- Mar 20, 2017
- 10,219
- 34,470
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Had to look up who Junior Rioli is. Didnt realise that because his father died recently for the next year he is to be known as Junior as a mark of respect. Thanks for letting us know.
List Mgmt. List Management 2022
- Thread starter Aphrodite
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Status
Had to look up who Junior Rioli is. Didnt realise that because his father died recently for the next year he is to be known as Junior as a mark of respect. Thanks for letting us know.
No chance he is picked ahead now after Youngs development.
Young was still an unknown.
I'd bet a pretty penny that they're not even in the same conversation.
If OMAC was the sole KPD in the run of games we would have been flogged.
2 full seasons in 7 years.
Last full season 2018.
History is a pretty good judge...and a decent guide. He is 26 and replaceable
Sent from my SM-N981B using Tapatalk
Which part of the almost two years he sat out completely did you draw these conclusions?
His body isn't up to it, it's why Melbourne let him go, and we've seen a continuance of it in his two years at Carlton.
I'll be disappointed if he isnt straight up delisted
Beyond Blue
Club Legend
- Jun 25, 2021
- 2,719
- 8,771
- AFL Club
- Carlton
He has played on the 8 quarters of football in 2 years with a chronic back injury that showed little sign of settling down and also derailed his career at his previous club. I’d say there is a pretty good chance he’ll break down again. It’s a huge risk retaining him. A tough decision either way for Austen.
- Aug 22, 2014
- 13,761
- 50,006
- AFL Club
- Carlton
I hope that a few sides that might be competing with us for Breust get sidetracked by Rioli.
Give me the older head from a better system who averages almost twice as many goals and score involvements.
That train has left I'm affraid.
Im taking Sam Durdin over Omac all day, got thrown into a baptism of fire with our injuries with a weeks prep and did very well. Seems to have matured, lets give him a preseason with Weits and Young and see what we have.
on footywire we have a lot of players OOC. Who do we let go?
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
That’s Biggs
Ronnie Briggs was aa Man U goal keeper. Alas that train has also left
- Mar 25, 2019
- 9,504
- 18,832
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Dramoth
Premium Platinum
He’d have to be informed that he’s now in the break glass in case of emergency category… along with Dow.
Agree with most and 4 - 8 out sounds likely, as list has some good depth now.
I think LOB re-signed to 2024 so list may be wrong?
Fitness staff may determine fate of Cuningham and OMAC. Cannot keep these guys on the list forever and we are not getting much output.
Potential replacements available may mean we keep one or more of Hayes, Fog and Newnes if we cannot find better?
Will be an interesting trade period
I think LOB re-signed to 2024 so list may be wrong?
Fitness staff may determine fate of Cuningham and OMAC. Cannot keep these guys on the list forever and we are not getting much output.
Potential replacements available may mean we keep one or more of Hayes, Fog and Newnes if we cannot find better?
Will be an interesting trade period
Young is well ahead of McDonald without doubt, our list contains too many players that miss large chunks of the season, we need to invest in some more durable players, Cunningham may get one more season, but l don't see McDonald being retained when we already have Durdin now.
May have hit his triggers anyway
Obviously the people paid to make the assessments will make the call on it...
There would be no point of Bigfooty though if we couldn't discuss things because we aren't the ones being paid to make the call. Scratch the ins and outs each week because we aren't actually on the match committee?
And no it's not a "wild guess based on 3/5 of FA".
It's a legitimate danger of happening. Using past information to make future risk assessment is not basing it on "3/5 of **** all"
The guy has litterally missed the last two years with back issues. Is it too much of a stretch to say its a very real risk it could happen again next year?
That is a bit too advantageous
I think clubs should get dibs in the rookie draft and the midyear draft for players on their VFL list (teams can select in the main draft if they really want a player)
Constant reader, infrequent poster, but for what it’s worth - my two cents.
- Trade Dow, would rather see him get a crack at it elsewhere to see if he can cut it than rot away in the 2’s. 3rd rounder probably the best return we can expect.
- Boyd is my first choice lockdown small back next year. If Marchy is fit as our 3rd tall along with a mix of Doc, Saad, Williams, Newman + Weiters and Young, we hold Plow and Durdin as backups and move on McDonald.
- Would like to see one of Williams/Saad played on the wing for a bit more leg speed forward of centre and better ball use to our forwards.
- As far as delistings go, obviously Willo comes off the list, I think we say good bye to atleast Fogarty and McDonald. Owies has reached his potential which should be depth only if we are to progress next year, on a small contract probably worth keeping in the VFL. Newnes in the same boat although I think he stays for some experience on the list. Ed may well retire but if he wants one more he’s going to be great for the development of our VFL boys if he can get on the park.
I’m 50/50 on whether Philp and Parks are worth persisting with. I wasn’t a huge fan when we reached for Philp in the draft a few years ago, I was a massive fan of Chad Warner’s 18’s year and now I’m more pissed he slipped well past our pick.
If Cunners can’t get his body right I think it’s time to say goodbye.
- Unsure where Silvagni really fits, the backup ruck role isn’t right for him and if he’s going to be our 3rd tall forward he needs to be kicking 30-40 a year and I don’t think he’s ever managed 20 before.
If Marchy stays fit, with Harry and Charlie reaching their potential as a combo we hoped for 4 years ago, could we now send Gov back to that 3rd tall forward role we purposed him for when we got him over? He could really excel there I think now with the pressure off thanks to H&C. Or we spend the summer trying to get Kemp into that role like he played on Sunday in the VFL.
- I wouldn’t be against a trade for Breust/Gunston to add some leadership and nous to the forward line. Interested as to what it’d cost. I wonder if a Dow for Breust swap could be a possibility?
- Would like to target some outside midfield speed with our first pick to compliment Walsh’s endurance and the bulls Cripps, Kennedy and Hewett.
If we manage to grab Breust, barring any draftees storming into the lineup early on, I’d like to think best 22 looks something like this
Boyd Young Marchbank
Docherty Weitering Saad
Williams Cripps Hewett
Breust Curnow McGovern
Motlop McKay Durdin
TDK Cerra Hewett
Kennedy Cottrell Martin Fisher
Stocker, Carroll, Kemp next in line if the four on the bench or even Durdin aren’t pulling their weight. Would love to see these three force their way into the 22 over season though.
Newman, Silvagni, LOB, Hayes, Plow, Newnes, Honey, Setterfield and Sam Durdin all very capable of playing a role if necessary.
SOS unlucky here, heart and soul but needs to nail down a role and really master it now.
Love all the conversation and going to try become more active around here.
Cheers guys!
- Trade Dow, would rather see him get a crack at it elsewhere to see if he can cut it than rot away in the 2’s. 3rd rounder probably the best return we can expect.
- Boyd is my first choice lockdown small back next year. If Marchy is fit as our 3rd tall along with a mix of Doc, Saad, Williams, Newman + Weiters and Young, we hold Plow and Durdin as backups and move on McDonald.
- Would like to see one of Williams/Saad played on the wing for a bit more leg speed forward of centre and better ball use to our forwards.
- As far as delistings go, obviously Willo comes off the list, I think we say good bye to atleast Fogarty and McDonald. Owies has reached his potential which should be depth only if we are to progress next year, on a small contract probably worth keeping in the VFL. Newnes in the same boat although I think he stays for some experience on the list. Ed may well retire but if he wants one more he’s going to be great for the development of our VFL boys if he can get on the park.
I’m 50/50 on whether Philp and Parks are worth persisting with. I wasn’t a huge fan when we reached for Philp in the draft a few years ago, I was a massive fan of Chad Warner’s 18’s year and now I’m more pissed he slipped well past our pick.
If Cunners can’t get his body right I think it’s time to say goodbye.
- Unsure where Silvagni really fits, the backup ruck role isn’t right for him and if he’s going to be our 3rd tall forward he needs to be kicking 30-40 a year and I don’t think he’s ever managed 20 before.
If Marchy stays fit, with Harry and Charlie reaching their potential as a combo we hoped for 4 years ago, could we now send Gov back to that 3rd tall forward role we purposed him for when we got him over? He could really excel there I think now with the pressure off thanks to H&C. Or we spend the summer trying to get Kemp into that role like he played on Sunday in the VFL.
- I wouldn’t be against a trade for Breust/Gunston to add some leadership and nous to the forward line. Interested as to what it’d cost. I wonder if a Dow for Breust swap could be a possibility?
- Would like to target some outside midfield speed with our first pick to compliment Walsh’s endurance and the bulls Cripps, Kennedy and Hewett.
If we manage to grab Breust, barring any draftees storming into the lineup early on, I’d like to think best 22 looks something like this
Boyd Young Marchbank
Docherty Weitering Saad
Williams Cripps Hewett
Breust Curnow McGovern
Motlop McKay Durdin
TDK Cerra Hewett
Kennedy Cottrell Martin Fisher
Stocker, Carroll, Kemp next in line if the four on the bench or even Durdin aren’t pulling their weight. Would love to see these three force their way into the 22 over season though.
Newman, Silvagni, LOB, Hayes, Plow, Newnes, Honey, Setterfield and Sam Durdin all very capable of playing a role if necessary.
SOS unlucky here, heart and soul but needs to nail down a role and really master it now.
Love all the conversation and going to try become more active around here.
Cheers guys!
Hit trigger last year. Pretty much zero chance contract would be negotiated with multi-year triggers for a DFA.
Despite his versatility, there are young players going past him. LOB, Cotts, Boyd, Stocker even Carroll with another pre season. Been dropped a couple of times over the season (3, I think) out of contract and we need list spots. Will be a bit unlucky, but the writing is on the wall. Vossy will be ruthless, can’t see him being retained, given other options.
- Banned
- #5,046
Good depth and versatile, apparently a very respected teammate and good for the group which may also play a part. Id be very surprised if he isnt retained.
TENACIOUS
Premiership Player
- Aug 16, 2008
- 3,533
- 13,530
- AFL Club
- Carlton
Would love to chase Zurhaar... Is a type I would love to get...
But that ship has possibly sailed now, with Clarkson becoming coach...
Brayden George, would be my next choice, kid could be elite... Been likened to Petracca...
But that ship has possibly sailed now, with Clarkson becoming coach...
Brayden George, would be my next choice, kid could be elite... Been likened to Petracca...
We need to go to the draft this year.
Acres will cost more than I think we should pay as I don't believe he is a free agent.
I would target Bruest and Ratugolea personally. Bruest is a bit of a no brainer for some leadership and is still playing good football. But depends on what the Hawks want for him.
Ratugolea is 24 and isn't getting a game. I see him as replacing the Casboult role on the list which we never did being a key position utility type. Can play Forward and Ruck plus has been looking good moving to defence this year. One year on his contact remaining so would depend on what Geelong expect back.
I really don't want us to trade any picks in the first 2 rounds this year.
Acres will cost more than I think we should pay as I don't believe he is a free agent.
I would target Bruest and Ratugolea personally. Bruest is a bit of a no brainer for some leadership and is still playing good football. But depends on what the Hawks want for him.
Ratugolea is 24 and isn't getting a game. I see him as replacing the Casboult role on the list which we never did being a key position utility type. Can play Forward and Ruck plus has been looking good moving to defence this year. One year on his contact remaining so would depend on what Geelong expect back.
I really don't want us to trade any picks in the first 2 rounds this year.
Chism
Franks & Beans
- Sep 7, 2008
- 38,932
- 38,753
- AFL Club
- Carlton
- Other Teams
- Cowboys/Pacers HotSpurs/Dodgers
A player like Bruest needs to be our No.1 priority as we need a cool head up forward who is a lethal kick that knows what it takes.
He is our missing link IMO and a 2 year deal would be on the cards if it were me. Hawks are going in the other direction to us and makes sense for both teams. Throw Dow in as a sweetener as well for him.
He is our missing link IMO and a 2 year deal would be on the cards if it were me. Hawks are going in the other direction to us and makes sense for both teams. Throw Dow in as a sweetener as well for him.
- Status
