Jesse White to Collingwood - Mike Sheahan 3AW

[Woods List Clogger]

So, where would this leave the Taylor Adams? I'm way more interested in him that Mumford or White or both.

Would it be Shaw? Or would we be banking on Daisy leaving and his compo pick getting it done?[/quote


I read today that GWS were waiting to see what was going on with Franklin re Adams.So I'm guessing now they will make an offer to Adams he can't refuse.

 

[THATSGOLD]

Do not pick this guy. He won't improve us in to a top 4 position and FFS don't give away a pick for him. This guy is an ordinary footballer.

 

[Shaneprice97]

Do not pick this guy. He won't improve us in to a top 4 position and FFS don't give away a pick for him. This guy is an ordinary footballer.

one thing he does give us is more hitouts in the ruck, and more mobility. I agree hes nothing special but he should do better then lynch (although i also said lynch should do better then dawes)

 

[THATSGOLD]

one thing he does give us is more hitouts in the ruck, and more mobility. I agree hes nothing special but he should do better then lynch (although i also said lynch should do better then dawes)

Can't Witts step up in the ruck? Grundy could pitch in and play forward and keep Hudson as back up. Plus we have Lynch. Could you imagine Lynch and White in the same team in 2014? We are looking ordinary.

 

[Frankenswan]

Can't Witts step up in the ruck? Grundy could pitch in and play forward and keep Hudson as back up. Plus we have Lynch. Could you imagine Lynch and White in the same team in 2014? We are looking ordinary.

White would replace Lynch.. as for Witts and Grundy they are both number 1 ruckmen, neither look great forward and Witts gets run off

White averages 1.5 goals a game.. Lynch 0.4

 

[Shaneprice97]

Can't Witts step up in the ruck? Grundy could pitch in and play forward and keep Hudson as back up. Plus we have Lynch. Could you imagine Lynch and White in the same team in 2014? We are looking ordinary.

Grundy will be our full time ruckman from now on (huddo will still play a handful of games). He is currently our most Mobile ruckman. And has great skills. If anything witts would be the forward who pitches in the ruck. I think White will be replacing lynch, i dont think theyll be in the same side

 

[Shaneprice97]

White would replace Lynch.. as for Witts and Grundy they are both number 1 ruckmen, neither look great forward and Witts gets run off

White averages 1.5 goals a game.. Lynch 0.4

Witts has shown he can play forward and is great 1 on 1, i can see him kicking 20-25 goals and doing ruck work

 

[Shaneprice97]

By 1 on 1 i mean in a marking contest, not when the ball hits the ground

 

[Woods List Clogger]

By 1 on 1 i mean in a marking contest, not when the ball hits the ground

Witts is actually pretty good below his knees for a player his size but still a year or two away,but you never know.

 

[jmac70]

Witts is actually pretty good below his knees for a player his size but still a year or two away,but you never know.

I would rather see Witts get a chance to learn that see White take his spot.

 

[THATSGOLD]

White would replace Lynch.. as for Witts and Grundy they are both number 1 ruckmen, neither look great forward and Witts gets run off

White averages 1.5 goals a game.. Lynch 0.4

White was ordinary in his last 6. Swans were horrible going forward in finals. White was the main problem.
Lynch had a good goal ratio before coming to Collingwood. Neither should be playing for a team that is serious about beating a team to win a gf.

 

[ksardog]

Whatever happens with white i will vomit if we pay more than a third round pick for him. The fact is sydney hav to hav a fire sale to be able to fit franklin into their 'so called' salary cap, the worth of the players they are looking to move on has dropped in value. Play hard ball collingwood

 

[Frankenswan]

White was ordinary in his last 6. Swans were horrible going forward in finals. White was the main problem.
Lynch had a good goal ratio before coming to Collingwood. Neither should be playing for a team that is serious about beating a team to win a gf.

Well that's it for 2nd rucks Grundy Witts and Hudson are all number 1 ruckmen.. and not good enough forward

We don't have a Hale

 

[Skin Expert]

White was ordinary in his last 6. Swans were horrible going forward in finals. White was the main problem.
Lynch had a good goal ratio before coming to Collingwood. Neither should be playing for a team that is serious about beating a team to win a gf.

Any grand final team has plenty of average players who play their role well, this is what White can be.

Embarrassing for you that you can't see it

 

[TradeDraft]

John Ralph is annoying as on Monday he said it will happen and yesterday said Highly Possible so will it happen 100% happening or not?

 

[Matthew_13]

Just got some inside word white needs some shoulder surgery

 

[TradeDraft]

Just got some inside word white needs some shoulder surgery

What about his Move to Collingwood?

 

[jimmy35]

John Ralph is annoying as on Monday he said it will happen and yesterday said Highly Possible so will it happen 100% happening or not?

It definately might be happening Dave as I understand it.

 

[morgoth]

Dave, if White nominates us he is ours. Sydney have to get rid of players for cap space ASAP.

They can't afford to play games with the PSD etc.

 

[Matthew_13]

As most know I have been told we are keen and he wants to come to us. So more then likely u will see white in black and white next year. But you never know what might happen

 

[TradeDraft]

Dave, if White nominates us he is ours. Sydney have to get rid of players for cap space ASAP.

They can't afford to play games with the PSD etc.

Guy above this post is right. I think he nominated us but nothing said Like The Buddy deal yesterday

 

[TradeDraft]

As most know I have been told we are keen and he wants to come to us. So more then likely u will see white in black and white next year. But you never know what might happen

Agree, until us Confirmed anything can happen and that makes me parnoid

 

[Wooljay]

I'd give Sydney an over the pants wristy for White and that's about it. There is no way that Hine will part with our second rounder for him.

 

[TradeDraft]

I'd give Sydney an over the pants wristy for White and that's about it. There is no way that Hine will part with our second rounder for him.

How you know this? Did Hine tell u?

 

[Jonno94]

3rd rounder or no deal.