Trade Requested John Noble [RFA 2026] - Requests trade out of Victoria

[kaiserchief13]

Noble and Future 1st for 13 and 41 is fair.

Why not just trade Noble for 41 then? Chances are Pies have a pick around 13 next year

 

[Iva Bigun]

Why not just trade Noble for 41 then? Chances are Pies have a pick around 13 next year

Suns taking the risk

 

[pressurepoint]

Back flanker who is not in Collingwoods best 22 when they’re all fit. Third round pick.

 

[kaiserchief13]

Suns taking the risk

So Suns think Pies will have a bad year in 2025 so they definitely want that pick?

 

[GCS in 11]

So Suns think Pies will have a bad year in 2025 so they definitely want that pick?

Pick 13 this year is worth more than pick 13 next year.

Pick 13 for Noble + F1 values Noble as roughly 28 or so since we could get F1 + 28 for 13 right now.

 

[perplexed]

Pick 13 this year is worth more than pick 13 next year.

Pick 13 for Noble + F1 values Noble as roughly 28 or so since we could get F1 + 28 for 13 right now.

Since that offer comes from Melbourne, who are likely to finish well below Collingwood, Noble would need to be worth minimum pick 18 to consider trading 13 for Noble + f1. This also makes sense when you consider the Sydney offer. Obviously he isn't worth even close.

Maybe Noble, F1, 36 for 13 could work?

 

[THE_GUN]

Imagine being involved in a trade negotiation with the Suns and you’re the one being laughed at. Impressive debut from Leppitsch with Craig Cameron basically begging to give them pick 13.

Post of the year

 

[CCurnow3votes]

Noble is not worth pick 13, more like something in the late 20's or 30's

At least your heading in the right direction.

20’s no way
30’s overs
40’s is about right.
45 - spot on.

 

[piesaregreat]

Amazing how invested Carlton supporters are in this trade

 

[Jeremias]

Amazing how invested Carlton supporters are in this trade

Given the possible ramifications it has for Carlton, it shouldn’t be that amazing.

 

[gutsroy]

From an unbiased point of view, feels like Noble for pick 13, Bailey Humphrey, next year's first rounder and Dimma's next born child is about god weight.
Might be able to be talked into a cheeky little swap of fourth rounders, but I've always been a soft touch.

 

[gutsroy]

Nonsense aside, this and the Rioli trade are both interesting because both have the potential to really skew what clubs perceive as 'fair value'.
Nothing against either, wish Noble had gotten a flag with us and Rioli has excelled in the role, but the asking prices of my mob and the Tigers seem crazy, even factoring in that they are under contract etc.

 

[CCurnow3votes]

Nonsense aside, this and the Rioli trade are both interesting because both have the potential to really skew what clubs perceive as 'fair value'.
Nothing against either, wish Noble had gotten a flag with us and Rioli has excelled in the role, but the asking prices of my mob and the Tigers seem crazy, even factoring in that they are under contract etc.

Rioli is a little over priced if reports are accurate - albeit he is a B&F winner.

Noble is a serviceable player who was dropped by Collingwood for finals/premiership for a reason.

Injuries gave him a regular game this year - when C’woos finished 9th.

Rioli & Noble really are worlds apart if your being honest.

 

[Merlin007]

Nonsense aside, this and the Rioli trade are both interesting because both have the potential to really skew what clubs perceive as 'fair value'.
Nothing against either, wish Noble had gotten a flag with us and Rioli has excelled in the role, but the asking prices of my mob and the Tigers seem crazy, even factoring in that they are under contract etc.

Fair value doesn't exist for the northern clubs, because they can give away top picks for the established players they want, and still get access to elite young talent by packaging up lower picks for points to take their academy graduates

equalisation is a joke

 

[gutsroy]

Rioli is a little over priced if reports are accurate - albeit he is a B&F winner.

Noble is a serviceable player who was dropped by Collingwood for finals/premiership for a reason.

Injuries gave him a regular game this year - when C’woos finished 9th.

Rioli & Noble really are worlds apart if your being honest.

No doubt that Noble is / was on the edge of the best 22, as is evidenced by sadly missing out on playing in the flag.
I was happy to see Rioli reinvent himself, but I don't think the degree of difficulty on either position is through the roof, to be honest.
Would definitely have Rioli ahead of Noble, though, so your point stands

 

[bradfisher14]

Amazing how invested Carlton supporters are in this trade

Breaking News: we live in a society.

 

[CCurnow3votes]

No doubt that Noble is / was on the edge of the best 22, as is evidenced by sadly missing out on playing in the flag.
I was happy to see Rioli reinvent himself, but I don't think the degree of difficulty on either position is through the roof, to be honest.
Would definitely have Rioli ahead of Noble, though, so your point stands

Interesting to see how this all unfolds - a big three days ahead.

Hearing Blues having a sneaky crack at Houston again.