out a deal for hogan while freo watch taberner kick 20 goals and finish bottom 4.
Why no make a offer? Who knows Melbourne might have gone back with something less then 2 1st rounders? Melbourne are the ones that need the trade to get May it doesn’t bother freo if it doesn’t happen till 8.25 Wednesday night
