Jumper clash fails

[stevothedevo]

From the back, the only way to identify the jumper as Carlton is the sponsors. The average person on the street with any rudimentary knowledge of the AFL teams and team colours would rightfully believe it it a Giants strip.

I was outside when that game started but could still see the telly. I caught a glimpse and thought, well I keep doing what I'm doing because obviously the game hasn't started yet. Thinking they're still showing previous match ups. I reckon it was 10mins in when I thought, why the hell are they still showing GWS v Geelong match ups. So I went inside....... Oh I see.

 

[phantom13]

Brisbane v Melbourne really saved by the white shorts tbh. Maroon and royal blue v royal blue and red.

 

[The Mailman Delivers]

Not a mega clash, but this is where Melbourne ideally should be in NSW blue.

 

[Billy ray]

Brisbane v Melbourne really saved by the white shorts tbh. Maroon and royal blue v royal blue and red.

Yes works because no white on brisbane.
If Brisbane had white numbers thought it wouldn’t work.

 

[Billy ray]

Not a mega clash, but this is where Melbourne ideally should be in NSW blue.

And yeh an even lighter blue would be better.

 

[phantom13]

I was outside when that game started but could still see the telly. I caught a glimpse and thought, well I keep doing what I'm doing because obviously the game hasn't started yet. Thinking they're still showing previous match ups. I reckon it was 10mins in when I thought, why the hell are they still showing GWS v Geelong match ups. So I went inside....... Oh I see.

They’re just not even similar aside from both having some orange.

I’d prefer they not wear this match up in a clash jumper but even that wouldn’t be the worst clash we’ve seen. Let alone enough to confuse the two teams in a different game.

 

[Mitchell Madness]

So North v Bulldogs and Richmond v Carlton the two likely problem games this round?

North vs dogs won't be a problem if:
North in white shorts and dogs in blue shorts (don't give me the bs home shorts etc)

Richmond vs blues - if blues wear their white jumper- no issue. Although, it's a big 4 clash that the afl love to roll out the "traditional" jumpers and create issues with

 

[Billy ray]

North vs dogs won't be a problem if:
North in white shorts and dogs in blue shorts (don't give me the bs home shorts etc)

Richmond vs blues - if blues wear their white jumper- no issue. Although, it's a big 4 clash that the afl love to roll out the "traditional" jumpers and create issues with

So yeh neither of those things happening

 

[clarkoscluster]

View attachment 2032951View attachment 2032952
They’re just not even similar aside from both having some orange.

I’d prefer they not wear this match up in a clash jumper but even that wouldn’t be the worst clash we’ve seen. Let alone enough to confuse the two teams in a different game.

The Giants Charcoal is the one that’s much more similar.

 

[phantom13]

The Giants Charcoal is the one that’s much more similar.

People have been saying home. I’m still pretty sure I know which team is which.

 

[yodellinhank]

View attachment 2033069View attachment 2033070
People have been saying home. I’m still pretty sure I know which team is which.

Good. The two teams can wear those guernseys and the away team can wear the white shorts.

 

[Big Sauce 21]

That Demon away kit is my most hated in the comp. Not a fan of the blue

 

[Outtatym]

White short fan club will be celebrating hard today

 

[phantom13]

Good. The two teams can wear those guernseys and the away team can wear the white shorts.

Look, I’d prefer not but I still don’t think it would be the worst clash we’ve seen.

More to the original point it’s perplexing to me that anyone with a passing knowledge of football would have seen Carlton, in a navy jumper with a big white monogram and mistaken them for GWS.

 

[matthew_s]

Not a jumper clash…but using a red ball when Sydney play at home is not a great watch on tv.

 

[coldlunch]

Not a jumper clash…but using a red ball when Sydney play at home is not a great watch on tv.

no biggie when the SCG camera crew can't keep the ball in shot anyway

 

[matthew_s]

no biggie when the SCG camera crew can't keep the ball in shot anyway

It’s a hard watch.

 

[emuboy]

That Demon away kit is my most hated in the comp. Not a fan of the blue

I've always liked Melbourne's 'Color TV' royal blue jumper with red yoke. I think it looks great, but each to their own. If you want to see a really bad Melbourne jumper, check out their silver 'tin-man' jumper of the late 2000s, that is one of the worst ever.

One other great jumper I haven't seen in years is the Brisbane Bears' 1992-1996 jumper, maroon in color with a gold and white vee. You still see it being worn in country and suburban leagues, but I haven't seen the Lions wear it for at least 20 years. I've seen them wear new jumpers inspired by the design, and on occasion the triangular BB jumper of the Bears' early years of 1987-1991, but not the jumper worn at the time of the merger.

I would love to see the Lions play games against Port Adelaide wearing the second Bears jumper in one, and a 1980s/1990s Fitzroy jumper in another, as Port obviously never played Fitzroy or the Bears.

 

[Lion_LegacyXL]

Carlton should be wearing all white

 

[Father Jack]

This is ****ing bullshit.

 

[cactuscall]

To me Carlton v Richmond right now is a clash. Carlton should be in all lighter colours. ie in an all white strip. The inverse of their home jumper looks good and is a complete contrast to Richmond's black.

White shorts alone isn't enough to quickly and clearly segregate players easily in the run of play, tackles and scraps etc. It just looks busier on the field when Carltons white jumpers are hanging up somewhere unused.

Same as WCE v Hawks, the genius decision to have 2 yellow jumpers on the field. Hawks should be in white jumpers to match the shorts. Dark vs light.

 

[Billy ray]

Never gonna change until it costs them a game and a player says he thought it was a teammate.
If they wear it against freo and port then they need to wear it against Richmond collingwood and Essendon.

I just dont watch the games now (that game not even on free to air up here anyway today).

 

[Rustin Cohle]

Carlton are the problem. Always have been.

 

[rippersnipper]

Carlton are the problem. Always have been.

In fairness Richmond and Essendon are genuinely terrible for this too, except against each other occasionally. Collingwood are the only big four team who get it right every time in these games.

 

[KissKiss]

I did think Port looked good in all white (and no number panel). Made a great contrast. Amazing how better better it looks when teams do the right thing