Josh Caddy

[Thewlis Dish]

Hansen more valuable than Thompson?

Just no.

 

[scooby1279]

Geelong very close and confident in getting all three of Caddy, Rivers and McIntosh says @barrettdamian

 

[Fart Cummings]

Hansen more valuable than Thompson?

Just no.

totally agree

 

[Waynesworld]

Would Hansen be on the cards at all, guys?

If North are willing to let him go to the Suns as part of a Caddy trade, along with a pick of some sort, I imagine that would put the Roos right in the box seat to land him. Especially with Bluey saying in our local rag this morning that he would go for a tall forward who can pinch hit in the ruck. With Hansen also having skills as a CHB, that would be even better.

Article here.

What about Cam Pederson + Pick of some sort for Caddy?

Pedo can play KP or ruck and would fit in well!

 

[scottywiper]

If Geelong are willing to play the game and assist us in getting Caddy they can have Hamish cheap.
If not, I would not accept a second or third round pick for Hamish. We'd be better keeping him and revisiting in 12 months, when we know if Daw can play at AFL level.

 

[Footy Karma]

Geelong very close and confident in getting all three of Caddy, Rivers and McIntosh says @barrettdamian

I will fume if we give up McIntosh for next to nothing.

 

[Waynesworld]

I will fume if we give up McIntosh for next to nothing.

Agreed.

I am happy to see Hamish go to Geelong if and only if it helps us get Caddy. If not Geelong can GTFO unless we get something decent.

Surely Nth wouldn't bend over and cop a mid-high 30s pick for Hamish only???

 

[jclei]

If we dont get caddy we should not trade H to the cats. Simply because we are just going to help them improve to our detriment. There would be no value to us

 

[Chog]

Geelong very close and confident in getting all three of Caddy, Rivers and McIntosh says @barrettdamian

Will do nothing for gokangas' chubby

 

[Hard_to_Beat]

Geelong very close and confident in getting all three of Caddy, Rivers and McIntosh says @barrettdamian

He wasn't exactly that confident on AFL trade radio 5 minutes ago.

 

[Atleyafterburners]

Will do nothing for gokangas' chubby

If that is the case we should take HMAC off the table or play hardball.

 

[gokangas]

Will do nothing for gokangas' chubby

Its gone again. Three weeks of this crap? I hope we can nail this now or move on. Can't stand the suspense.

 

[Joey7]

He wasn't exactly that confident on AFL trade radio 5 minutes ago.

what'd ya mean??

 

[True North]

If we don't get Caddy and lose HMac and his salary we will be able to offer Lachy $700 000 per year. Everyone is happy and you can all stop calling me a hater already, he kicked 20 Goals in 12 games!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[Clappa87]

Damian Barrett on Trade radio basically said cats are confident of getting Caddy deal done but so are north and neither team are too keen to get the HMAC deal done until the Caddy one is completed. Sounds like both deals are quite way off.

 

[Hard_to_Beat]

what'd ya mean??

He wasn't as emphatic as that.

In fact, I can't even see those comments on Barret's twitter page.

Damian Barrett on Trade radio basically said cats are confident of getting Caddy deal done but so are north and neither team are too keen to get the HMAC deal done until the Caddy one is completed. Sounds like both deals are quite way off.

That is pretty much how I heard it.

 

[Johnny99]

Surely Nth wouldn't bend over and cop a mid-high 30s pick for Hamish only???

We will get pick 30 something as compensation next year, if HMac walks as a free agent.

So why trade him this year to the cats for pick 36, and help them win a flag and have no ruck back up if Goldy gets hurt ?

Piss off cats ! No deal !

 

[Thewlis Dish]

So selective tweeting then.

 

[GarnerSmash]

Its gone again. Three weeks of this crap? I hope we can nail this now or move on. Can't stand the suspense.

Blueballs.

 

[Mailman]

Damian Barrett on Trade radio basically said cats are confident of getting Caddy deal done but so are north and neither team are too keen to get the HMAC deal done until the Caddy one is completed. Sounds like both deals are quite way off.

....and it sounds from that like the Caddy and HMac trades aren't linked in any way. I don't think thats good for us.

 

[gokangas]

Blueballs.

Oh the memories.

 

[RoyalBlue]

So help me **** I hate trade month.

 

[Waynesworld]

Could someone please put a temporary ban on this thread until there is actually some news worth posting???

Otherwise we will end up with 200 pages of speculation from people who don't really know, and it will all go around in circles like it has until now.

 

[Tas]

Could someone please put a temporary ban on this thread until there is actually some news worth posting???

Otherwise we will end up with 200 pages of speculation from people who don't really know, and it will all go around in circles like it has until now.

Since when did we need facts to make 200 page threads full of bullshit?

It is off-season, there is nothing else to talk about.

 

[GarnerSmash]

Locked and loaded.

Locked and loaded.

Locked and loaded.